marioguy wrote:
I read all that your wrote. You have some good points. It's not out of the realm of possibility that they are the same person. Gosho might be pulling off another Vermouth.
True, you can't rule out the possibility that Okiya is Bourbon until Gosho decides to reveal the truth.
marioguy wrote:
I do however wonder why Conan was surprised that Akai at the mall. That means he never thought that Okiya and Akai were the same person. If he thought they were, why would Conan desperately help him escape?
Conan knew Okiya's identity from the beginning, hence Conan knowing where Okiya lived and letting Okiya borrow his house. Conan might be surprised that Okiya has turned up at the department store where Jodie was looking for scar-Akai because it means Subaru has likely been shadowing Jodie and possibly also scar-Akai which might be dangerous.
Okiya following either person too closely is risky because Akai's plan was to hide his death from even the FBI in a "fool your friends to fool your enemies" way. If Okiya is tailing Jodie this closely, then Jodie risks figuring out Okiya's identity which, although not catastrophic, Jodie might not be able to convincingly act like Akai is dead after figuring out the truth and thus may inadvertently blow his cover. Jodie doesn't appear to be a very good actor - she slipped up in front of Ran with her magically improving Japanese. Also Hattori figured out she was faking after meeting her only once.
The other more serious problem is of course the B.O. Since the FBI are under watch, people watching the FBI are more likely too be noticed. Also, Conan found out that scar-Akai, a likely agent, is hanging out in the store. Furthermore if the agent is Bourbon, a good detective, then Okiya risks having his identity blown which is catastrophic. After learning about the snipers, Conan ran downstairs in a panic to create a situation to block the target from being shot without knowing who the target is. On seeing Okiya, no doubt the thought crossed Conan's mind that Okiya might be the target and somehow the B.O. figured it out.
marioguy wrote:
Even though there's no way that Okiya is actually Kaito. I have to point out that your argument against it is faulty. The anime isn't not run by Gosho. Hence why episode 5 and 13 created plot holes. Since the men on the train were just some random thugs. Conan didn't learn Gin and Vodka's names. Akemi had to come back in 129 to be properly killed.
True, it's not a convincing argument, but the animators have been good about sticking to the script for quite a while now. I assume that Gosho communicates with the animators to make sure they keep the details correct because it would be easy to accidentally mess something crucial up if they weren't paying attention closely enough.