Anyway, I wasn't blaming actually, I was defending. Which would be even more suspicious of being a BO member actually.
But my reason for defending Chekhov was, that xpon "doesn't like to lynch people without clues/evidence. But he accuses Chekhov. But the clue in the dream, that Chekhov could be Irish isn't valid anymore. And getting a PM, where he doesn't want to reveal his role is making him suspicious isn't a good clue either. He doesn't want to be targeted by Eisuke? Who wants to?
Targeting Chekhov because of that isn't better or worse than targeting Holmes.
Anyway, I don't have any good clues either yet. So Holmes and Chekhov could still be BO or a townie.
Also, I gave hints about my role too, but people ignored it O.o"
If youre Eisuke or a protector.
Kindly join our team, me being Sherry is like 100 percent:
Conia won't give Vermout a Sherry role because she/he will be useless for the Mob, because she's not tracking other guy.
Anyway, I wasn't blaming actually, I was defending. Which would be even more suspicious of being a BO member actually.
But my reason for defending Chekhov was, that xpon "doesn't like to lynch people without clues/evidence. But he accuses Chekhov. But the clue in the dream, that Chekhov could be Irish isn't valid anymore. And getting a PM, where he doesn't want to reveal his role is making him suspicious isn't a good clue either. He doesn't want to be targeted by Eisuke? Who wants to?
Targeting Chekhov because of that isn't better or worse than targeting Holmes.
Anyway, I don't have any good clues either yet. So Holmes and Chekhov could still be BO or a townie.
Also, I gave hints about my role too, but people ignored it O.o"
Looks like the people from Germany reason in a similar way
Anyway, I wasn't blaming actually, I was defending. Which would be even more suspicious of being a BO member actually.
But my reason for defending Chekhov was, that xpon "doesn't like to lynch people without clues/evidence. But he accuses Chekhov. But the clue in the dream, that Chekhov could be Irish isn't valid anymore. And getting a PM, where he doesn't want to reveal his role is making him suspicious isn't a good clue either. He doesn't want to be targeted by Eisuke? Who wants to?
Targeting Chekhov because of that isn't better or worse than targeting Holmes.
Anyway, I don't have any good clues either yet. So Holmes and Chekhov could still be BO or a townie.
Also, I gave hints about my role too, but people ignored it O.o"
Looks like the people from Germany reason in a similar way
Oh, Ms. Kleene you don't know that he could also have another role. Seriously im really confused. Alot of guys gave me roles, but im pretty sure most of these PM are not truth.
Anyway, I wasn't blaming actually, I was defending. Which would be even more suspicious of being a BO member actually.
But my reason for defending Chekhov was, that xpon "doesn't like to lynch people without clues/evidence. But he accuses Chekhov. But the clue in the dream, that Chekhov could be Irish isn't valid anymore. And getting a PM, where he doesn't want to reveal his role is making him suspicious isn't a good clue either. He doesn't want to be targeted by Eisuke? Who wants to?
Targeting Chekhov because of that isn't better or worse than targeting Holmes.
Anyway, I don't have any good clues either yet. So Holmes and Chekhov could still be BO or a townie.
Also, I gave hints about my role too, but people ignored it O.o"
Looks like the people from Germany reason in a similar way
You could even say, people from Bavaria reason in a similar way
Beastly wrote:
Callid wrote:
Kleene Onigiri wrote:
Oh, I'm 5%?
Anyway, I wasn't blaming actually, I was defending. Which would be even more suspicious of being a BO member actually.
But my reason for defending Chekhov was, that xpon "doesn't like to lynch people without clues/evidence. But he accuses Chekhov. But the clue in the dream, that Chekhov could be Irish isn't valid anymore. And getting a PM, where he doesn't want to reveal his role is making him suspicious isn't a good clue either. He doesn't want to be targeted by Eisuke? Who wants to?
Targeting Chekhov because of that isn't better or worse than targeting Holmes.
Anyway, I don't have any good clues either yet. So Holmes and Chekhov could still be BO or a townie.
Also, I gave hints about my role too, but people ignored it O.o"
Looks like the people from Germany reason in a similar way
Oh, Ms. Kleene you don't know that he could also have another role. Seriously im really confused. Alot of guys gave me roles, but im pretty sure most of these PM are not truth.
Not sure if I can follow you. But I think you mean "Chekhov isn't Irish" statement by me?
What I meant is, that Chekhov isn't Irish for 100%, when you (beastly) are Haibara. But Chekhov can still be another BO role (vermouth, gin etc.)
But seems like you don't trust the all people, that are PMing you their roles
Keyhole drawn by Yuri Iwamoto <3
Spoiler: Secret Santa gift from Commi-Ninja <3
A Black Organization Christmas Carol (need to fix the link)
Anyway, I wasn't blaming actually, I was defending. Which would be even more suspicious of being a BO member actually.
But my reason for defending Chekhov was, that xpon "doesn't like to lynch people without clues/evidence. But he accuses Chekhov. But the clue in the dream, that Chekhov could be Irish isn't valid anymore. And getting a PM, where he doesn't want to reveal his role is making him suspicious isn't a good clue either. He doesn't want to be targeted by Eisuke? Who wants to?
Targeting Chekhov because of that isn't better or worse than targeting Holmes.
Anyway, I don't have any good clues either yet. So Holmes and Chekhov could still be BO or a townie.
Also, I gave hints about my role too, but people ignored it O.o"
Looks like the people from Germany reason in a similar way
You could even say, people from Bavaria reason in a similar way
Beastly wrote:
Callid wrote:
Kleene Onigiri wrote:
Oh, I'm 5%?
Anyway, I wasn't blaming actually, I was defending. Which would be even more suspicious of being a BO member actually.
But my reason for defending Chekhov was, that xpon "doesn't like to lynch people without clues/evidence. But he accuses Chekhov. But the clue in the dream, that Chekhov could be Irish isn't valid anymore. And getting a PM, where he doesn't want to reveal his role is making him suspicious isn't a good clue either. He doesn't want to be targeted by Eisuke? Who wants to?
Targeting Chekhov because of that isn't better or worse than targeting Holmes.
Anyway, I don't have any good clues either yet. So Holmes and Chekhov could still be BO or a townie.
Also, I gave hints about my role too, but people ignored it O.o"
Looks like the people from Germany reason in a similar way
Oh, Ms. Kleene you don't know that he could also have another role. Seriously im really confused. Alot of guys gave me roles, but im pretty sure most of these PM are not truth.
Not sure if I can follow you. But I think you mean "Chekhov isn't Irish" statement by me?
What I meant is, that Chekhov isn't Irish for 100%, when you (beastly) are Haibara. But Chekhov can still be another BO role (vermouth, gin etc.)
But seems like you don't trust the all people, that are PMing you their roles
Well some, this is what happen, when you had was a BO member for 2 straight games, have an important role, and is on a complicated game.
Okay, all this PM stuff is getting way too complicated. Basic premise of this game is that the BO starts with an advantage of knowledge while the townies start with an advantage of numbers. The BO's advantage is that they already know who the townies are and who the BO are. So for the townies to win, they need to get as much knowledge out as possible. The BO wants to keep knowledge from being found out as much as possible.
In other words, townies, let's open up with as much info as we can. Sure, the BO can also open up with false information, but we have ways of checking up on them to find out if it's false. If we let them get by with saying nothing, they win because we have no way of checking them.
In that manner, I'm proposing we have an open list of who's who:
These are what people have told me directly or conia has confirmed. Townsfolk, let's fill this in! Add your role, and the role of anyone else you know. Don't worry about becoming a target. Sherry is the biggest threat to the BO right now because she can't be tricked and she can identify Vermouth. They're going to go after her before anyone else. And if we all work together, then we can start to suspect those people who don't want to add their roles to the list, because they're BO!
, 
, 
, 
, 
or 
are attached, that paragraph may not be 100% serious. Seriously.
Seriously im really confused. Alot of guys gave me roles, but im pretty sure most of these PM are not truth.
- Get your Detective Conan bobbleheads today! - 