conia wrote:
But that's a different moment. I don't know if she would have refused to go back, but sooo many things happened till episode 570 that I'm positive she prefers death rather than going back to the BO.
AICHAN wrote:
(for example i asked if you think Haibara would go back to the BO if she is threatened by them...)
You did? I don't remember that question...
Maybe I answered it before, but I think she wouldn't, even if threatened. The main reason would be Akemi.
LOLXD sorry for the mistake...it's the same word in french
i agree with Nyarl...even if she has changed a lot,i still think she would sacrifice herself to protect people she loves...before that was for Akemi and now it would be for the Professor and the DB...
Spoiler:
Spoiler:
mangaluva wrote:
"I've built a wall not to keep people out, but to see who loves me enough to climb over it."
[/quote]
AICHAN wrote:
(for example i asked if you think Haibara would go back to the BO if she is threatened by them...)
You did? I don't remember that question...
Maybe I answered it before, but I think she wouldn't, even if threatened. The main reason would be Akemi.
LOLXD sorry for the mistake...it's the same word in french
i agree with Nyarl...even if she has changed a lot,i still think she would sacrifice herself to protect people she loves...before that was for Akemi and now it would be for the Professor and the DB...
But going back to the BO would mean work in APTX4869 and again be a murderer. Conan has taught her with his values how awful is to be considered a murderer, no matter the circunstances.
AICHAN wrote:
(for example i asked if you think Haibara would go back to the BO if she is threatened by them...)
You did? I don't remember that question...
Maybe I answered it before, but I think she wouldn't, even if threatened. The main reason would be Akemi.
LOLXD sorry for the mistake...it's the same word in french
i agree with Nyarl...even if she has changed a lot,i still think she would sacrifice herself to protect people she loves...before that was for Akemi and now it would be for the Professor and the DB...
But going back to the BO would mean work in APTX4869 and again be a murderer. Conan has taught her with his values how awful is to be considered a murderer, no matter the circunstances.
If it's me or him/her, I prefer to ba a murderer than a dead Body xD
Anonnymus wrote:[...] Prof decided to rape a giant juice maker using a feather of ostrich [...]
AICHAN wrote:
(for example i asked if you think Haibara would go back to the BO if she is threatened by them...)
You did? I don't remember that question...
Maybe I answered it before, but I think she wouldn't, even if threatened. The main reason would be Akemi.
LOLXD sorry for the mistake...it's the same word in french
i agree with Nyarl...even if she has changed a lot,i still think she would sacrifice herself to protect people she loves...before that was for Akemi and now it would be for the Professor and the DB...
But going back to the BO would mean work in APTX4869 and again be a murderer. Conan has taught her with his values how awful is to be considered a murderer, no matter the circunstances.
If it's me or him/her, I prefer to ba a murderer than a dead Body xD
I prefer otherwise. And I think Haibara also would want that.
xGinx wrote:
If it's me or him/her, I prefer to ba a murderer than a dead Body xD
I prefer otherwise. And I think Haibara also would want that.
To me that depends on the one(s) I should murder...
I still prefer otherwise.
Really? Even if you either had to die or kill someone like, well, Hitler?
We have been through this already in some other thread, and my answer is the same: NO. No one deserves death and nobody has the right to take away the life of other.
xGinx wrote:
If it's me or him/her, I prefer to ba a murderer than a dead Body xD
I prefer otherwise. And I think Haibara also would want that.
To me that depends on the one(s) I should murder...
I still prefer otherwise.
Really? Even if you either had to die or kill someone like, well, Hitler?
We have been through this already in some other thread, and my answer is the same: NO. No one deserves death and nobody has the right to take away the life of other.
That's his Shinichi side talking xD .... let's ask his Gin side
Anonnymus wrote:[...] Prof decided to rape a giant juice maker using a feather of ostrich [...]
xGinx wrote:
If it's me or him/her, I prefer to ba a murderer than a dead Body xD
I prefer otherwise. And I think Haibara also would want that.
To me that depends on the one(s) I should murder...
I still prefer otherwise.
Really? Even if you either had to die or kill someone like, well, Hitler?
We have been through this already in some other thread, and my answer is the same: NO. No one deserves death and nobody has the right to take away the life of other.
in that case death penalty shouldn't exist...
anyway if people i love are threatened by a bad organisation(i mean if their lifes really are in danger), i would choose to join the BO...i think haibara would do the same...if only her life was threatened,of course she would refuse,but when innocent people she likes are involved,she would do everything to protect them... even if that means create a poison...
life isn't in black or white,you don't always have the choice...
moreover if she join the BO she could make the antidote for conan quickly
Spoiler:
Spoiler:
mangaluva wrote:
"I've built a wall not to keep people out, but to see who loves me enough to climb over it."
[/quote]
xGinx wrote:
If it's me or him/her, I prefer to ba a murderer than a dead Body xD
I prefer otherwise. And I think Haibara also would want that.
To me that depends on the one(s) I should murder...
I still prefer otherwise.
Really? Even if you either had to die or kill someone like, well, Hitler?
We have been through this already in some other thread, and my answer is the same: NO. No one deserves death and nobody has the right to take away the life of other.
in that case death penalty shouldn't exist...
It shouldn't, but it does...
AICHAN wrote:
anyway if people i love are threatened by a bad organisation(i mean if their lifes really are in danger), i would choose to join the BO...i think haibara would do the same...if only her life was threatened,of course she would refuse,but when innocent people she likes are involved,she would do everything to protect them... even if that means create a poison...
life isn't in black or white,you don't always have the choice...
moreover if she join the BO she could make the antidote for conan quickly
But the ones she is protecting would still be in danger. If the BO already targeted them, they can kill the ones she loves for any reason(i.e the poison didn't had the expected results) and whenever they want...
conia wrote:
Honestly, that's my Christian side, which I adopted for my life ,but not all of it...
I don't want to start a war or anything like that, it's just my opinion.
Religion sucks, they've killed more people than WW I and II I prefer not to believe in Heaven, and all those things. It's better just to live our life without remorse for what we've done, we do or we're going to do, just enjoy the moment
Anonnymus wrote:[...] Prof decided to rape a giant juice maker using a feather of ostrich [...]
conia wrote:
Honestly, that's my Christian side, which I adopted for my life ,but not all of it...
I don't want to start a war or anything like that, it's just my opinion.
Religion sucks, they've killed more people than WW I and II I prefer not to believe in Heaven, and all those things. It's better just to live our life without remorse for what we've done, we do or we're going to do, just enjoy the moment
It's okay, I accept your opinion. But I got a little correction for your thinking which I'll PM to you to stop the off-topicness