Mafia! Mafia! Mafia! Character Role Discussions

[Akonyl]

so you're saying that shinicih/conan/heiji are inferior when you ignore half of their abilities?

yes, I agree with you then, but it makes no sense to compare them like that.

[xpon]

if we talk about general then i still think that getting a police is better (and if we get akai / megure/shiratori it became waaaay better!)

back in the old round, getting the detective is really great! you will be really happy and became the pillar for the townie if you get detective right?

[Abs.]

It's pretty obvious the choice for the poll when it's broken down like that.  Megure/Shiratori/Nakamori (and other police who have investigate and arrest abilities) don't need to coordinate with anyone before eliminating a BO.

[xpon]

yes.. so if we play to win, getting a cop is way better then a detective

[Akonyl]

It's pretty obvious the choice for the poll when it's broken down like that.  Megure/Shiratori/Nakamori (and other police who have investigate and arrest abilities) don't need to coordinate with anyone before eliminating a BO.

power != ability to take down BO on your own, though. If Kir had a list of all the people who were BO but she couldn't do anything herself, she'd be the most powerful role anyway. It's not very hard to get town support as an interrogator most of the time.

In general, I'm always the most afraid of the interrogators+haibs because usually not much arresting goes on.

[xpon]

btw.. i still hoping that Sherry and Ai can be together in 1 game

[pofa]

as general hakuba is inferior to the other 3 detective.. but they are not strong role in this game.. and often they are suspected as GIN!.

I think this is on purpose. And nowadays, with observe and steal, it's pretty easy to tell the difference anyway.

[xpon]

i know.. but a detective is not the best role now days!

[Yurikochan]

Maybe a detective should investigate or special investigate, since Conan does say things that happen days before.

[xpon]

if you got a choice. to chose between kaito kid or detective.. which one you chose?

[breva]

Speaking of detectives, I was thinking on maybe adding another item to Kogoro?, he is very vulnerable with only alcohol

[xpon]

how about a Yoko poster book!

nah.. he dont own a car......


nor gun too.

[Akonyl]

Speaking of detectives, I was thinking on maybe adding another item to Kogoro?, he is very vulnerable with only alcohol

while I agree, he doesn't really have many other items, but that's why it was made that he becomes sober when his booze gets stolen.

Though, I dunno why he doesn't have car keys, tbh. he's driven in the show, after all.

[pofa]

Maybe he should have Yoko's panties. 

[Yurikochan]

He was a panty thief in that one episode.