Mafia Round 6 (Town Wins!)

[bluekaitou1412]

This is slowly becoming a boring game.

[Holmes]

I still don´t know who to lynch ...

[Kleene Onigiri]

@ctu:
Did you tell anybody the contents of your dream before Beastly claimed to be Haibara?

i believe he told me before that.. but because i'm not sonoko.. that's why we search for more clue

I feel ignored D:

@question conia-sensei:
If we get a dream, and it has "Beastly is Haibara" in it. Will it be true when he is actually vermouth disguised as Haibara? Or will it be false, because he's actually Vermouth then? (this is an example :p)

@ctu:
Did you tell anybody the contents of your dream before Beastly claimed to be Haibara?

Not completely I did not say anything about Beastly  b4 he admitted it

So you talked about your dream before making it public? Did you tell that person which player is what role? Like: "Xpon =  Sonoko, Chekhov = Irish, Beastly = haibara"? Or did you make a more vague statement, like: "I think Chekhov could be a BO member"

And why do you want to lynch Chekhov? If it's true, that Beastly is Haibara, then Chekhov can't be Irish. Although he can still be another BO member.
But you should have a good reason why you want to lynch him, since you guys (especially xpon) "don't want to lynch without clues/evidence"
And since you already told your roles, you should be able to tell your information to us freely anyway.

[Beastly]

So who are you? i'm Ai andi have a best friend Sonoko who wouldn't want to be name.

I'll consider telling you next day. The only reason I'm not telling you now is because I am worried you might be Vermouth in disguise. I sure hope you are not, because Vermouth Ai would be a fox in the henhouse. Assuming I don't get tricked, I should be able to sort out whether or not you are Vermouth (I don't know if I trust c-squares pronouncement that there is one, but I figure there might be one), if people take certain night actions like they said they would. If things go like I expect, I probably will tell you. If you know who Eisuke is, tell him not to target me because I really do need someone trustworthy to pool my intelligence with and I don't know if I survive another round of xpon's accusations.
Since it's my first time playing, I do have a question about Ai's role. Do you tell the GM during the night who you want to accompany or do you tell him during the day and then get results back the same day? It was one of the things I forgot to ask Conia when I sent him several questions in the beginning of the game.

Also, please don't tell xpon about pming me. If I get lynched because of that idiot confused person, this game is going to go to hell in a handbasket...

I'm a bit behind schedule in getting ready for work so you probably won't hear from me until tonight if you reply. I hope you figure out Ctu's alignment safely and if you are Ai, good luck protecting yourself from the B.O.

Former BO, you could know why that loooks suspectful.

This i what he said, there are also chance that Ctu is not really Makoto, as i PMed Conia if i got protected will he PM me. So if Ctu is a BO, we would also deduce that his friend xpon is a BO member, As he knew of a fake dream. Don't think to lowly of me, i'm just pointing out what i think, i'm still part of your team. Another thing is c-square, i don't know if he really is a B.O. but he should be Bourbon or Okiya, so any detective there kindly deduce that. What is weird about c-square is choosing to use his first aid to himself, when i'm pretty sure he wont be targetted because Okiya still have scent and can be still Bourbon.


So everyone,

65 PERCENT OF BEING BO:
Chekhov McGmuffin

35 PERCENT OF BEING BO:
CTU
XPON

20 PERCENT OF BEING BO:
c-square

19.9999999 percent of being BO:
nomemory, something's really weird about him.



Bluekaitou, is this still boring?

I say that we should get Chekov this morning, then i'll get more infos about the trio. Or you could also ask some infos to them.

Sorry team, don't think too lowly of me. And sorry of my deduction is far off, but i'm just saying what is on my mind.


I also said that i have a bestfriend so i can be protected, so BO you can kill me now hahaha

[Kleene Onigiri]

Well, for me Chekhov isn't suspicious because of that PM. Not trusting you blindly, even tho you said you're sherry is, is not suspicious. Because you could pretend to be sherry, or you could accidentally have teamed up with a BO member. Or another good reason to not tell you our role is, because you leak a lot of information

So suspecting Chekhov based on the dream (and since you say you're Sherry, you should know Chekhov can't be Irish) and on that PM doesn't make him suspicious for 65% He's as suspicious as everyone else (at least for me)

[Beastly]

Well, for me Chekhov isn't suspicious because of that PM. Not trusting you blindly, even tho you said you're sherry is, is not suspicious. Because you could pretend to be sherry, or you could accidentally have teamed up with a BO member. Or another good reason to not tell you our role is, because you leak a lot of information

So suspecting Chekhov based on the dream (and since you say you're Sherry, you should know Chekhov can't be Irish) and on that PM doesn't make him suspicious for 65% He's as suspicious as everyone else (at least for me)

IMO, That really looks suspicious


I'll consider telling you next day. The only reason I'm not telling you now is because I am worried you might be Vermouth in disguise. I sure hope you are not, because Vermouth Ai would be a fox in the henhouse. Assuming I don't get tricked, I should be able to sort out whether or not you are Vermouth (I don't know if I trust c-squares pronouncement that there is one, but I figure there might be one), if people take certain night actions like they said they would. If things go like I expect, I probably will tell you. If you know who Eisuke is, tell him not to target me because I really do need someone trustworthy to pool my intelligence with and I don't know if I survive another round of xpon's accusations.
Since it's my first time playing, I do have a question about Ai's role. Do you tell the GM during the night who you want to accompany or do you tell him during the day and then get results back the same day? It was one of the things I forgot to ask Conia when I sent him several questions in the beginning of the game.

Also, please don't tell xpon about pming me. If I get lynched because of that idiot confused person, this game is going to go to hell in a handbasket...

I'm a bit behind schedule in getting ready for work so you probably won't hear from me until tonight if you reply. I hope you figure out Ctu's alignment safely and if you are Ai, good luck protecting yourself from the B.O.

He wants help to get not trikced, he want me to tell who is him the next night, thus i think he was targetting me.

More to come later, cause ill be out tom

[Beastly]

The reason that Chekhov have a higher chance to be a BO than those guys:

Cause of no killing.

Try this everyone:

Araide healed Ctu<<< Dont know who
Ctu protects Beastly
C-SQUARE USING FIRST TO C-SQUARE

[pofa]

The reason that Chekhov have a higher chance to be a BO than those guys:

Cause of no killing.

Try this everyone:

Araide healed Ctu<<< Dont know who
Ctu protects Beastly
C-SQUARE USING FIRST TO C-SQUARE

Didn't you imply earlier that you suspected Ctu because you didn't get a PM from conia saying he'd protected you? (Or would you only get a PM if you'd been the target and had needed the protection?)

[Kleene Onigiri]

The reason that Chekhov have a higher chance to be a BO than those guys:

Cause of no killing.

Try this everyone:

Araide healed Ctu<<< Dont know who
Ctu protects Beastly
C-SQUARE USING FIRST TO C-SQUARE

Didn't you imply earlier that you suspected Ctu because you didn't get a PM from conia saying he'd protected you? (Or would you only get a PM if you'd been the target and had needed the protection?)

I think you only get a notice when you got protected and got attacked too. Otherwise you don't get a notice that you got protected by someone.

[Beastly]

The reason that Chekhov have a higher chance to be a BO than those guys:

Cause of no killing.

Try this everyone:

Araide healed Ctu<<< Dont know who
Ctu protects Beastly
C-SQUARE USING FIRST TO C-SQUARE

Didn't you imply earlier that you suspected Ctu because you didn't get a PM from conia saying he'd protected you? (Or would you only get a PM if you'd been the target and had needed the protection?)

I think you only get a notice when you got protected and got attacked too. Otherwise you don't get a notice that you got protected by someone.

Looks like we're back to Zero, but whoever is detective kindly do what i have told you.

Thanks.

[c-square]

The reason that Chekhov have a higher chance to be a BO than those guys:

Cause of no killing.

Try this everyone:

Araide healed Ctu<<< Dont know who
Ctu protects Beastly
C-SQUARE USING FIRST TO C-SQUARE

Well, first, let me tell you that if you investigate me using First Aid on myself, you will find out I didn't.  That's because I didn't use it on myself, I used it on Ctu.  I said I was using it on myself to make the BO think I would.  Then I could use it on Ctu instead without being too worried about being attacked myself.  So, investigate me using First Aid on Ctu, and you'll see I'm telling the truth.  You can also check to see that I asked if Vermouth was in the game.  If I were Bourbon, I would already know that and would have no reason to waste a night checking it out.

Second, as far as who to lynch, here are my thoughts.  I know Beastly is Sherry with 100% certainty.  And both xpon and Ctu knew I was not protected last night, and still I wasn't attacked.  That's evidence to me that they're trustworthy.  The only suspicious activity I have to go on is that Callid and BK1412 both voted for Holmes for the previous lynching with absolutely no evidence to go on.  That sounds like BO votes to me.

You might say that xpon and I did the same with our votes for nomemory, but if you think about it, which pair has been more open and honest here?  xpon and I have both come out and revealed our identities.  I've even given you a way to confirm that I'm telling the truth.  If we really were BO, it would be a huge risk to announce fake identities because someone else might already have those roles.  As you've seen, no one else has claimed to be Okiya.  That's because I am Okiya.

Callid and BK1412, on the other hand, have given no information as to who they are, or what they've been up to.  They've given us no way to test whether they're BO or not.  Unless they come out and be as forthcoming about who they are and what they've been up to as I have, my lynch vote is going for Callid. 

[Callid]

The reason that Chekhov have a higher chance to be a BO than those guys:

Cause of no killing.

Try this everyone:

Araide healed Ctu<<< Dont know who
Ctu protects Beastly
C-SQUARE USING FIRST TO C-SQUARE

Well, first, let me tell you that if you investigate me using First Aid on myself, you will find out I didn't.  That's because I didn't use it on myself, I used it on Ctu.  I said I was using it on myself to make the BO think I would.  Then I could use it on Ctu instead without being too worried about being attacked myself.  So, investigate me using First Aid on Ctu, and you'll see I'm telling the truth.  You can also check to see that I asked if Vermouth was in the game.  If I were Bourbon, I would already know that and would have no reason to waste a night checking it out.

Second, as far as who to lynch, here are my thoughts.  I know Beastly is Sherry with 100% certainty.  And both xpon and Ctu knew I was not protected last night, and still I wasn't attacked.  That's evidence to me that they're trustworthy.  The only suspicious activity I have to go on is that Callid and BK1412 both voted for Holmes for the previous lynching with absolutely no evidence to go on.  That sounds like BO votes to me.

You might say that xpon and I did the same with our votes for nomemory, but if you think about it, which pair has been more open and honest here?  xpon and I have both come out and revealed our identities.  I've even given you a way to confirm that I'm telling the truth.  If we really were BO, it would be a huge risk to announce fake identities because someone else might already have those roles.  As you've seen, no one else has claimed to be Okiya.  That's because I am Okiya.

Callid and BK1412, on the other hand, have given no information as to who they are, or what they've been up to.  They've given us no way to test whether they're BO or not.  Unless they come out and be as forthcoming about who they are and what they've been up to as I have, my lynch vote is going for Callid. 

Great reasoning of yours. Yet I have already told my role to someone in your group I trust. If you haven't received that information yet, said someone is probably off. So before you make accusations, first ask your allies if they know something you don't.

[nomemory]

Even though I'm glad that I got the lowest percentage of being bo I'm not to sure how I feel about being really weird, but then again it is true irl so it might show here as well. But to my defence I would also like to say that I've only gotten five hours sleep the latest two days 'cause my stomach hurts like hell very much, and I am also a noob at this game

[Beastly]

The reason that Chekhov have a higher chance to be a BO than those guys:

Cause of no killing.

Try this everyone:

Araide healed Ctu<<< Dont know who
Ctu protects Beastly
C-SQUARE USING FIRST TO C-SQUARE

Well, first, let me tell you that if you investigate me using First Aid on myself, you will find out I didn't.  That's because I didn't use it on myself, I used it on Ctu.  I said I was using it on myself to make the BO think I would.  Then I could use it on Ctu instead without being too worried about being attacked myself.  So, investigate me using First Aid on Ctu, and you'll see I'm telling the truth.  You can also check to see that I asked if Vermouth was in the game.  If I were Bourbon, I would already know that and would have no reason to waste a night checking it out.

Second, as far as who to lynch, here are my thoughts.  I know Beastly is Sherry with 100% certainty.  And both xpon and Ctu knew I was not protected last night, and still I wasn't attacked.  That's evidence to me that they're trustworthy.  The only suspicious activity I have to go on is that Callid and BK1412 both voted for Holmes for the previous lynching with absolutely no evidence to go on.  That sounds like BO votes to me.

You might say that xpon and I did the same with our votes for nomemory, but if you think about it, which pair has been more open and honest here?  xpon and I have both come out and revealed our identities.  I've even given you a way to confirm that I'm telling the truth.  If we really were BO, it would be a huge risk to announce fake identities because someone else might already have those roles.  As you've seen, no one else has claimed to be Okiya.  That's because I am Okiya.

Callid and BK1412, on the other hand, have given no information as to who they are, or what they've been up to.  They've given us no way to test whether they're BO or not.  Unless they come out and be as forthcoming about who they are and what they've been up to as I have, my lynch vote is going for Callid.  

I really told ya. BTW, looks like i'm going to trust you now. I'll give you one important role, since you would probably avoid killing him if you're a BO.

My theory is that:

You 3 can be BO 15 percent chance.
Callid,no memory,Chekhov yea sorry something's really weird about him and BK are BO 35 percent chance.
Add Kleene to the mix of BO 5 percent, cause all she did is blaming others, but can it help im also doing the same working with BO before lol. You will all know what im talking.

So yea, sorry for doubting you. I really misunderstand the rule because of Conia saying if i got protected i'll get a PM. Since even if you got tricked and unsucessful you'll still have a PM.

Sorry for jumping to conclusions.

So yea, i'll go with Bluekaitou my bestfriend?

If anyone have a better idea post or pm me cause i'm like the only one that have a job in morning.

[Kleene Onigiri]

Oh, I'm 5%?

Anyway, I wasn't blaming actually, I was defending. Which would be even more suspicious of being a BO member actually.
But my reason for defending Chekhov was, that xpon "doesn't like to lynch people without clues/evidence. But he accuses Chekhov. But the clue in the dream, that Chekhov could be Irish isn't valid anymore. And getting a PM, where he doesn't want to reveal his role is making him suspicious isn't a good clue either. He doesn't want to be targeted by Eisuke? Who wants to?
Targeting Chekhov because of that isn't better or worse than targeting Holmes.
Anyway, I don't have any good clues either yet. So Holmes and Chekhov could still be BO or a townie.

Also, I gave hints about my role too, but people ignored it O.o"