Mafia Round 6 (Town Wins!)

[Conia]

I feel ignored D:

Why? You haven't posted since the end of Day 1...

@question conia-sensei:
If we get a dream, and it has "Beastly is Haibara" in it. Will it be true when he is actually vermouth disguised as Haibara? Or will it be false, because he's actually Vermouth then? (this is an example :p)

Vermouth can't disguise as Haibara Kleene
Anyways: In that case, I'd have mentioned "Beastly is Vermouth". True or false fact, I reveal the role, but not the disguise.

[Callid]

@ conia-dono:
Actually there is no rule that forbids Vermouth to disguise as Sherry. Only the DB are save, but not Sherry, as she may be an adult (that's why her role is Sherry...). And, apart from the logic, there is nothing in the roles about that. Or did I overlook anything? Could you quote it?

[Kleene Onigiri]

I feel ignored D:

Why? You haven't posted since the end of Day 1...

I know. But people didn't get my obvious hint (besides Callid). Or they pretended I didn't say anything :x

@question conia-sensei:
If we get a dream, and it has "Beastly is Haibara" in it. Will it be true when he is actually vermouth disguised as Haibara? Or will it be false, because he's actually Vermouth then? (this is an example :p)

Vermouth can't disguise as Haibara Kleene
Anyways: In that case, I'd have mentioned "Beastly is Vermouth". True or false fact, I reveal the role, but not the disguise.
[/quote]
"Vermouth can't disguise as Haibara" That actually isn't written in the roles (I checked Haibara and Vermouth). But since she's a small kid, I would agree to that (since the DB's can't be disguised as either)
It should be added to Haibara and Conan, that Vermouth can't disguise as them. But not for Shinichi, since Vermouth can disguise as Shinichi (so you also have to tell correctly, whether you're conan or Shinichi, cos they would be different then)

@Callid: I checked, there is not "vermouth can't disguise as Haibara or Conan". Should be cleared then.

[Kleene Onigiri]

Just noticed, the role is "sherry" (like callid said) so it can be either the big or small version of her?

[Callid]

Just noticed, the role is "sherry" (like callid said) so it can be either the big or small version of her?

That was the way I intended it to be. Also, the DB were special, because they are innocent kids, and trusting each other is their strength. You couldn't really say that Ai and Conan are strong because of trust...

[c-square]

What we do know is that, because conia says Vermouth can't disguise as Sherry, she's not disguised as Sherry.

[Conia]

it says Sherry(Ai), so both of them can be deducted.
Vermouth can't disguise as Haibara or Conan, as well as DBs and BO. I'll be staying with this for this game. You can discuss it for next game

[Conia]

Based on A LOT of questions regarding roles, LOTS of holes in the roles section have been discovered. Do you want me to fix them now, which will give out suspicion points on some players, or you prefer a new,fresh roles list for next game?

[Kleene Onigiri]

I'm sorry ^^"

I guess you should fix them. Otherwise people will have false assumptions and that's bad too I guess? And pretty much anyone is suspicious atm, at least for me

the only ones I trust are:

Spoiler:

Akonyl and Schillok

[Callid]

Based on A LOT of questions regarding roles, LOTS of holes in the roles section have been discovered. Do you want me to fix them now, which will give out suspicion points on some players, or you prefer a new,fresh roles list for next game?

Actually some of them weren't holes, but some were used different than the rules say. For example, the rules are clear: Vermouth can disguise as Sherry, because she isn't an exception. The GM just decided that he will change the rules.

[Beastly]

Unless someone has a REALLY GOOD EXCUSE (If you have, post it in this thread) for doing it, I'm applying this rule from now own:

I'll be checking the Who's Online page whenever I can. If I catch any user that's playing Mafia seeing the Who's Online page, I'll come here and post that player's name AND his/her role with no exceptions.

I hope I made myself clear

Why? what will knowing who is online mean for Org members and why would you release that info because they are looking at it?

I'm refering to the Who's Online page, not the list of Last Active Members.

I knew that..still don't know why you would be so against they looking

BECAUSE IT'S LIKE CHEATING!
Private Messages are used so that only you and the receiver(s) know both of them are communicating.

What if i proved my innocence, i just looked at the Who's Online.


Jk...

[Conia]

People, I'm not sure if I'll be at home at 23:00. Most than probably, I'll announce if I can or if I can't post before 23:00, but just in case, if I don't post, I'll extend Night 2 till tomorrow Saturday 23:00.

[Callid]

People, I'm not sure if I'll be at home at 23:00. Most than probably, I'll announce if I can or if I can't post before 23:00, but just in case, if I don't post, I'll extend Night 2 till tomorrow Saturday 23:00.

Everlasting Night!

[Akonyl]

I could post the stuff for you if you wanted :V :V

Also, I would point out that while the role does say "sherry/ai", she's called the "shrunken scientist" so it makes sense to assume vermouth can't disguise as her even if it labels her as sherry.

[Conia]

I could post the stuff for you if you wanted :V :V

Also, I would point out that while the role does say "sherry/ai", she's called the "shrunken scientist" so it makes sense to assume vermouth can't disguise as her even if it labels her as sherry.

I'll consider that

Also, Haibara is the one who can feel BO scent, not Sherry