The scars are likely from either the Kōji case, or the incident 10 years ago that put Hyōe in a coma.Kor wrote: ↑December 7th, 2020, 12:24 amI think Rumi's scars are an indication she's Asaka and she fought Rum during the Kouji case. (Of course, the scars could have come from some other circumstance)
*Seriously, is there any explanation to that "demon in the darkness" thing other than Tsutomu being in the BO for a time? Cause in this case, he either infiltrated the BO for a time, or Gin once had to fight him and Tsutomu just happened to utter that phrase, or Mary and Gin just happened to coincidentally utter the exact same phrase in the exact same chapter and there's no hidden truth behind it.
I think Goshō did actually acknowledge this question—he acknowledged it with a typical non-answer answer, but unlike the Hyōe recalling no blood beneath Kōji's face issue, Goshō did acknowledge this point.
As recently as the time Holmes' Revelation took place, the BO wanted to get at Mary, and their knowledge of how Tsutomu looked and spoke helped them do that. If Tsutomu isn't Kanenori or Hyōe, then perhaps we should look at other characters he could be posing at. After all, these past three years have now had two major instances of characters who appeared in just one case and weren't referenced again... only for them to be suddenly revealed as major players—Karasuma, at the very least, was the original BO boss, and the old man from CoRaB is now masquerading as Kanenori Wakita. So maybe there's another character who hasn't appeared/hasn't been referenced for a while that Goshō's going to have turn out to be Tsutomu.
Gosho has already denied that there are multiple Rums, and I'd say the odds of there being a prior one (let alone a prior one who is still alive and now a major player in current events) have gone down with this reveal.Shinan-Kudogawa wrote: ↑December 7th, 2020, 2:59 amA very plausible theory; Hyoe was Rum and Rumi was Asaka, Rumi rebeled, and left the BO, Hyoe fought against Tsutomo and they supposedly died, Hyoe resurfaces as Kuroda rather than his previous ID as Rum, and while he went under a coma, another member of the BO became the new Rum in the time of the coma (Wakita=new Rum), which explains his Pirate's Spirit quote. Who could be very likely Tsutomo himself, and was undercover in BO, saw the chance after Rum's mistake to use his own ID as Wakita and rise to become new Rum to reach the boss.
Perhaps proving the description of 3 claims of Rum to be true; The feminine was his protege Asaka, the strong is the new Rum, and the old is the Rum that was left by the BO, who had to change his ID to escape BO and became Hyoe Kuroda.
It would explain the BO vibe of Haibara, except for Wakita. And the fact that Gin is wary of Rum having live enemies who know him (Rumi) and the BO's sensitive awareness of anything named Asaka. And the interaction of Hyoe and Rumi at the camp, it might make sense somehow..
But on the matter of who triggered Shiho's/Ai's BO radar in 987–989/909–910, it comes down to either Hyōe or Rumi being Asaka. Rumi was pretty clearly implied as the one, so the subversion of Hyōe actually being the one who triggered it would make sense—and this ties back to the potential subversion of Rumi being so clearly implied to be Asaka, yet it actually turning out to be Hyōe.
But that would also mean Tsutomu was the old man from Andre's Clash of Red and Black flashback. He really sold out his son there, then.Unlucky Devil wrote: ↑December 7th, 2020, 1:25 pmTsutomu can be Wakita, if you consider the reveal to be fake. I'm still waiting for the full translation, but the phone conversations could have conveniently been with two different people. The car details and the co-passenger details are different enough for me to be skeptical about Wakita = Rum. It seems like how Gosho tried to establish Jodie as Vermouth by the photos on the cupboard.
But what about the driver? He's the same in both panels. That points to the car being the same, which means the person in the backseat is the same, which means Kanenori is Rum.
I don't see equivalence, there. That was a single panel with a blink and you miss it detail—a panel that was the last panel of the last page of the end of the case.
This current reveal, though? It's at least two pages (around 12 panels or more) long, and by no means as subtle—this is a full-blown reveal sequence.
"Kanenori Wakita" being revealed to be the old man from Andre's Clash of Red and Black flashback is already a huge indicator of the truth—this is a BO member who gets chauffeured around, has only one natural eye, and he's now personally investigating someone who stuck their nose into Kōji case-related matters... a case that's considered in the BO to be a screw-up of the impatient Rum, and a case that warrants investigation by the BO's top investigator of anyone probing into it.
It's just not likely to me this isn't Rum, and I think many of the assumptions he isn't are based on only a few panels of 1,066 being available right now. Just look at the text spoilers:
And I also think most objecting to this reveal to the point of denying it as the truth is a genuine expression of, "I really don't want Kanenori Wakita to be Rum, and I'll have to think less of Gosho if that's what he's going with". While that's understandable, it probably shouldn't precede actually trying to make a logical case against this reveal being the truth. Now if the logical case came first and/or Kanenori being Rum isn't deemed a negative, then cool, fire away with what you got.- “rum is wakita, it’s confirmed,
gin got a call from rum, and it was wakita who called”
- Gosho's first drawing of RUM in the file is as a silhouette without detail to the left eye
- All his orders so far have been in the car while he was heading to the restaurant
- We see Wakita put on fake hair (originally bald), fake teeth and mustache while accompanied by a body guard and driver.
- Wakita is extremely rich and his car is a Rolls Royce
- Last page, RUM exits his car and heads for the restaurant after he disguises as Wakita, and he looks at MOURI DETECTIVE AGENCY
EDIT:
1,066 is now out in its entirety, and the car appears to be the same (again, the driver being the same is a major point against there being any misdirection, here). Nothing in this file decisively points to Kanenori not being Rum, and as far as I'm concerned, you need decisive, smoking gun evidence to actually argue there's a twist here, with the presentation being as clear-cut as it is.