Mafia Round 55: What Kind of Pokémon Are You? (BO WINS!)

[Kaito Lady]

congrats BO!
may I know now who arrested me?

[Fujiwara]

Thanks for GMing, BO Buddy <3 It was really fun!

And congrats to the BO!

@KL: Gio HSed you as Irish-Shiratori

[Kaito Lady]

Thanks for GMing, BO Buddy <3 It was really fun!

And congrats to the BO!

@KL: Gio HSed you as Irish-Shiratori

DDDDDDDD::::::::::
I knew I wouldn't be arrested for merely discombobulating T_T

[KainTheVampire]

Woo :V

Congrats

.... Whoa, so much text o.O *won't bother reading*

He is trying to save you. :x

I had just woken up when I saw it, my brain wasn't ready for so much text

[breva]

The BO slayed big this round. Congrats!

[Stopwatch]

\o/

Thanks for the game, PT (especially the phase change posts and GM log *_*).

[Giogio]

Wohoooo \o/
(Dang, it's over already.)
Great game, thanks everybody

Also, I didn't really expect Yukiko anymore at this point :V We thought about detecting her a few times, and SI'd a few people CC in prep, but Jecka stayed well hidden ^^

The GM log is cool.

[Memesu]

GM log?

[PT]

I'm really glad all of you enjoyed the game. I had a lot of fun with it.

That final post is probably one of the biggest ever on the forums.

I did learn from the master of long posts. :V

GM log?

Here. Aaaand, Roles and Actions are here.

[Memesu]

Thanks <3 *Gives PT a flower*

[PT]

\o/

[Yurikochan]

Jd- forgot about my game. *feels left out*

I'm sorry to everyone I lied too and I apologize to my amazing Bourbon for our fake fight. Please forgive me, fellow BO-chan. <3

Also Conia, you gained another adopted son and daughter.

[Paix672]

Thanks for GMing, PT!

And congratulations to the BO. You played exceptionally well!

[PT]

Thanks for GMing, PT!

<3 Thanks for playing!

And since I said I was going to bring stuff up, a few points that we should probably discuss:

- MORE COP ROLES. Should we give arrest back to Yamato and possibly to Tome? The problem was variety in this game. In a game this large, all but two of the cops that can arrest were in - Shiratori and Yumi. And everyone was expecting 4-6 cops, which means most of them are going to be in, which means little variety and potentially easier to guess based on actions.

- OBSERVE. As it is, a single person cannot both gender and age observe the same target. Should we allow, say Korn and Chianti, to do both (Chianti age-observe X, Korn gender-observe X)? Town can, because even if Jodie and Camel are both in, they're not necessarily going to ally and share their results. This should be specified in the rules.

- TRICK AND DETAIN. A line needs to be added under Detain and/or Discombobulate whether the trick goes through if the person the trickster is tricking is detained. I made a judgment called that it would not go through, based on the fact that Detain needs to look like arrest (and trick wouldn't go through if the target is arrested), but clarification in the rules for future GMs would be a great thing to have.

- DURATION OF DETAIN. The rules say 3 phases. Since it's not specified, I made the call that the phase the person is detained counts (given that actions would fail that phase due to detain), meaning that if they're detained on N1, they're released at the end of N2 (actions don't go through for N1, D1, N2). However, some of made it three phases after the initial detain (detained N1, then released at the end of D2). This should be clarified for future GMs so that it's consistent.

- SONOKO AND INJURIES. Right now, if Sonoko's BFF gets injured during the game, Sonoko also becomes injured. Why is this? I don't really think it's necessary. Discuss?

- AND A QUESTION: Why did we decide that Cross Examine needs to leave a notice? I can't remember why this was made to happen. V:

[Conia]

Jd- forgot about my game. *feels left out*

I'm sorry to everyone I lied too and I apologize to my amazing Bourbon for our fake fight. Please forgive me, fellow BO-chan. <3

Also Conia, you gained another adopted son and daughter.

That makes 13 :V Not counting Hayley.