Mafia Round 55: What Kind of Pokémon Are You? (BO WINS!)

[Conia]

Yes, it is super late to be a hero And if your role is so important, why wouldn't the BO kill you? They had plenty of nights to get rid of an important role, I know you have been talking to some people, and maybe I was the one with whom you talked most, since we have been in talks since Night 1, if I were BO, knowing what I know about you, I could have easily killed or APTX'd you, I'm pretty sure you wouldn't have sent a will if you hardly sent actions on most phases And I believed you were town but in my (perhaps desperate) connection of loose dots, I think of you as Body Odor, hopefully you or someone can prove me wrong, but I don't see anyone doing that so far. I'll be glad to clear some suspicion, I've got other names under the scope

I didn't talk with anyone but you and xpon until I first posted in the thread a day or two ago... and how would you APTX me? I only hinted at my action (on accident.. >.<).. and it's shared by several other people. you couldn't have guessed my role from it. unless you know who the other people were?

If your action is shared by several people, and we can be sure it is a night action, why would you only "hint it"? I see no problem with revealing a common action, for example like I myself did with you on Night 1. There's little to no reason to hide it, and I want to remark that in one of your PMs you believed in me as a townie, which further encourages revealing an action, although it is ok if you don't want to reveal it. In the case of guessing your role, it means you would have been poisoned. In the case I just worked on the hints of your role, killing you seems logical enough, as would happen with any important role. I also remember a PM from you saying you talked with people, not a person, before deciding to talk to me again, around the time you were Detained. I guess I will have to assume that was a lie?

Yes, it was a lie. I didn't trust you at all. You were asking for my role/abilities and you hadn't given me any of your own or even told me you didn't have any. You were expecting me to give you information without you giving any.. of course I lied to you and didn't trust you.

I am pretty sure I remember mentioning my action to you, on Night 1, as I asked for your ability in reply so I could check it while you could check mine too, ask other people about it like you said. I can see now that you never tried to tell the truth, right from the start and even now, after being injured which is preeeeeeeetty convincing to rtust my towniness... although I understand if people choose not to believe it.

@Iwa: Save that for the end of the game, please.

[Trickster]

Trickster...
EVERY ROLE IN MAFIA HAS ACTIONS

saying you don't know you had any is stupid... And not reading rules is worse, considering Magia is rules heavy and you should at least look up your role.

I've played mafia on more than three other sites for a while now.. On no other site have I played a mafia game where every role has actions. In fact.. on most of them, only a very few players have actions.

[Iwamoto Yuri]

Trickster...
EVERY ROLE IN MAFIA HAS ACTIONS

saying you don't know you had any is stupid... And not reading rules is worse, considering Mafia is rules heavy and you should at least look up your role.

I've played mafia on more than three other sites for a while now.. On no other site have I played a mafia game where every role has actions. In fact.. on most of them, only a very few players have actions.

Games are different, never assume they are all the same and actually read before you start a game. It might be a lot but you need them rules <_<

[Trickster]

I am pretty sure I remember mentioning my action to you, on Night 1, as I asked for your ability in reply so I could check it while you could check mine too, ask other people about it like you said. I can see now that you never tried to tell the truth, right from the start and even now, after being injured which is preeeeeeeetty convincing to rtust my towniness... although I understand if people choose not to believe it.

@Iwa: Save that for the end of the game, please.

LOL Nope. You never mentioned an action. I lied once, and it was to you, because you were doing things that felt scummy to me. Seeing as you're lying to everyone right now, you have no right to convict me on this premises. Please stop trying to lynch townies in the thread. Town has majority here (and thus has the power).. and we'd like to keep it that way. I'm sure you have a QT or something to talk with your mafia buddies tho..(I know you can at the very least PM them).. so go talk with them there if you're upset you got caught.

What does Iwa mean?

PEdit... yeah.. I just figured this one would be as simple as all the others. This is completely different however. I'm sorry I screwed up. >.< It won't happen again.

[Iwamoto Yuri]

Iwa is Conia's nickname for me :-x

I'm staying out of this topic now.

[Conia]

I am pretty sure I remember mentioning my action to you, on Night 1, as I asked for your ability in reply so I could check it while you could check mine too, ask other people about it like you said. I can see now that you never tried to tell the truth, right from the start and even now, after being injured which is preeeeeeeetty convincing to rtust my towniness... although I understand if people choose not to believe it.

@Iwa: Save that for the end of the game, please.

LOL Nope. You never mentioned an action. I lied once, and it was to you, because you were doing things that felt scummy to me. Seeing as you're lying to everyone right now, you have no right to convict me on this premises. Please stop trying to lynch townies in the thread. Town has majority here (and thus has the power).. and we'd like to keep it that way. I'm sure you have a QT or something to talk with your mafia buddies tho..(I know you can at the very least PM them).. so go talk with them there if you're upset you got caught.

Spoiler:

I got caught? That's news to me My theory and claims, trying to back them up with any piece of info I can struggle for, is that you are much more likely to be BO than Kain is, from what I know about you both. Seeing as hopeless said to lynch Kain, I'm trying to convince her and everyone that the correct lynch for today would be you instead of Kain. (Who isn't a proved townie, might as well let that be clear) And it's also my first open accusation in this game, you seem too deffensive from time to time.

Spoiler:

[PT]

Just a quick reminder to all: Dead people should not be commenting on the game.

[KainTheVampire]

Lynching townies is pretty normal both for BO and townies :x Just saying
Like half the people lynched are townies most games

[Yurikochan]

I am pretty sure I remember mentioning my action to you, on Night 1, as I asked for your ability in reply so I could check it while you could check mine too, ask other people about it like you said. I can see now that you never tried to tell the truth, right from the start and even now, after being injured which is preeeeeeeetty convincing to rtust my towniness... although I understand if people choose not to believe it.

@Iwa: Save that for the end of the game, please.

LOL Nope. You never mentioned an action. I lied once, and it was to you, because you were doing things that felt scummy to me. Seeing as you're lying to everyone right now, you have no right to convict me on this premises. Please stop trying to lynch townies in the thread. Town has majority here (and thus has the power).. and we'd like to keep it that way. I'm sure you have a QT or something to talk with your mafia buddies tho..(I know you can at the very least PM them).. so go talk with them there if you're upset you got caught.

Spoiler:

I got caught? That's news to me My theory and claims, trying to back them up with any piece of info I can struggle for, is that you are much more likely to be BO than Kain is, from what I know about you both. Seeing as hopeless said to lynch Kain, I'm trying to convince her and everyone that the correct lynch for today would be you instead of Kain. (Who isn't a proved townie, might as well let that be clear) And it's also my first open accusation in this game, you seem too deffensive from time to time.

Spoiler:

Proven*

[KangarooGirl]

... Stop trying to split the votes Conia. We have no evidence on trickster but we have some for Kain. If you don't think Kain is proven town then stop. Because town can't afford it. Unless you're not really town then keep continuing while I build more of a case against you.

[Trickster]

... Stop trying to split the votes Conia. We have no evidence on trickster but we have some for Kain. If you don't think Kain is proven town then stop. Because town can't afford it. Unless you're not really town then keep continuing while I build more of a case against you.

This is another reason I have a scum read on him. It's like he's deflecting attention from his scummy buddy by picking on the newb. Yes, I made a mistake by not keeping caught up on the game.. I didn't mean to at all.. RL hit me hard right around the time this game started... and I was barely able to get online on most games. My senior year of high school is an insane one.. and most things have been completely unpredictable.

[Conia]

... Stop trying to split the votes Conia. We have no evidence on trickster but we have some for Kain. If you don't think Kain is proven town then stop. Because town can't afford it. Unless you're not really town then keep continuing while I build more of a case against you.

Can you explain then why was Kain tricked? After 5 or 6 phases of non-existant tricking roles?

[KangarooGirl]

I'd rather not explain in public or especially to you since you can't think of it at the moment how a townie can trick a BO after non-existent tricking roles if you don't mind. Also you're taking it on face value. She could be lying. How does she know she was tricked if she doesn't hand in her own actions which is what it sounds like.

@Trickster: Don't sound so smug. We'll get to you later, mister!

[Conia]

I'd rather not explain in public or especially to you since you can't think of it at the moment how a townie can trick a BO after non-existent tricking roles if you don't mind. Also you're taking it on face value. She could be lying. How does she know she was tricked if she doesn't hand in her own actions which is what it sounds like.

@Trickster: Don't sound so smug. We'll get to you later, mister!

Well for starters, I asked and made sure she sends an action last night, with a particular target: Trickster. And somehow it failed, being discombobulated is the claim. I can't just think this is all a big coincidence, Kain could be trying to cover Trickster too, ne? Lots of posibilities are opened, but I believe lynching Trickster can be the less harmful to a very beaten up town.

[Yurikochan]

Well with 2 in jail, it's quite possible there are 4-6 BO left. I really don't want to bring up numbers in the thread, since the BO know the actual number they have left. And are probably laughing at all of us fighting. I haven't decided my actions yet though, cause I'm on the fence, but if we don't get a BO today, we'll be in BIG trouble. I'll shut up now and go back to being silent.