Mafia Round 27: Dead Men Tell No Tales (BO Wins)

[IdentityUnknown]

*joins without bothering to read anything*

[Cheesus]

Pencil me in.

[xpon]

Pencil me in.

[miikosan]

Also joins ;P

Nerf the town! Nerf the town!

are you gonna be inactive miiko?

I'll be the inactive BO Miiko

Jokes, I'll probably pop in every phase for 5 mins and send in a random action on someone and hope that it helps xD

[pofa]

I suppose I'll play, Parkur. <3 (Hope I'm town though, since the GM seems to think the town needs way more help than it does. )

(I'm all for nerfing Sherry and modifying the injure APTX, but also giving all the police arrest back and upgrading house search again and announcing failed arrest attempts and downgrading all the other killing actions and making the travelers more powerful? Maybe the BO won't have their numbers cut so much to compensate? )

Jokes, I'll probably pop in every phase for 5 mins and send in a random action on someone and hope that it helps xD

*hopes we're on opposite sides then*

[Vylash]

is the suspension announcement really that bad? o.O

And I suppose I can put house search back where it was

[Commi-Ninja]

*joins without bothering to read anything*

[Conia]

And I suppose I can put house search back where it was

Yes please

[KangarooGirl]

Parks, maybe reinstate the ones for the snipers. It used to be usable for them before and that wasn't a problem. You mainly wanted to curb Vermouth, Anokata and Gin because theirs made it really difficult to catch them at the end, right? People like Pisco, Calvados, Bourbon and the snipers weren't so bad.

And yes, keep house search where it was.

[Akonyl]

(you suppose you'll put it back? Thought you said you were putting house search back anyway )

is the suspension announcement really that bad? o.O

arrest is powerful enough as a tool for getting BO out of the game without giving every police officer a way to prove themselves that the BO can't reproduce, imo. Also, adding suspension notifications back in puts matsumoto in a very vulnerable position.

I'm also not a fan of travelers being made able to prevent their own deaths the same phase of, but I'm not really gonna argue it.

[Schillok]

Well, I can't say I am a fan of removing the killing ability from the BO when they are the last one left. If there is only 1 BO, things are already really hard for them anyway. They would have to somehow get rid of all other players except of one to win - and if they have bad luck that last one is a police and wins the game for the town with an arrest right at the last moment. (Or they get locked in a draw if it is a discombobulator or Araide and the BO is out of APTX.)

Otherwise... yeah, I will join.

[KangarooGirl]

But, think of it this way: if it's one BO against that many town, doesn't that mean the town has done very well in discovering the others and deserves the win? It'll likely only delay the inevitable. Last round, the town only had one mislynch and the killing ability made it so that it took longer than it should have to find Vermouth, despite knowing she was the one killing still.

[Schillok]

But, think of it this way: if it's one BO against that many town, doesn't that mean the town has done very well in discovering the others and deserves the win? It'll likely only delay the inevitable. Last round, the town only had one mislynch and the killing ability made it so that it took longer than it should have to find Vermouth, despite knowing she was the one killing still.

I rather have the end still exciting. If I (Sonoko) had checked tonsostuff for being Vermouth earlier the fact that 3 other roles which could not be disguised as (Ayumi, Mitsuhiko, Hakuba) were around it would have been 4 confirmed townies against Vermouth. Yeah, it took a bit longer, but the town had the better chances anyway. However, their win was not inevitable, if Vermouth was able to deceive everyone long enough AND kill those who she couldn't disguise as.

[IdentityUnknown]

EDIT: Turns out I won't have internet access...so I'm sitting this one out. Have fun, everyone!

[xpon]

no tonso... i havent manage to kill you!!!!