Mafia Round 19: Shake Up Christmas

[CTU]

So any lynching leads?

[Akonyl]

So any lynching leads?

read the thread

[CTU]

So any lynching leads?

read the thread

Fine...Tho it will take me a wile to catch up

[Akemi~chan]

? confused

[Detective Tommy]

About what?

[Akemi~chan]

everything on here. since i died i stopped coming on. i just now came on

[Detective Tommy]

Eh, maybe you should try reading everything if you want to understand.

[Akemi~chan]

....oyu have no idea how i hate readin backwards....noway

[Schillok]

Well, after thinking for a while...

Since no townie died last night, it seems reasonable that Eve is telling the truth - that she was the one attacked. It makes little sense for the BO to kill their own members, no matter how suspicious they already are. So Anokata was likely killed by the criminal.
Anyway: If Eve was attacked, it means she is town. So that is one point speaking for her.
There is no reason for a townie to try to get another townie getting lynched. So the suggestion to go after Eve by Akonyl makes no sense.

So rather than voting against a player very likely being town, it is much better to vote against the player who tries to get that player lynched. At least this is what I think.

[PT]

Anyone like my new sig and avatar?

I do, though it confused me at first.

Anyway, I'll go with lynching Ako-chan for today and then if he turns out to be town... well, I'll probably lynch Eve next, since she's the one pushing for his lynching. But I guess we'll have to see what happens.

[Detective Tommy]

Anyone like my new sig and avatar?

I do, though it confused me at first.

What part confused you?

[PT]

The part where you have a new avatar. I didn't get much sleep last night and it's been a long day, forgive me for being brain dead.

[Akonyl]

There is no reason for a townie to try to get another townie getting lynched. So the suggestion to go after Eve by Akonyl makes no sense.

So rather than voting against a player very likely being town, it is much better to vote against the player who tries to get that player lynched. At least this is what I think.

my point is that her want to get me lynched over a situation that she basically forced me into in the first place is nothing short of suspicious, and is worthy of a lynching.

Anyway, I'll go with lynching Ako-chan for today and then if he turns out to be town... well, I'll probably lynch Eve next, since she's the one pushing for his lynching. But I guess we'll have to see what happens.

out of curiosity, as someone other than xpon/eve, what about their side of the argument makes sense to you? I've already refuted all their points basically, and they don't bother defending themselves.

And rather than "seeing what happens", I'd much rather you just lynch her the next day, as she's probably betting on peoples' short memories in this game, and pointing them at a different target than herself anyway. :V

Not to mention, DT's mention of balancing sucking makes me feel like they're an unlucky BO/BO lover pair or something, as if I was a BO, 2 BO vs 1 town killed isn't really a horrible balance issue.

[PT]

It's not so much about either of their arguments making much sense, but it seems like the general consensus is that we're lynching you today, so rather than go against it and try to lynch Eve instead, when probably it'll end up being futile, I'll go ahead and lynch you now.

And yes, I pretty much plan on lynching Eve next if you turn up town, but if something goes really screwy during this phase or the next, then it might change. So like I said, we'll just have to see.

[Akonyl]

so you only want to lynch me today because you want to go with the flow? How fabulous. D:

Also, sounds sorta like a BO thing trying not to stand out. :V