Mafia Round 18: Jungle Bells (Town wins)

[Dus]

The problem with Sherry is that it would tell the BO right away that Ai isn't in the game. I know it doesn't make sense canon-wise but we also have Akai and Okiya at the same time.

I think I agree with the changes proposed for both Kir and Kogoro and Calvados can't cover poisoning anymore. Don't know why I did that in the first place.

Nakamori has discovered Kid's disguise a few times, but he has never arrested him. Maybe I will make it a Night-only ability, depending on how many people are going to join in the end.

[Eve]

@ the Title... It's Jung now? XD lol

[Dus]

Problem?
Also: Jirikuchi added. Discuss. (How is he spelled, anyway?

[Eve]

Nuthing XD LOL

Oh, I think I have to sit out in this round as well , just got a call informing me about [something] that will make me busy for the next two weeks DX

[Grawwbear]

Jirokichi.

[Dus]

Nuthing XD LOL

Oh, I think I have to sit out in this round as well , just got a call informing me about [something] that will make me busy for the next two weeks DX

D:

[Schillok]

The problem with Sherry is that it would tell the BO right away that Ai isn't in the game.

Well, that is fine to me. What are they going to do now? They can hardly pretend to be Haibara and start following people... Unless they disguise as Kazuha I guess, which is a bad disguise and a single observation will still tell the difference. So, not much of a difference. Just that they can feel a bit more save.

And if Haibara is in the game (and killed) the town will know there is no Sherry in the game as well. With little additional advantages. Which should make it fair...

I know it doesn't make sense canon-wise but we also have Akai and Okiya at the same time.

Because they actually might really be two different people. It is not known yet if he he is Akai, Bourbon or someone completely different.
We also have some dead members within the BO. But shh, don't tell them.

I think I agree with the changes proposed for both Kir and Kogoro and Calvados can't cover poisoning anymore. Don't know why I did that in the first place.

Question remains if an arrested Sherry who still has APTX remaining will have those confiscated and thus given to Satô or Okiya.
The whole "confiscation" thing seems strange to me anyway... so maybe you just remove the rule in the first place. Satô with APTX makes no sense to me...

Nakamori has discovered Kid's disguise a few times, but he has never arrested him. Maybe I will make it a Night-only ability, depending on how many people are going to join in the end.

Well, but this time he can go and arrest him right during the next phase. Because he will have all the information he needs for that.



@Jirokichi: I still think the Gems should have more use than just being a nice distraction to thieves. Otherwise his role is almost useless once Akemi is out of the game (if she was in the game in the first place).

[Abs.]

so on the forum index, this topic is abbreviated as:
Re: Mafia Round 18: Jing...

why are we trying to summon Jing? D:

Yeah I get a shock every time I see that D:

Ah, it's been changed.  Hooray, I say!

Btw the reason why Satou gets APTX is that her character is one who can be driven to go outside of the rules for the sake of vengeance, etc.  Besides, most of the female roles are underpowered vs. the male roles, so. 

[Dus]

When the hell was confiscate added? Was that me?

I don't know, but there was some aversion towards the BO knowing that there's no Haibara, but I would be okay with having only one of them in the game.

[Abs.]

No it was way back when I was GM.  It's never been used, but it was supposed to be more of a deterrent for the BO to APTX indiscriminately.  As in, be careful who you have doing the APTXing, because they might end up being arrested and then the game will get more dangerous for you.

[Holmes]

I shall play.

[pofa]

Nuthing XD LOL

Oh, I think I have to sit out in this round as well , just got a call informing me about [something] that will make me busy for the next two weeks DX

*wants to play with Eve again*

Rather than the police, I feel like it would make more sense for the FBI agents to get the confiscated APTX, since they sort of play by their own rules. But I'm not too much in favor of confiscate anyway.

[Abs.]

@pofa

But it's never been used/tested yet    Give it a chance!  You may love it when you are a townie with a confiscated APTX and you are like, "Yay, we can get rid of two BO this phase instead of just lynching one!"  It also solves some problems of "Who to lynch first?" and can act as an Identify XD  (albeit with consequences)

[pofa]

@pofa

But it's never been used/tested yet    Give it a chance!  You may love it when you are a townie with a confiscated APTX and you are like, "Yay, we can get rid of two BO this phase instead of just lynching one!"  It also solves some problems of "Who to lynch first?" and can act as an Identify XD  (albeit with consequences)

Well, it's up to the GM. And I know I'd love it in that situation; that's why I'm not in favor of it. XD Because it sounds like it would over-power the town if it happened, especially late in the game. But it would be interesting too, so I won't be mad or anything if Dus leaves it in.

[Eve]

Nuthing XD LOL

Oh, I think I have to sit out in this round as well , just got a call informing me about [something] that will make me busy for the next two weeks DX

*wants to play with Eve again*

*wants to play with pofa again, too*