Mafia Round 16 - Yarrharr~ (BO wins!)

[Akonyl]

Even though we found the hints... there was no guarantee that the lovers would have told the truth. Just the same way they could have wanted us to lynch an innocent to end the game more quickly.
Following Breva's will, who was a confirmed townie was a logical choice at that point. The wrong choice as it turned out, but we could hardly know that in advance.

if it was just edo's will, true, however shin_ichi's will also just said "sherlock3, that is all", so combined it was pretty trustworthy info that sherlock was BO.

and like other people, I can open em up just fine, so I dunno what's up with your pdfs :/

[Kleene Onigiri]

To be fair, Holmes seemed to have missed Edo's will and the blatant "hints" toward Sherlock = Anokata, and I may or may not have PMed him hinting that I thought DT was BO. And since Schillok followed Holmes....

Even though we found the hints... there was no guarantee that the lovers would have told the truth. Just the same way they could have wanted us to lynch an innocent to end the game more quickly.
Following Breva's will, who was a confirmed townie was a logical choice at that point. The wrong choice as it turned out, but we could hardly know that in advance.


About the pdf files: Kleene there is on / too much after the http:
That's why I couldn't open it. (And still can't without correcting it.)

Strange, there was really 1 / too much, but everyone, including me could still open it :V
Computers are just strange, aliens!

Well, fixed it now

[Akonyl]

Strange, there was really 1 / too much, but everyone, including me could still open it :V
Computers are just strange, aliens!

Well, fixed it now

so there were 3 /'s after the http? I guess maybe the browser most of us use just chopped it off from the link or something, just schillok's didn't.

[Schillok]

if it was just edo's will, true, however shin_ichi's will also just said "sherlock3, that is all", so combined it was pretty trustworthy info that sherlock was BO.

and like other people, I can open em up just fine, so I dunno what's up with your pdfs :/

Why should I trust the other lover more than the first one?
Just like for your BO guys, those two were also the towns enemies. They had no specific reason to help a particular side.

But yes, I would have followed the hint. But that would have required to convince everyone of it and when Holmes had chosen to go for DT like suggested in Brevas will I had no real reason to object. DT not defending himself sealed everything.

Strange, there was really 1 / too much, but everyone, including me could still open it :V
Computers are just strange, aliens!

Well, fixed it now

so there were 3 /'s after the http? I guess maybe the browser most of us use just chopped it off from the link or something, just schillok's didn't.

Well, my browser is well trained. It only does what I tell him. And if there is on slash too much, it still tries to comply to my order.

[Akonyl]

Why should I trust the other lover more than the first one?
Just like for your BO guys, those two were also the towns enemies. They had no specific reason to help a particular side.

the lovers were edo and kain, shin_ichi wasn't one of the lovers, just kobayashi. So, she would have no reason to lie about sherlock in her will.

[nomemory]

if it was just edo's will, true, however shin_ichi's will also just said "sherlock3, that is all", so combined it was pretty trustworthy info that sherlock was BO.

and like other people, I can open em up just fine, so I dunno what's up with your pdfs :/

Why should I trust the other lover more than the first one?
Just like for your BO guys, those two were also the towns enemies. They had no specific reason to help a particular side.

But yes, I would have followed the hint. But that would have required to convince everyone of it and when Holmes had chosen to go for DT like suggested in Brevas will I had no real reason to object. DT not defending himself sealed everything.

Shin wasn't the second lover, Kain was. Shin was just a regular townie.

[Schillok]

Too many dead people in a single day then.

Still, following Breva made more sense to me at that time. I mean... if it had worked then Sherlock was only a matter of time. And we would have had the chance to make sure.
But yeah, it was the wrong choice. Shouldn't have heard to the majority and tried to convince everyone instead instead of taking the "safe" route.

[Kleene Onigiri]

all action + hints are up \o/

I post my suggestions about rules later :V *sleepy*


also, the hints are totally strange and way too hard :x But that was intended! D: Since the BO and the town had some leads already :V

[Abs.]

Re: Hints/Decisions

I figured out what made the right answer vs. wrong answer for the first one (drink with Kleene): Underage (Heiji, Makoto) vs. Not underage

However I couldn't figure out what made the right answer vs. wrong answer for the others...

Well except for that of course I had to help my daughterStriprice XD

[Akonyl]

Re: Hints/Decisions

I figured out what made the right answer vs. wrong answer for the first one (drink with Kleene): Underage (Heiji, Makoto) vs. Not underage

However I couldn't figure out what made the right answer vs. wrong answer for the others...

Well except for that of course I had to help my daughterStriprice XD

the choices were all random apparently, so for the bar it was just coincidence

and D:

[Kleene Onigiri]

It was random actually :V Lol XD

[Abs.]

It was random actually :V Lol XD

...!



THERE IS NO RIGHT ANSWER!!!!!!!!!!  D: D: D:

[Commi-Ninja]

It'll be okay, Abs..

[Eve]

It'll be okay, Abs..

Considering he died, not so much XD lol

[Akonyl]

It'll be okay, Abs..

Considering he died, not so much XD lol

now, now. He was never actually stated as dying in the story. Maybe he's spun his way to a deserted island.