Mafia Round 16 - Yarrharr~ (BO wins!)

[Vylash]

i did pair all the legal couple

Fairly certain PiscoxAyumi isn't legal at all.

i'm sure we can get around that with parental consent 

[xpon]

BTW.. Edogawa kill my beloved Ai chan right?

[Yurikochan]

i did pair all the legal couple

Fairly certain PiscoxAyumi isn't legal at all.

i'm sure we can get around that with parental consent 

The same goes for Makoto/Genta. That would be scary. How would they fall in love even...?

[Vylash]

i did pair all the legal couple

Fairly certain PiscoxAyumi isn't legal at all.

i'm sure we can get around that with parental consent 

The same goes for Makoto/Genta. That would be scary. How would they fall in love even...?

Makoto buys genta a lot of food?

[Yurikochan]

i did pair all the legal couple

Fairly certain PiscoxAyumi isn't legal at all.

i'm sure we can get around that with parental consent 

The same goes for Makoto/Genta. That would be scary. How would they fall in love even...?

Makoto buys genta a lot of food?

I wonder if I really did make that FI mistake subconciously or if my phone did change school to food.

Kleene, I love you. ^^ Your pm made me feel amazing thanks for believing in the fat kid that loves cake.

[PT]

i'm sure we can get around that with parental consent 

What kind of parent would consent to their seven-year-old daughter being with an old man?

...then again, didn't we decide Abs.' parents are Conia and xpon awhile back...?

[xpon]

i dont remember it?

[PT]

Pretty sure you're just repressing the memories, xpon.

[Kleene Onigiri]

I think the GM should just heavily edit a will of a treacherous lover.

At that point, it didn't matter. That's why I didn't edit it at all

that is why the town should use announcer!!!!

just look at the slow mafia

Can't comment on a running game.

But you can never be sure if the announcer is BO or not. Or... that he lives long enough once he is proven.

I think the main difference between normal, slow, and mini mafia is the amount of time you have to think about stuff and to analyze the behaviour of your allies. That's why BO has won almost all mini mafias and why town will probably win slow mafia, as far as I can tell.

@PT: So you're saying we won because we're awesome? Awww...
But yeah, there were several fairly inactive townies. Meme and sakina come to mind. And you didn't seem all that active either, schillok.

Can't tell much about slo mafia either. But Imo the rules itself in that game are unbalanced.

well  with this.. we will need a interesting new round.. ( just like schillok's Personal Objective)

Meaning my round wasn't interesting? I see.
Obviously, the fact that the town lost is totally my fault. Even tho the game was balanced at the beginning. Which I can totally point out.
But people don't like to wait and see what actions were actually done.
Nooo~ Since it's, in any way whatever I show, totally my fault. People being inactive is also my fault.

[Vylash]

i think he meant that he wants the next round to be interesting as well

[nomemory]

well  with this.. we will need a interesting new round.. ( just like schillok's Personal Objective)

Meaning my round wasn't interesting? I see.
Obviously, the fact that the town lost is totally my fault. Even tho the game was balanced at the beginning. Which I can totally point out.
But people don't like to wait and see what actions were actually done.
Nooo~ Since it's, in any way whatever I show, totally my fault. People being inactive is also my fault.

Don't take it to heart Kleene. I think you did a great job.

[Kleene Onigiri]

Your way makes sense, what about the others? They have been using the same method?

my method (when using random.org) was to make a list of roles, and a list of players, number each list, and then choose random numbers from each list and pair the role to the player, and if it was invalid for one reason or another, I just did it again.

But yes, being DB 3x in a row, followed by BO 4x in a row (two of which are calvados) is D:

Hmmmm.... I think maybe GM should try a set way to choose roles?

Random is random. The fact that you get calvados 2x is speaking for it being random than against it :V

just like a townie won't sell out townies

One word: xpon 

But yes, this round made me realize how strong Tequila is.

I didn't realize how strong Tequila was and I was the one being frightened alla da time, yo

Identify xpon: oops he died
Identify pofa: well that didn't work but we know she's not whatever role she claimed anyway
Identify Kain: well that didn't work but she's dead anyway

There's already a limit on how many wrong roles you can poison someone as (3)

^This

btw... even without me leaking info

Other than that, I did everything I normally do as town: gather information.

However you didn't share the information (well except for with your BO buddies) so I knew something was up with that.

And I was all shocked I wasn't the one being frightened. I guess I should apologize to Abs. more than anyone here.

I, too, was shocked that Yuriko wasn't the one being frightened.  Why me   Did Parkur Observe me or something?  Anyhow, no apologies necessary 

It was too dangerous for me to talk to Abs. too much, because he would've figured me out a lot faster than you did, I think. Or, at least, I was paranoid that he would have.

This is why you were bold/italicized/whatever it was I did.

Even after my super nice clues you didn't vote for Sherlock? D:

^This

I figured Kleene leaving that for us town to see meant that we were dead meat, and I was right. D:  HOWEVER that still doesn't explain why no one voted for her >_<


The only thing I think that should be changed re: abilities, etc. is Gin's Slander being changed to "cannot be covered"


Also: Schillok was town?  ;

@gin: I don't think that's necessary. Since in that game, Gin was just covered once. and at that time, Gin himself didn't slander, just calvados did (so there were always just 2 slandering every night. Not more.)

But maybe changing it, so Calvados can just do 1 slander when he covers Gin. Either BO or Town. So there can be max 3 slandering done. But usually, the BO totally needs 4 slandering, depending on how many interrogators there are. And remember, it can always fail in case Gin get's killed/arrested.

so .. can i made a crazy round now?

because you will hope you became Townie this round!!!!!

^I'm not gonna join then

And I've been BO three times in a row, so I'm tired of it too. Though I guess Akonyl has more reason to complain than I do.

That makes me wonder about how GM designate players, I mean there are people who get to be town repeatedly, and vice-versa 

Since Random.org was sometimes strange imo, I used a real random generator.
I wrote down roles and players on a paper. Then I put it into a hat and draw out roles and a player for that.

[Kleene Onigiri]

i did pair all the legal couple

Fairly certain PiscoxAyumi isn't legal at all.

i'm sure we can get around that with parental consent 

The same goes for Makoto/Genta. That would be scary. How would they fall in love even...?

Makoto buys genta a lot of food?

I wonder if I really did make that FI mistake subconciously or if my phone did change school to food.

Kleene, I love you. ^^ Your pm made me feel amazing thanks for believing in the fat kid that loves cake.

[xpon]

did i say your round bad kleene? not a single word! i am glad enough that i can play in the middle of flood! your phase change always make me laugh because i really love the Pirates Of Carribean

i am already trying to made the next round as fair as it can be.. because since long time ago i want to have a crazy round where only vermouth vs townie!

looking at a couple post in this thread really offend my feeling!

to be honest i dont think the Round will be over this soon, but it's too bad that the town lose, even without me being a blabber mouth!

i hope this is just a misunderstanding because i cant read english well... but this is different from the time when you angry at me because i create the thread before you even made it...

i know how hurt someone feeling when his / her hard work called trash or being ignored. but trust me. i am grateful that you made the round 16. it even better then Akonyl Phoenix Wright round!!!

and the interesting new round that i mean is a round where people need to use a new tactic. it can be a good round or it can lead into a very bad and fail round.

your lover changed in this round is way better then my idea. this way, the 2 side lover can have a good chance to win it!. and that is why i pairing the legal couple.. because if i pair just a newbie-veteran.. then it wont happen.. and kain x edogawa is really a 2 side lover... but they didnt make it....

i'm not going to hurt your feeling any more. but if you really mad at me.. then i know what i'm going to do ... just like when you remind me after round 15...

i prefer to have friend in the forum then playing some mafia but losing some of my precious friend .

[Dus]

Don't get upset Cpt. Kleene, you were a great GM.
I think it wasn't all tha unbalanced, and Yuriko was the blabbermout this round, having exactly the wrong people as allies. And it might have been an unfair game for the BO if I had been a townie instead.