Mafia Round 16 - Yarrharr~ (BO wins!)

[Detective Tommy]

If breva was sober, then I have to have been slandered.
Also, if that is the case then the possibility that you were slandered is high. If, you indeed did find Dus as Gin, then he would want to slander you.

And I'm suspecting the BO aren't slandering themselves this round. Due to perfect "_______ slandered ________" investigation a round or two ago. So I'm thinking the BO will try to slander people that are usually suspicious already.

Now, I have no lead.

I didn't find Dus as Gin, though. I can't prove he is. It's just a hunch based on breva's will and the fact that he's been supposedly investigating since Night 1. He could also be Anokata.

I investigated Dus slandering himself last night and it came back false. (All my other investigations came back false as well, but they involved pofa, so.) But now with Slander's new rules, he can slander both a townie and a BO in the same night. So it's possible he went for me and one of his BO buddies that I don't know of.

It's possible you were slandered (seems unlikely, but not impossible, given that this is mafia and nothing is impossible).

Also, I think you're reading too much into the phase change post. I don't think the grouping means anything.

Well, I just thought it was a possibility since the numbering of people I'm with, is slightly like the show. But the chances of us all being in the game, is slim. So it's probably not right.

Also, I was slandered. If the BO can slander both town and BO, then I'm a likely target. Since I usually alliance with at least one person early on. I've just been a bit inactive due to school.

[Detective Tommy]

PT has been fairly active, so the BO might have slandered her. You on the other hand have also been interrogated as BO and you weren't in contact with anyone. So I have no idea whom I should trust. I sure as hell don't trust PT but you just aren't trustworthy either.
Maybe your even both BO?

Well, it's a high chance that they're going after people that make alliances fairly quickly.
I was slandered on Night 2, and if PhoenixTears was slandered on Night 3, then it's a high chance.
Since they can slander 2x the people in one night now...

Does that mean PT, Paix and  me are the DB since there's three of us? Or nom, sherlock and sakina?
I don't think that's how it works, though.

It was just a possibility.

Yeah, nothing makes sense atm. And why did no one try to arrest me or interrogate me while trying for self-slandering or anything? Why is no-one even interested in actually making sure I'm BO? I'm getting ever so slightly irritated....

Well, nobody is 100% sure of your actions. Just saying. I'm not sure whether you are or aren't BO.
But I find it highly suspicious that you knew about Pofa's interrogation, and she was not BO. Then she actually was BO.

[PT]

@DT:
On Day 2 if you pay attention it says "A .." not "A.." Meaning, a type of person contacted her. A two-letter type. Either DB or BO. Now, I'm gonna give breva the benefit of the doubt and assume she didn't just hand her role out to someone claiming to be BO, meaning someone claiming to be a DB contacted her.

[Detective Tommy]

Oh, I'm sorry.
I'll lynch Dus, but I really hope he's BO.

I'm leaving to work now.

[Dus]

PT has been fairly active, so the BO might have slandered her. You on the other hand have also been interrogated as BO and you weren't in contact with anyone. So I have no idea whom I should trust. I sure as hell don't trust PT but you just aren't trustworthy either.
Maybe your even both BO?

Well, it's a high chance that they're going after people that make alliances fairly quickly.
I was slandered on Night 2, and if PhoenixTears was slandered on Night 3, then it's a high chance.
Since they can slander 2x the people in one night now...

What I don't get is how you're saying "yeah, PT and me were both slandered even if no-one could have known they were going to be interrogated" but no-one considers the possibility that pofa's slandering was a coincidence that has now lead to 3 townies getting lynched.

Well, nobody is 100% sure of your actions. Just saying. I'm not sure whether you are or aren't BO.
But I find it highly suspicious that you knew about Pofa's interrogation, and she was not BO. Then she actually was BO.

Yes, but I have admitted to that even before she was killed. (To be fair, her APTXing would have been fairly foreseeable for me) and I don't blame you or indeed anyone for saying that I'm the most suspicious atm. I'm just pissed about how I'm not even given a fair trial...

[Akonyl]

just to point out (skimming the topic, maybe it was pointed out already but I didn't see it):

Breva was Kogoro. So the chances that her interrogation was false, is highly possible.
I interrogated someone too. I got PT is BO.

this isn't "highly possible" at all, actually, because she used analyze, thus she's been sober since the start of the game.

[PT]

Yeah, I pointed that out earlier.

[Akonyl]

Yeah, I pointed that out earlier.

ah, touche.

[Schillok]

So we have PhoenixTears and Dus as main suspects now. Who should we vote for?


On another matter - I am still interested in proving myself. So if there are some Detective Boys out there - and if you don't have any other plans - please contact me.

[Edogawa4869]

So we have PhoenixTears and Dus as main suspects now. Who should we vote for?


On another matter - I am still interested in proving myself. So if there are some Detective Boys out there - and if you don't have any other plans - please contact me.

I believe that Dus was the one that had more evidence against him...  Though I could be wrong.

[Dus]

There is merely circumstancial evidence, while DT has been interrogated as BO and no-one should have had a reason to slander him. I'm inclined to think he's actually BO, but it's also possible that PT is BO, that they're both town or that they're both BO.

[PT]

So we have PhoenixTears and Dus as main suspects now. Who should we vote for?

How did I go from being semi-suspicious to being a main suspect?

[Holmes]

So we have PhoenixTears and Dus as main suspects now. Who should we vote for?

How did I go from being semi-suspicious to being a main suspect?

With Det. Tommy´s interrogation I believe, but hey, I´m lynching Dus.

[Dus]

*cough* I advise everyone who doesn't have access to information not made public in the thread to vote for me instead of PT or DT and at least give them time to prove themselves then hopefully you'll be able to lynch a BO for once on day 4.
Two reasons:
a) Even if I survive, I'm pretty much useless as a townie, since absolutely no-one will trust me. I'd rather die and reveal some information that could help you discover BOs via my will than seeing a more useful townie die.
b) I have a job interview tomorrow and if I actually survive then I will be thinking of a way to prove myself during the interview. Which wouldn't be a good idea.

[PT]

So we have PhoenixTears and Dus as main suspects now. Who should we vote for?

How did I go from being semi-suspicious to being a main suspect?

With Det. Tommy´s interrogation I believe, but hey, I´m lynching Dus.

DT was also interrogated and it came up BO, and his result was much less likely to have been slandered than mine.