pofa's superspecialawesome Mini-Mafia round (BO Wins 1, Town Wins 1)

[PT]

BTW.. why dont try to kill akonyl or me on night 2?

Because it was Commi and she wanted to kill me because I'm her sister?

Or it could be because I asked her if she killed Yuriko, she said no, asked who I was voting for (this was during Day 1), and I told her that the last person who I'd heard about asking someone who they were voting for on Day 1 I ended up suspecting the whole game and voting for them all the time, and they turned out to be Vermouth. So she knew I was suspicious of her.

[Commi-Ninja]

BTW.. why dont try to kill akonyl or me on night 2?

Because it was Commi and she wanted to kill me because I'm her sister?

Or it could be because I asked her if she killed Yuriko, she said no, asked who I was voting for (this was during Day 1), and I told her that the last person who I'd heard about asking someone who they were voting for on Day 1 I ended up suspecting the whole game and voting for them all the time, and they turned out to be Vermouth. So she knew I was suspicious of her.

Actually PT, it wasn't precisely that.  It was your mannerisms when you asked me that.

[PT]

Actually PT, it wasn't precisely that.  It was your mannerisms when you asked me that.

Even if I gave away that I was incredibly suspicious of you, and you killed me for it, you still got lynched and the town still won. So.... I'd say it was a necessary sacrifice on my part. Had you killed Ako-chan instead of me, I dunno if I could've got the rest of the town to support me as quickly.

[Akonyl]

Actually PT, it wasn't precisely that.  It was your mannerisms when you asked me that.

Even if I gave away that I was incredibly suspicious of you, and you killed me for it, you still got lynched and the town still won. So.... I'd say it was a necessary sacrifice on my part. Had you killed Ako-chan instead of me, I dunno if I could've got the rest of the town to support me as quickly.

at the very least, I'd told xpon to point people towards commi if I was to die.

[Commi-Ninja]

Really, we should've just killed PT at the beginning.  That would've saved some trouble, I think.

[PT]

at the very least, I'd told xpon to point people towards commi if I was to die.

Yeah, but I had no way of knowing that. And I couldn't really go around saying "Yeah, so, I was talking to Akonyl and he told me he was police, and blahblahblah" cause that probably would've pitted them against me rather than making allies out of it. Though I might've been able to just flat out tell them my role and what actions I'd used. Cause if I hadn't died, we would've known for sure that Akemi was in the game, so...

Really, we should've just killed PT at the beginning.  That would've saved some trouble, I think.

D: That's just mean.

(Actually, would've been smart for you probably. I doubt Ako-chan is stupid enough to actually kill me right after he's spent all that time threatening me, but the other people might've jumped on him for it. Of course then there's the whole reverse-psychology issue - Ako spends all that time threatening me in the hopes that when he does kill me it'll make people think he wasn't the one that did it because obviously he's not stupid enough to call attention to himself that way...)

[Akonyl]

(Actually, would've been smart for you probably. I doubt Ako-chan is stupid enough to actually kill me right after he's spent all that time threatening me, but the other people might've jumped on him for it. Of course then there's the whole reverse-psychology issue - Ako spends all that time threatening me in the hopes that when he does kill me it'll make people think he wasn't the one that did it because obviously he's not stupid enough to call attention to himself that way...)

I probably woulda done it had I been BO also.

but maybe not as far as actually PMing you that I was gonna shoot you.

[PT]

I probably woulda done it had I been BO also.

but maybe not as far as actually PMing you that I was gonna shoot you.

The PM was actually what made me think you weren't BO. And then, of course, after you got breva as Gin, that was more or less all the proof I needed.

Keep in mind, that tactic probably won't work again - and it definitely won't work in regular mafia when there's more BO to work with, thus it's okay to make a sacrifice or two.

[Akonyl]

I probably woulda done it had I been BO also.

but maybe not as far as actually PMing you that I was gonna shoot you.

The PM was actually what made me think you weren't BO. And then, of course, after you got breva as Gin, that was more or less all the proof I needed.

Keep in mind, that tactic probably won't work again - and it definitely won't work in regular mafia when there's more BO to work with, thus it's okay to make a sacrifice or two.

or maybe it's the fact that you'd never think it would work that would make it work, because you'd never expect me to try it :O

[PT]

or maybe it's the fact that you'd never think it would work that would make it work, because you'd never expect me to try it :O

It's possible, but seeing as we've never actually been allies in regular mafia, you don't know quite how much I over-analyze everything. So you can try it, but it'll probably just make me more suspicious of you.

[Akonyl]

or maybe it's the fact that you'd never think it would work that would make it work, because you'd never expect me to try it :O

It's possible, but seeing as we've never actually been allies in regular mafia, you don't know quite how much I over-analyze everything. So you can try it, but it'll probably just make me more suspicious of you.

well, considering I haven't been a living townie in a normal mafia since june 25th, there's a reason we've never been able to be allies.

though in normal mafia I tend to be more secluded anyway.

[PT]

well, considering I haven't been a living townie in a normal mafia since june 25th, there's a reason we've never been able to be allies.

though in normal mafia I tend to be more secluded anyway.

You say that like I haven't been allies with BO in any round ever. But you're better off not attempting to be my ally if you're BO and I'm town anyway. (The other way around, though, would be fine for me. But I'm never BO, so it's not an issue. )

I noticed that actually, from your PMs with Kleene in Round 14.

[Akonyl]

You say that like I haven't been allies with BO in any round ever. But you're better off not attempting to be my ally if you're BO and I'm town anyway. (The other way around, though, would be fine for me. But I'm never BO, so it's not an issue. )

I noticed that actually, from your PMs with Kleene in Round 14.

true, true.

and round 14 isn't the best indicator, I mean of course I'd be secluded when I'm calvados. Heck, I was even secluded when I was Gin and could actually investigate.

[PT]

true, true.

and round 14 isn't the best indicator, I mean of course I'd be secluded when I'm calvados. Heck, I was even secluded when I was Gin and could actually investigate.

True, but iirc, you said something to Kleene about not usually making allies or something. (I dunno, this was over a month ago, I could be remembering wrong.)

[Akonyl]

true, true.

and round 14 isn't the best indicator, I mean of course I'd be secluded when I'm calvados. Heck, I was even secluded when I was Gin and could actually investigate.

True, but iirc, you said something to Kleene about not usually making allies or something. (I dunno, this was over a month ago, I could be remembering wrong.)

ah, gotcha, yeah I think I said that, I thought you meant you just noticed that I didn't trust kleene.

you can partially blame her for telling me I was too obvious a BO once :V