Mafia Round 15 - The Devil's playground - BO wins!

[Eve]

So... lynch Edogawa?

Alright, so in the interest of continuing the lovely on-topicness!

I interrogated Eve last night and she came back as Black Organization.

So.... That gives us two very likely targets.  I submitted a vote for Edo already, but I'm willing to change to Eve if we agree that she's more of a threat (though I've got less than an hour to do so).

If we knew their roles, it would be easier to pick through them...

Okay, so apparently Commi, you interrogated me.... but decided to say it when I'm not on? If that attempt isn't obvious, I don't know what is ...
I'm NOT Org, If you guys lynch me, well
I don't even have to write a scenario out right now, Thanks DT

Honestly, I don't think we can trust Commi-Ninja.
Now that Kir is dead, she told me there were 9 BO. Since two are dead, that leaves 7.


16 players left. 7 BO left.
Once Edogawa is lynched, it'll be 15 players and 6 BO.
That means 9 town and 6 BO.

If Eve is town and dies, that leaves 8 town and 6 BO. One more kill for night, that leaves 7 town and 6 BO.
And if town is lynched that morning, 6 town and 6 BO. We lose.

[Detective Tommy]

Eve, I wasn't defending you.
I was simply stating that we can't trust Commi yet. And we can't trust Eve.


The only person I know is town, is me.
And I'm pretty sure Dus is town.

He asked me to identify him. But I didn't send in the action.
I doubt he would tell me his role to identify if he is BO.

Most likely, town.

[Eve]

I didn't say you were defending me, I said I was going to write a scenerio about BO winning b/c you guys would end up lynching another town (You have a specific numbers, I was gonna go with, only 2 BOs down so they would have a lot more left)

Is this how it is? someone gave you their role and you automatically trust them?
Dus is town for sure, that bit I know, b/c if he was BO, no point for him to claim stolen and expose Akemi, but now, BO could just PM you a role, and say "I identify me" and you're not going to turn in any action and trust them?

[Detective Tommy]

That's not what happened.
Dus asked me to identify him. Why would BO ask me to identify them if I wasn't about to die?
And I didn't tell him I didn't have to identify him.

I forgot to send in my action, because I said I was quitting.
But it doesn't make sense to tell me your role, if you have no way of lying if it was false.

[KainTheVampire]

Ah btw... I hope everyone realizes that this round wont end until all BOs or all townies are dead!

[Eve]

[facepalmed]

I pretty sure DUS is town, reason stated as above , but now you're saying it in the thread that "I trust Dus b/c he told you his role, oh, and I didn't identify him yet" .....

Dus asked me to identify him. Why would BO ask me to identify them if I wasn't about to die?

And you're giving BO an option to just contact you with maybe a "couple of roles" and DT would trust us even more, all we have to do is not kill him .....
PS. I'm confused....you "forgot to turn in your action"? I thought DB identify is DAY action...... it's not even phase change yet.... how can you "forgot to turn in your action".....? Unless you were serious when you told us you can identify at night..... D:

[Detective Tommy]

/facepalm
You're misunderstanding.
He asked me to identify him 2 phases ago.

Parkur and I talked about whether we should identify Paix or Dus.
Or if we should randomly try to find BO.

Then I forgot to send in my action.

[Eve]

[facepalmed] You mean we're not even talking about the same phase here D: ?

[Detective Tommy]

No, we're not.
You thought I was talking about THIS phase.
I'm talking about earlier.

[Dus]

So that's why you haven't PMed me yet?;_;
It does make sense, but you're forgetting one scenario: The BO could know/believe/hope that no DB would be alive by the next phase. That's what happened in round 14, pofa asked me to identify her as Yusaku and we were all inclined to believe her, until the results came in.
In fact, I was half-convinced that there weren't any DBs left in-game.

[Detective Tommy]

No, cause at that point I wasn't about to die.
It would be foolish to ask me to identify you.
I wasn't poisoned or anything.

[Dus]

I'm not trying to convince you I'm BO.
But in general, you should identify people if they offer you their identity. Better safe than sorry.

[Kleene Onigiri]

Ah btw... I hope everyone realizes that this round wont end until all BOs or all townies are dead!

You will continue the game even if, for example, there are 4 BO and 3 townies left? D: + all police dead

[Detective Tommy]

I'm not trying to convince you I'm BO.
But in general, you should identify people if they offer you their identity. Better safe than sorry.

I forgot. D:
I told Parkur about it.

[Abs.]

...Then I suppose it's possible that BO already outnumbers town