Mafia! Mafia! Mafia! Character Role Discussions

[Abs.]

One of these days, Tommy, you are going to be BO and be all, "$#!+ the town roles are too strong we are all screwed!!!!!!!!"

[Edogawa4869]

Oh, just an update to SOS:

*SOS
Role with that action: Kir/Hidemi
-When Kir is killed, one random Town member is given a note containing a clue to the identity of the killer.
-If Vermouth is disguised as a Town member, she MAY receive the note.
-Sometimes if the Town member deciphers the clue on the first attempt ONLY (by PMing the GM), an Auto-Report will be sent to a random officer.
-The Town member will not know if he was right or wrong in his (or her) guess.

[Edogawa4869]

if kir is in the game.. let her be like reverse vermouth!

so in prep phase she chose list and disguise as that BO person.

she will have all the ability of the one she disguise..

( anokata and vermouth cant be disguise as )

the anokata will know if she is in the game or not

But, she's already in the BO.  Why would she need to disguise herself as a BO member if she technically is one?  And what happens if Anokata orders Kir to kill someone?

[Detective Tommy]

One of these days, Tommy, you are going to be BO and be all, "$#!+ the town roles are too strong we are all screwed!!!!!!!!"

Can't wait for this day...

if kir is in the game.. let her be like reverse vermouth!

so in prep phase she chose list and disguise as that BO person.

she will have all the ability of the one she disguise..

( anokata and vermouth cant be disguise as )

the anokata will know if she is in the game or not

That makes no sense. Why would Kir be able to disguise as someone?

[Detective Tommy]

if kir is in the game.. let her be like reverse vermouth!

so in prep phase she chose list and disguise as that BO person.

she will have all the ability of the one she disguise..

( anokata and vermouth cant be disguise as )

the anokata will know if she is in the game or not

But, she's already in the BO.  Why would she need to disguise herself as a BO member if she technically is one?  And what happens if Anokata orders Kir to kill someone?

Also, I forgot to mention. Kir is TOWN! Not BO.

[xpon]

if kir is in the game.. let her be like reverse vermouth!

so in prep phase she chose list and disguise as that BO person.

she will have all the ability of the one she disguise..

( anokata and vermouth cant be disguise as )

the anokata will know if she is in the game or not

But, she's already in the BO.  Why would she need to disguise herself as a BO member if she technically is one?  And what happens if Anokata orders Kir to kill someone?

soorry.. havent read ytill last page..

btw.. if someone knows all bo roles.. and kir is townie.. then all bo is as good as die.....

kir must  be BO.

[Edogawa4869]

if kir is in the game.. let her be like reverse vermouth!

so in prep phase she chose list and disguise as that BO person.

she will have all the ability of the one she disguise..

( anokata and vermouth cant be disguise as )

the anokata will know if she is in the game or not

But, she's already in the BO.  Why would she need to disguise herself as a BO member if she technically is one?  And what happens if Anokata orders Kir to kill someone?

Also, I forgot to mention. Kir is TOWN! Not BO.

I know that!  I was just saying, technically, she's in the BO.  But she's playing on the Town side.  If, however, you're talking about what happens if Anokata orders Kir to kill someone, I meant to add (following your [xpon's] definition).

[Detective Tommy]

if kir is in the game.. let her be like reverse vermouth!

so in prep phase she chose list and disguise as that BO person.

she will have all the ability of the one she disguise..

( anokata and vermouth cant be disguise as )

the anokata will know if she is in the game or not

But, she's already in the BO.  Why would she need to disguise herself as a BO member if she technically is one?  And what happens if Anokata orders Kir to kill someone?

soorry.. havent read ytill last page..

btw.. if someone knows all bo roles.. and kir is townie.. then all bo is as good as die.....

kir must  be BO.

... She doesn't know Player/Role.
She only knows the role.

And if she's BO, then her ability to know what BO roles are in the game - becomes useless.

[Detective Tommy]

if kir is in the game.. let her be like reverse vermouth!

so in prep phase she chose list and disguise as that BO person.

she will have all the ability of the one she disguise..

( anokata and vermouth cant be disguise as )

the anokata will know if she is in the game or not

But, she's already in the BO.  Why would she need to disguise herself as a BO member if she technically is one?  And what happens if Anokata orders Kir to kill someone?

Also, I forgot to mention. Kir is TOWN! Not BO.

I know that!  I was just saying, technically, she's in the BO.  But she's playing on the Town side.  If, however, you're talking about what happens if Anokata orders Kir to kill someone, I meant to add (following your [xpon's] definition).

He's saying that Anokata will know whether Kir is in the game, playing.

[Edogawa4869]

if kir is in the game.. let her be like reverse vermouth!

so in prep phase she chose list and disguise as that BO person.

she will have all the ability of the one she disguise..

( anokata and vermouth cant be disguise as )

the anokata will know if she is in the game or not

But, she's already in the BO.  Why would she need to disguise herself as a BO member if she technically is one?  And what happens if Anokata orders Kir to kill someone?

Also, I forgot to mention. Kir is TOWN! Not BO.

I know that!  I was just saying, technically, she's in the BO.  But she's playing on the Town side.  If, however, you're talking about what happens if Anokata orders Kir to kill someone, I meant to add (following your [xpon's] definition).

He's saying that Anokata will know whether Kir is in the game, playing.

Ah.  That makes sense, too.

[pofa]

Maybe Kir should have the Hide ability. Or call it Coma.

If we go with the "she can PM hints to people at night", if she picks a BO member she has to go into hiding and can't lynch vote, etc the next day or night.

Or else she can choose to go into hiding. Still wouldn't fix the problem of PM ing someone with "LOL here are all the BO members." But in the same way, the BO could use that to figure out who she is.

[Akonyl]

If we go with the "she can PM hints to people at night", if she picks a BO member she has to go into hiding and can't lynch vote, etc the next day or night

in other words, give her a 100% BO detector along with knowledge of the roles?

No thanks.

[Detective Tommy]

Maybe Kir should have the Hide ability. Or call it Coma.

If we go with the "she can PM hints to people at night", if she picks a BO member she has to go into hiding and can't lynch vote, etc the next day or night.

Or else she can choose to go into hiding. Still wouldn't fix the problem of PM ing someone with "LOL here are all the BO members." But in the same way, the BO could use that to figure out who she is.

1) So she PMs the hint to other players, not the GM?
2) So she can go into hiding everyday?

Her PMing hints to random players = no.

[PT]

Something I've been thinking about for a couple rounds now: I think we need another way for townies to get arrested. We only have Kid and Eisuke that can be arrested, and the town is pretty strong as it is, so maybe borrow one of the BO abilities, attach it to a townie (like Kir, for example, though I don't know which ability), and that gives the BO another townie role to hide behind in case they're arrested.

Just a thought.

[Detective Tommy]

Something I've been thinking about for a couple rounds now: I think we need another way for townies to get arrested. We only have Kid and Eisuke that can be arrested, and the town is pretty strong as it is, so maybe borrow one of the BO abilities, attach it to a townie (like Kir, for example, though I don't know which ability), and that gives the BO another townie role to hide behind in case they're arrested.

Just a thought.

Well, if I was BO, I probably would want that.
I've been so focused on keeping the town strong, once I'm BO I'mma be pretty pissed