File 680 (spoiler)

Forum reserved for discussing specific points of the story—mostly from the manga. Be warned, these discussions will be current with the manga and will spoil many plot lines for anime-centric fans.
Sandam

Posts:
15

Re: File 680 (spoiler)

Post by Sandam »

cane? i dont think so... im sure haibara can identify bullet marks... and how can a cane pierce through seats?
as to theyr identity im sure they are the pair from fuurinkazan. that man said: "it'll save us the trouble of looking for his place..."
that means they dont know where mouri lives. shinichi parents know that. BO know that too...
Nanatsu no Ko

Posts:
167

Re: File 680 (spoiler)

Post by Nanatsu no Ko »

Kristantei wrote:
cdgal wrote: i have 2 questions: how do you explain the blood stains and the bullet marks on the seats? if they were yamato and uehara pair from furinkazan case as most people believe?
Go through this thread and you will see my explanations on this case.

http://forums.dctp.ws/viewtopic.php?p=18067#p18067
http://forums.dctp.ws/viewtopic.php?p=18259#p18259
There is probably some explanation for the blood and bullet marks, like you said. However, I am still hoping that in the case of Okiya we get to see one of those moments where Conan is flat out mistaken on his identity. Of course, I would be okay with Conan getting captured, questioned, and expiremented on by the Organization for a while.
Rellik
/facepalm

Posts:
1288

Re: File 680 (spoiler)

Post by Rellik »

Kristantei wrote: This chapter just reaffirms that Okiya isn't a member of the BO. The fact Conan suggested they have Okiya pick him up helps with that. Conan would never put Haibara at risk. Just remember the extents that Conan went to before to keep Haibara away from Jodie when he just suspected her. Like during the Bus Hijacking, Conan smeared his blood on her leg just to get her out of the area.
I think that if Conan is so sure he knows who Okiya isn't makes me believe that he knows just who he really is.
The same goes for Ran. Conan forgot to even mention that Okiya was there. If Okiya was dangerous there is no way he would of let Ran walk into something dangerous.
i perfectly agree with this part (im not disagreein wit the rest btw :P), theres most likely a reason Conan trusts Okiya, u can clearly tell Conan figured somethin out tat made Okiya go on the not-a-dangerous-person list - better reread the chapters and look for hints ;D
User avatar
Chekhov MacGuffin
Community Scholar
BAGA BGEGD EDBDEG A

Posts:
2684

Re: File 680 (spoiler)

Post by Chekhov MacGuffin »

cdgal wrote: i have 2 questions: how do you explain the blood stains and the bullet marks on the seats? if they were yamato and uehara pair from furinkazan case as most people believe?
They're police. I am sort of not surprised that their car took a bit of abuse. For some reason I have the impression that Yamato is not the type to worry about how spiffy his car looks. He probably thinks its manly to have a round or two in the seat. They probably had to arrest a whole bunch of people from the neighboring village who helped conspire to throw the tournament and burn the Fire target from the Fuurinkazen case.
As for why I think they are Yamato Kansuke and Torada Yui (I don't know why people are calling her Uehara) compare the two pictures.

Yamato Kansuke from 680
Spoiler:
Image
Yamato from 618. Note the pattern of the stubbly mustache and dark skin. 
Spoiler:
Image
Torada Yui from 680
Spoiler:
Image
Torada from 618, note the curve of the hair and the "black" lips.
Spoiler:
Image
Kristantei

Posts:
56
Contact:

Re: File 680 (spoiler)

Post by Kristantei »

Rellik wrote: i perfectly agree with this part (im not disagreein wit the rest btw :P), theres most likely a reason Conan trusts Okiya, u can clearly tell Conan figured somethin out tat made Okiya go on the not-a-dangerous-person list - better reread the chapters and look for hints ;D
I already have a strong idea of who Okiya really is. I just wasn't going in on it here. This thread is about this case.
I have written a rather long and detailed explanation about Okiya on this forums and Holmes Study.
I still remember how paranoid how Conan was about Jodie getting close to Haibara. Even to go so far as to go to her house with Heiji. He went to great extent to keep Haibara away from Jodie.
I doubt Conan would use her as bait. Watch by the end of this recent case Haibara will feel so embarrassed of suspecting these police that she will also put aside her suspicions of Okiya.
Remember that the only reason Conan gave Haibara about Okiya is that, "No Holmes fan could be a bad person.". We all know that's not true, including Conan. There was the killer from the 'Holmes Freak Murder Case'. Both a Holmes fan and a psycho.
Chekhov MacGuffin wrote: As for why I think they are Yamato Kansuke and Torada Yui (I don't know why people are calling her Uehara) compare the two pictures.
We are calling her Uehara, because that was her family name before she married into the Torada family. (Thought that was a bit obvious.) She didn't really love her husband. She married into the family to investigate. When Yamato asked her for the time he used the name Uehara out of habit. http://www.dctp.ws/V59-Reader/File615-EN/A4.html

I guess I like the idea that now her husband died and she has no reason to stay with that family she went back to her maiden name. Especially, now that the man she really loves is alive and she's working with him again.
So far there is nothing to say that she kept the Torada family name. So, until then I'm sticking with Uehara.
Last edited by Kristantei on February 2nd, 2009, 10:17 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Misztina

Posts:
976
Contact:

Re: File 680 (spoiler)

Post by Misztina »

Kristantei wrote: I doubt Conan would use her as bait. Watch by the end of this recent case Haibara will feel so embarrassed of suspecting these police that she will also put aside her suspicions of Okiya.
I'm not so sure about that. Now she wants Conan to throw Okiya out of Shinichi's house, because she sensed in the recent case by the sea that Okiya has a very dangerous aura, the aura of a BO member. She wouldn't drop her instict just because of a misunderstanding.
Of course it'll turn out that she have been paranoid about our two strange people with no reason, but I think her insticts are much stronger. She sees it as a fact that Okiya is a Bo-member.
User avatar
Tenken

Posts:
322
Contact:

Re: File 680 (spoiler)

Post by Tenken »

Haibara definitely knew Okiya's true identity after "Ikkaku Rock".
Kristantei wrote: Remember that the only reason Conan gave Haibara about Okiya is that, "No Holmes fan could be a bad person.". We all know that's not true, including Conan.
Of course! When reading that, I thought, the real reason Conan couldn't tell Haibara straight out was because Okiya really is someone who doesn't have the courage to face her, or vice versa.
Rellik
/facepalm

Posts:
1288

Re: File 680 (spoiler)

Post by Rellik »

Kristantei wrote:
Rellik wrote: i perfectly agree with this part (im not disagreein wit the rest btw :P), theres most likely a reason Conan trusts Okiya, u can clearly tell Conan figured somethin out tat made Okiya go on the not-a-dangerous-person list - better reread the chapters and look for hints ;D
I already have a strong idea of who Okiya really is. I just wasn't going in on it here. This thread
is about this case.
I have written a rather long and detailed explanation about Okiya on this forums and Holmes Study.
I still remember how paranoid how Conan was about Jodie getting close to Haibara. Even to go so far as to go to her house with Heiji. He when to great extent to keep Haibara away from Jodie.
I doubt Conan would use her as bait. Watch by the end of this recent case Haibara will feel so embarrassed of suspecting these police that she will also put aside her suspicions of Okiya.
Remember that the only reason Conan gave Haibara about Okiya is that, "No Holmes fan could be a bad person.". We all know that's not true, including Conan. There was the killer from the 'Holmes Freak Murder Case'. Both a Holmes fan and a psycho.

underlined part: i think that is the biggest hint to why Okiya isnt Bourbon - yes it sounds ridiculous but i think Conan is tryin to make a joke out of what he figured out - like wat he always do :P

If u narrow it dwn tat means 'No Holmes fan' is the main hint.
Tenken wrote: Haibara definitely knew Okiya's true identity after "Ikkaku Rock".
That's why she didnt torture Conan into kickin Okiya out?
User avatar
Tenken

Posts:
322
Contact:

Re: File 680 (spoiler)

Post by Tenken »

Rellik wrote:That's why she didnt torture Conan into kickin Okiya out?
Ask Haibara, she knew ;D
but Conan is not persuaded :P
TheBlind
Insane Vigilante of JUSTICE!

Posts:
1280

Re: File 680 (spoiler)

Post by TheBlind »

Misztina wrote:
Kristantei wrote: I doubt Conan would use her as bait. Watch by the end of this recent case Haibara will feel so embarrassed of suspecting these police that she will also put aside her suspicions of Okiya.
I'm not so sure about that. Now she wants Conan to throw Okiya out of Shinichi's house, because she sensed in the recent case by the sea that Okiya has a very dangerous aura, the aura of a BO member. She wouldn't drop her instict just because of a misunderstanding.
Of course it'll turn out that she have been paranoid about our two strange people with no reason, but I think her insticts are much stronger. She sees it as a fact that Okiya is a Bo-member.
I agree that she just won't let it go. Some event has to happen in this case to lead Haibara (if even possible) to trust Conan even more than she does now. If said event happens then she would be "ok" in letting a man she believes to be a B.O. member to live next to her because she is now sure Conan won't let anything happen to her.

The other thing that could happen(which I prefer) is that Haibara gets her own "Ran confront Shinichi moment" at the end of the case. Where Haibara confronts Conan alone about why he won't tell her anything about Okiya and Conan responds with jokes to defuse the situation which in turn just makes Haibara lower her head similar to the case she was introduced. Then we get our "Ran confront Shinichi moment" where it seems like she's crying and asking "why won't you tell me anything?", making Conan get serious, embrace her, and tell her some of the details with a "I'm sorry Haibara I didn't mean--" to be cut off with a "That's it?". Then the scene ends with Haibara explaining she faked the whole thing to get a satisfactory answer out of him meanwhile Conan is still in shock that she went that far and calls her a demon in that little caption box of his at the end of the episode.

Yep I know shamelessly sneaked in a scenario that has a zero chance of happening but we need a Haibara & Conan moment to add more exciment to the series, hear that Gosho, we need one. ;D
Image
                                                      The Faces of Evil
                                 Trying to start a club about magical ponies!
User avatar
kirite
Cookie-Eating Moderating Machine
Chillin'

Posts:
1762
Contact:

Re: File 680 (spoiler)

Post by kirite »

Most likely because Haibara has been wrong before, multiple times actually.  If she press the issue he'll just bring up the fact that she's paranoid.  If she forces him to kick him out that will be unreasonable, I really doubt Conan can force "poor student" out of his house without a good reason anyways.

D'aww TheBlind should write fanfiction ^_^.
Hey, I have an idea, let's have a THIS SUCKS / NO THIS SUCKS / NO YOU / NO YOU argument for a couple pages, that will really be great. - Ingmar
Rellik
/facepalm

Posts:
1288

Re: File 680 (spoiler)

Post by Rellik »

wouldnt Conan be freaked out if Haibara did the 'why wont you tell me anything?' thing?

hell probably get a heart attack :P

Blackmail seems more haibara XD
TheBlind
Insane Vigilante of JUSTICE!

Posts:
1280

Re: File 680 (spoiler)

Post by TheBlind »

D'aww TheBlind should write fanfiction ^_^.
*Gets Red*
N-no,  it's best we leave that to the professionals.... ;D
wouldnt Conan be freaked out if Haibara did the 'why wont you tell me anything?' thing?

hell probably get a heart attack :P

Blackmail seems more haibara XD
Well she took advantage of his guilt and kindness, so not too far off from blackmail or something she would do.
And Haibara acting like a girl giving Conan a heart attack..?......... ;D ;D. That I would like to see, especially the conversation between Conan and Haibara afterwards in the hospital.
Image
                                                      The Faces of Evil
                                 Trying to start a club about magical ponies!
User avatar
Kite

Posts:
178

Re: File 680 (spoiler)

Post by Kite »

TheBlind wrote:
wouldnt Conan be freaked out if Haibara did the 'why wont you tell me anything?' thing?

hell probably get a heart attack :P

Blackmail seems more haibara XD
Well she took advantage of his guilt and kindness, so not too far off from blackmail or something she would do.
And Haibara acting like a girl giving Conan a heart attack..?......... ;D ;D. That I would like to see, especially the conversation between Conan and Haibara afterwards in the hospital.
Conan (dying from complications for more drama effect): "H ... Haibara ... I'm glad ... to see ... you have finally become ... a real girl .... "

Now that would make one hell of a plot twist! ;D
Rellik
/facepalm

Posts:
1288

Re: File 680 (spoiler)

Post by Rellik »

Kite wrote:
TheBlind wrote:
wouldnt Conan be freaked out if Haibara did the 'why wont you tell me anything?' thing?

hell probably get a heart attack :P

Blackmail seems more haibara XD
Well she took advantage of his guilt and kindness, so not too far off from blackmail or something she would do.
And Haibara acting like a girl giving Conan a heart attack..?......... ;D ;D. That I would like to see, especially the conversation between Conan and Haibara afterwards in the hospital.
Conan (dying from complications for more drama effect): "H ... Haibara ... I'm glad ... to see ... you have finally become ... a real girl .... "

Now that would make one hell of a plot twist! ;D
and give the readers a heart attack ;D
Post Reply