It doesn't have to do with your wins (for me, at least). It has to do with the posts you make/PMs you send while you are alive. Like I said, bad questions and good instincts.Akonyl wrote:I'm bein completely honest when I say that I still have no idea where this comes from. I mean, people will look at my wins in the table, but ignore the fact that for a fair amount of those wins I was too dead to have been part of the reason the town won.pofa wrote: It's true about being unoriginal. But getting rid of you two early is always a good idea for the BO; you're both dangerous players that tend to ask inconvenient questions, be very convincing in the thread, and have good instincts.Although I understand your frustration...I don't know how to fix it. Unless we make a rule that the person to die on Night 1 can't be killed on Night 1 the next game.
For Schillok, it's because his posts/PMs are so methodical--he notices little things that way. And they are very convincing even if they maybe shouldn't be (I remember how he did a big post with percentage numbers two rounds in a row, first round he was town, second he was BO. IIRC, he used basically the same probability stats to draw completely opposite conclusions. But it made him look less suspicious both times).
