Mafia! Mafia! Mafia! Character Role Discussions

[Akonyl]

Just to be clear: I asked for less ghost talk because information was leaked. It is in the rules people, ghosts can't give info.

Once this round is over I totally want to know what this is all about. My curiosity must knoooow. Or do you mean in one of the rounds you GMed?

[Conia]

Just to be clear: I asked for less ghost talk because information was leaked. It is in the rules people, ghosts can't give info.

Once this round is over I totally want to know what this is all about. My curiosity must knoooow. Or do you mean in one of the rounds you GMed?

I mean this Round. Like, even a new ghost topic was created for the Mafia results.

[Akonyl]

Just to be clear: I asked for less ghost talk because information was leaked. It is in the rules people, ghosts can't give info.

Once this round is over I totally want to know what this is all about. My curiosity must knoooow. Or do you mean in one of the rounds you GMed?

I mean this Round. Like, even a new ghost topic was created for the Mafia results.

wait, really? Like, an actual topic? Am I just blind or did it get deleted?

[Conia]

Just to be clear: I asked for less ghost talk because information was leaked. It is in the rules people, ghosts can't give info.

Once this round is over I totally want to know what this is all about. My curiosity must knoooow. Or do you mean in one of the rounds you GMed?

I mean this Round. Like, even a new ghost topic was created for the Mafia results.

wait, really? Like, an actual topic? Am I just blind or did it get deleted?

The Clarification Letter one.

[Akonyl]

Just to be clear: I asked for less ghost talk because information was leaked. It is in the rules people, ghosts can't give info.

Once this round is over I totally want to know what this is all about. My curiosity must knoooow. Or do you mean in one of the rounds you GMed?

I mean this Round. Like, even a new ghost topic was created for the Mafia results.

wait, really? Like, an actual topic? Am I just blind or did it get deleted?

The Clarification Letter one.

ah, touché. I hadn't initially taken that as a hint at nomemory being BO or anything, but now that I look at it I suppose it was.

[Abs.]

Shall I go ahead and delete that topic, or just lock it again?

[Grawwbear]

I say delete it. There really is no use for it anymore.

[Detective Tommy]

If there is no use then he could just leave it...
If there is any information on who is BO and who is TOWN (concerning roles) please delete it ASAP.

[nomemory]

ah, touché. I hadn't initially taken that as a hint at nomemory being BO or anything, but now that I look at it I suppose it was.

So it's all xpons fault? =( I knew my act was flawless! Or maybe not.

[Detective Tommy]

ah, touché. I hadn't initially taken that as a hint at nomemory being BO or anything, but now that I look at it I suppose it was.

So it's all xpons fault? =( I knew my act was flawless! Or maybe not.

What was xpon's fault?

[Akonyl]

ah, touché. I hadn't initially taken that as a hint at nomemory being BO or anything, but now that I look at it I suppose it was.

So it's all xpons fault? =( I knew my act was flawless! Or maybe not.

iunno, I dunno who it was that started the crusade against you and if they were really influenced by that topic at all. I mean, when I first saw it I just saw it as him effectively calling you a meanie.

[Kleene Onigiri]

Are you rolling your eyes because you're in contact with me?   :P  That doesn't count, we are talking about important GM stuff!   ;D  And baby-making

the was on tommy. Because if I remember correctly after he died he PMed me and asked if he can know the roles in round 9. Oh, the irony ->

I didn't ask for the roles when I died. I asked if I could know what all your hints/clues meant.
Then when there were only 2 BO left, you asked me about who I thought was BO.

And I said Conia and xpon. You didn't tell me anything though.
But when you asked me who I thought the last BO was, I asked who. And you told me it was Ctu.
But I didn't PM anyone, because I wouldn't cheat like that.

Asking for the hint/clues that are hints on roles is pretty much the same? Isn't it?

Are you rolling your eyes because you're in contact with me?    That doesn't count, we are talking about important GM stuff!    And baby-making

the was on tommy. Because if I remember correctly after he died he PMed me and asked if he can know the roles in round 9. Oh, the irony ->

You did to in this round

Indeed I did. But I didn't say that I want "all information should be revealed at the end only" (which would also include the hints/clues right?)

I think it's up to the player if he wants to know the roles after he died or not. And it's up to the gm if he tells it or not.

If there is no use then he could just leave it...
If there is any information on who is BO and who is TOWN (concerning roles) please delete it ASAP.

srsly now.... If you delete it by a mod then it will be obvious that there was a hint in the post. So everyone who was lucky to read it knows for sure that this was a true hint...
So the only thing you can do is to tell people to not reveal info. If they do (or accidentally do) then the GM should PM that person and tell him/her to stop or telling him/her that it could be seen as a hint.

[Detective Tommy]

Asking for the hint/clues that are hints on roles is pretty much the same? Isn't it?

I didn't ask you for the person's role. I asked for the hint's explanation.
It's not exactly the same. Explaining the hints might help give off the role.. but it's still different.

[Kleene Onigiri]

Still you posted that: "Dead players can get the results at the end of the game, just like the alive players."

And the clues/hints are results too ;p And if you get the hit/clues results that are pointing towards roles in the game, then giving you the actually roles isn't much more info anyway.

Well, just explained the ;p
Wasn't meant to offend you either D:

[Detective Tommy]

Still you posted that: "Dead players can get the results at the end of the game, just like the alive players."

And the clues/hints are results too ;p And if you get the hit/clues results that are pointing towards roles in the game, then giving you the actually roles isn't much more info anyway.

Well, just explained the ;p
Wasn't meant to offend you either D:

It's fine, but I just didn't want to be accused of cheating.
And the reason that the Town won.