Mafia - Round 10 Psycho Edition (Town Wins)

[nomemory]

I always thought people to trust people early on are suspicious. But I don't know how they think and maybe they have a good reason or they are trying to pull an xpon sorry xpon. Anyway about lynching, I personally don't have a clue yet. So I will most likely not vote.

[Detective Tommy]

Rhenandriel do a newbie mistake.. and i tricked him so he investigate me.. not knowing that i did the same to him.. ( cross check) and when i gut a result that he is an investigator that makes me believe him..

and when he point you out tommy.. my instict tell me you are a townie.. but you can see.. i keep my role hidden from you right?

Well, considering he didn't die from APTX night 1, then I'm probably not BO.
But it's still too early to trust anyone.

I have crucial evidence that I'm town, but If I tell you guys.. it will also tell you my role.
Which is a problem.

Unless I want to continue my APTX poison streak

Well, we have about 6 hours to discuss.

[Kleene Onigiri]

Rhenandriel do a newbie mistake.. and i tricked him so he investigate me.. not knowing that i did the same to him.. ( cross check) and when i gut a result that he is an investigator that makes me believe him..

and when he point you out tommy.. my instict tell me you are a townie.. but you can see.. i keep my role hidden from you right?

Well, considering he didn't die from APTX night 1, then I'm probably not BO.
But it's still too early to trust anyone.

I have crucial evidence that I'm town, but If I tell you guys.. it will also tell you my role.
Which is a problem.

Unless I want to continue my APTX poison streak

Well, we have about 6 hours to discuss.

APTX is a day ability :p

And I think you just marked yourself for the next death on night 2? O.o"

[PT]

DREAM:

xpon = gin
phoenix = ai
pofa = hakuba
laurell = agasa

that's wat ive received. not sure about the identities of them but i know xpon is 90% townie and laurell is 70% townie. the rest is unknown.

90%? 70%?
Is there any statistics behind this? Or how do you get to those numbers.

Of course, you don't have to tell, especially if it could endanger one of you, but knowing your reasonings why you trust these particular players could be helpful...

Something different... I don't know if it is a good idea to post the roles from the dreams here. Maybe "town" would have been enough for town roles (you could PM the corresponding persons to find out which one is true). This would decrease the chance for APTX poisoning...
Beside... shouldn't a dream contain 5 persons?

Rhenandriel told me his role (Town), but I'm not sure if it is true.
Rhenandriel also told xpon that I knew his (Rhenandriel) role, so xpon PM'ed me claiming to be investigator.

So for all I know, Rhenandriel and xpon told me they're town.
But I have no way to prove it.


Also, it's weird that they both trust me so early on. Because I might be BO.

xpon and I have also been talking because I was curious as to why he said Rhenandriel is 80% townie, and how he knew that. He also told me he has an investigative role.

Now, looking at this logically, if he was Gin (like the dream stated), he probably wouldn't have posted in the forum that Rhenandriel is townie just like that.

[xpon]

I always thought people to trust people early on are suspicious. But I don't know how they think and maybe they have a good reason or they are trying to pull an xpon sorry xpon. Anyway about lynching, I personally don't have a clue yet. So I will most likely not vote.

yeah right!.. ha ha ha

---

@PhoenixTears

yeah.. thanks.. i'll prove my self to you!...

[Detective Tommy]

APTX is a day ability :p

And I think you just marked yourself for the next death on night 2? O.o"

How so?

xpon and I have also been talking because I was curious as to why he said Rhenandriel is 80% townie, and how he knew that. He also told me he has an investigative role.

Now, looking at this logically, if he was Gin (like the dream stated), he probably wouldn't have posted in the forum that Rhenandriel is townie just like that.

True, unless Rhenandriel is BO and xpon thinks he is town. Or vice versa (xpon is BO and Rhenandriel think he is town).
But it's TOO EARLY in the game to decide anything.

[xpon]

if you are a good role.. they will target you!

[PT]

APTX is a day ability :p

And I think you just marked yourself for the next death on night 2? O.o"

How so?

xpon and I have also been talking because I was curious as to why he said Rhenandriel is 80% townie, and how he knew that. He also told me he has an investigative role.

Now, looking at this logically, if he was Gin (like the dream stated), he probably wouldn't have posted in the forum that Rhenandriel is townie just like that.

True, unless Rhenandriel is BO and xpon thinks he is town. Or vice versa (xpon is BO and Rhenandriel think he is town).
But it's TOO EARLY in the game to decide anything.

Well, if it were me in xpon's shoes here: Assuming I'm Gin, I wouldn't just tell everyone that I think Rhenandriel is innocent. If Rhenandriel and I were both BO, that would put him in danger of being found out if everyone else found out I'm BO. If Rhenandriel is not BO, I would already know he's a townie and probably wouldn't tell everyone else because that's one less person for the town to suspect instead of me.

Of course there's still the chance that either one of them is Vermouth disguised as a town role, but I'd say that's more likely Rhenandriel than xpon for pretty much the same reasons as mentioned above.

I don't trust Rhenandriel at all, because I haven't been in touch with him and even xpon's investigation hasn't proven to me that's a townie because of the whole Vermouth angle. I'm taking xpon at his word for now because there's no reason not to. If something comes up later, then I might change that.

[Schillok]

Well, if it were me in xpon's shoes here: Assuming I'm Gin, I wouldn't just tell everyone that I think Rhenandriel is innocent. If Rhenandriel and I were both BO, that would put him in danger of being found out if everyone else found out I'm BO. If Rhenandriel is not BO, I would already know he's a townie and probably wouldn't tell everyone else because that's one less person for the town to suspect instead of me.

Of course there's still the chance that either one of them is Vermouth disguised as a town role, but I'd say that's more likely Rhenandriel than xpon for pretty much the same reasons as mentioned above.

I don't trust Rhenandriel at all, because I haven't been in touch with him and even xpon's investigation hasn't proven to me that's a townie because of the whole Vermouth angle. I'm taking xpon at his word for now because there's no reason not to. If something comes up later, then I might change that.

I have no reason to trust xpon not being Gin.
I mean, he claimed to be an investigative role and the dream delivered the same result. So far there does not seem to be another confirmed role among the ones posted here (I still think it was a bad idea...). Well, it is still strange that your dream is missing one role and contains only 4 person instead of the normal 5. So... yeah, I can't really trust that dream (and its dreamer) either.

Still, it is the best clue we have I guess. Everything else would be even more random.


Well, there are still 4 hours left before the lynching vote. I can only recommend each townie to vote - no matter for who. Better lynching someone who is not known if he is town or BO than to leave everything to the BO.

[Tanner-kun]

Well, if it were me in xpon's shoes here: Assuming I'm Gin, I wouldn't just tell everyone that I think Rhenandriel is innocent. If Rhenandriel and I were both BO, that would put him in danger of being found out if everyone else found out I'm BO. If Rhenandriel is not BO, I would already know he's a townie and probably wouldn't tell everyone else because that's one less person for the town to suspect instead of me.

Of course there's still the chance that either one of them is Vermouth disguised as a town role, but I'd say that's more likely Rhenandriel than xpon for pretty much the same reasons as mentioned above.

I don't trust Rhenandriel at all, because I haven't been in touch with him and even xpon's investigation hasn't proven to me that's a townie because of the whole Vermouth angle. I'm taking xpon at his word for now because there's no reason not to. If something comes up later, then I might change that.

I have no reason to trust xpon not being Gin.
I mean, he claimed to be an investigative role and the dream delivered the same result. So far there does not seem to be another confirmed role among the ones posted here (I still think it was a bad idea...). Well, it is still strange that your dream is missing one role and contains only 4 person instead of the normal 5. So... yeah, I can't really trust that dream (and its dreamer) either.

Still, it is the best clue we have I guess. Everything else would be even more random.


Well, there are still 4 hours left before the lynching vote. I can only recommend each townie to vote - no matter for who. Better lynching someone who is not known if he is town or BO than to leave everything to the BO.

i did vote but for king, god, ctu, gm, kira

[Detective Tommy]

Well, if it were me in xpon's shoes here: Assuming I'm Gin, I wouldn't just tell everyone that I think Rhenandriel is innocent. If Rhenandriel and I were both BO, that would put him in danger of being found out if everyone else found out I'm BO. If Rhenandriel is not BO, I would already know he's a townie and probably wouldn't tell everyone else because that's one less person for the town to suspect instead of me.

Of course there's still the chance that either one of them is Vermouth disguised as a town role, but I'd say that's more likely Rhenandriel than xpon for pretty much the same reasons as mentioned above.

I don't trust Rhenandriel at all, because I haven't been in touch with him and even xpon's investigation hasn't proven to me that's a townie because of the whole Vermouth angle. I'm taking xpon at his word for now because there's no reason not to. If something comes up later, then I might change that.

I have no reason to trust xpon not being Gin.
I mean, he claimed to be an investigative role and the dream delivered the same result. So far there does not seem to be another confirmed role among the ones posted here (I still think it was a bad idea...). Well, it is still strange that your dream is missing one role and contains only 4 person instead of the normal 5. So... yeah, I can't really trust that dream (and its dreamer) either.

Still, it is the best clue we have I guess. Everything else would be even more random.


Well, there are still 4 hours left before the lynching vote. I can only recommend each townie to vote - no matter for who. Better lynching someone who is not known if he is town or BO than to leave everything to the BO.

Maybe the dream was shorten because there are 21 players.
With 5 possibilities, it would be harder to find out who is true.
So he decreased the numbers in the dream, so it's easier to figure out.

I have not made a vote yet because I don't know who to vote for.
But if we don't vote, the BO is at an advantage.

I think we should discuss ideas.

[Kleene Onigiri]

Well, I don't have clues on BO's Just on townies lol! XD

So I dunno who to vote for either.

[Detective Tommy]

Seems like we're in quite a pickle.

[Paix672]

Maybe the dream was shorten because there are 21 players.
With 5 possibilities, it would be harder to find out who is true.
So he decreased the numbers in the dream, so it's easier to figure out.

I have not made a vote yet because I don't know who to vote for.
But if we don't vote, the BO is at an advantage.

I think we should discuss ideas.

If that were the case then Ctu would've probably said it, becasue normally GMs announce changes regarding rules/roles.
I don't have any clues either, so I might abstain, but then they'd have the advantage

[Grawwbear]

I say we spin a stick, and whoever it points to we should lynch.