Mafia - Round 9 (Town wins!)

[Akonyl]

And on the note, neither "A" word sounded like Eisuke.  :P)

Obviously one would avoid such a klutz as Eisuke.  Come on.   ::)   :P

it could also just be unrelated to the role (as was my case), the "avoid" was just because I'd avoided being killed night 1 D:

[CTU]

I admit I didn't trust conia until the phase after James Rye and Detective Tommy died.  I was convinced he was Vermouth disguised as a police officer.

Him trusting James Rye was the only reason I thought he was BO.
But he said he could investigate, so I assumed he was Vermouth as a investigator.

Yep, and we had been talking at that time, so I was in agreement with you.  It was only after you died and I started talking to him that I believed conia was actually a police officer.  And it was so easy at that point to discover that Holmes was Akemi.

Sorry Conia.
I really thought you were BO because you kept helping James Rye (claiming James Black)
When I was James.

Who wouldn't?

How did you find out Ninja stole from me and when?

I told him.

Hey, by the way, I DID steal a gun and glasses from you.

BTW.. if you stole some thing... you cant tell that to the tread right comni? only to you and your allies that not police.. because you'll get arrested right?

That is how it should work

[Abs.]

it could also just be unrelated to the role (as was my case), the "avoid" was just because I'd avoided being killed night 1 D:

Uh what.  "Aggressive" was actually the only reason you were APTXed, dude.

[Detective Tommy]

I admit I didn't trust conia until the phase after James Rye and Detective Tommy died.  I was convinced he was Vermouth disguised as a police officer.

Him trusting James Rye was the only reason I thought he was BO.
But he said he could investigate, so I assumed he was Vermouth as a investigator.

Yep, and we had been talking at that time, so I was in agreement with you.  It was only after you died and I started talking to him that I believed conia was actually a police officer.  And it was so easy at that point to discover that Holmes was Akemi.

Sorry Conia.
I really thought you were BO because you kept helping James Rye (claiming James Black)
When I was James.

Who wouldn't?

How did you find out Ninja stole from me and when?

I told him.

Hey, by the way, I DID steal a gun and glasses from you.

BTW.. if you stole some thing... you cant tell that to the tread right comni? only to you and your allies that not police.. because you'll get arrested right?

You can tell the thread that you stole something, but you wouldn't want to.
Only Kid and Akemi can steal right? Akemi = BO.

So if Kid said he stole, the BO would poison him b/c they know he isn't Akemi.
There is no point in arresting Kid, because he's town. It'll create a disadvantage.

(My thoughts, others may disagree.)

[Conia]

ahhh, seems like I tricked everyone
I think I can add something more: Abs. and Holmes, the 2 pointed as BO in my dream, "blamed" James Rye. I decided to go for Abs. and try to arrest Holmes for killing Schillok (Holmes was Vermouth and Schillok had an apple on his hand when killed, so I took a shot). James Rye played somehow bad when chatting with me: He followed every of my words, never opposed to my ideas when I told him that Ab.s and Holmes were BO. I suppose he didn't know what to do when a crazy guy came to him claiming he trusted him from nowhere ^^

Abs. I always knew you send that PM because I told James Rye about playing with the victim. You just ended being my arresting victim for Night 3...

i wonder who is the mvp

obv conia

I was a total disaster! But if I didn't have connection problems on Night 2, I would have unmasked James Rye quicker

[Detective Tommy]

I asked Kleene to explain all her notes because I was curious. Here is the alphabets one.

3. Night:
The note that was made by me: It's alphabetical. So it's Abs. and Akonyl. (although both words fit here too) I wrote why I choose those words. And what I intended with that.

A: aggression= Abs. (vodka) Well, he's kinda aggressive. And a BO.
avoid = Akonyl (Genta) Tht's not a hint in the role Genta, but that Akonyl avoided to be killed for so long XD He was almost the one who was killed, but they changed the target on the last minute. And he was never voted for lynching either Wink
B: beaten = Beastly (Shinichi); Well, he was lynched and beaten by a mob :x
C: confidence = Commi-ninja (KID(Akai)). Fit's for both roles. And can be interpreted for other roles too. Also possible for Gin or maybe even Vermouth. So it's a small clue.
confusion = Conia (takagi); His plans are so confusing that it even confuses the GM D: Can also be interpreted as a BO who confuses the town.
camouflage = Ctu (Vermouth(Eisuke)); Can be for KID or Vermouth or another BO that is hiding in the town.
D: despair = Detective Tommy (James); He's being accused. So it fits whether he's town or BO. Because you'll be desperate then and feel despair Grin
E: enthusiastic = Elika12 (Mitsuhiko); Also a small hint. But I think it's not that obvious (I hope)
H: help = Holmes (Akemi); Well, this one is interesting. I wrote a small story for the BO and in that Akemi is in Beika City to rob a bank. But since she's already here she has to help out the others in killing townspeople. And on the other hand she's forced to work for the BO (DC story wise) and thus needs help for herself too.
J: jeopardize = James Rye (Calvados); It could mean to be a treat for both sides, either for BO or for town.
K: kind = KainTheVampire (Sonoko); This one is a bit irritating. But I didn't want to give a big clue on Sonoko. Since she doesn't have any active abilities and her purpose is to stay alive or to defend her friend. But Sonoko is kind too, right? ;p
L: leaving = Laurell (Ran); Well, I made that hint before I knew that they use APTX on Laurell XD So it wasn't intended to hint on his death. But more like Shiniche left Ran (in DC) and died in the mafia game too. And it should hint on Makoto too. Since he's able to leave Japan.
N: no-more= nomemory (Sherry); well, it should be clear? Grin
P: passionate = pofa (Heiji); Heiji is hot-blooded. So passionate. Well, that's also a hint on other roles (Yumi, Ran, Sonoko?)
S: sacrifice = Schillok (Megure); First one to die, so a "sacrifice". Could be interpreted as a protecting role too
selfless = Sebolains (Kazuha); She has the charm and gives it to others in order to protect them. So she's selfless. Can also hint on other protection roles.
x: x-tinct = xpon (Camel); He's not playing D: Still didn't hear anything from him ^^"

[Akonyl]

BTW.. if you stole some thing... you cant tell that to the tread right comni? only to you and your allies that not police.. because you'll get arrested right?

That is how it should work

yeah, if commi told conia, tbh that shouldn't technically be allowed imo, but it's just an honor code thing because you can't really enforce PMs that well anyway.

You probably still would have been lynched either way.

it could also just be unrelated to the role (as was my case), the "avoid" was just because I'd avoided being killed night 1 D:

Uh what.  "Aggressive" was actually the only reason you were APTXed, dude.

I'm totally aware of that, but after I died kleene PMed me with all the game's info, and the "aggressive" was actually intended for vodka, and the "avoid" was for me. So the whole me getting aptx'd thing was just pure chance.

Spoiler:

A: aggression= Abs. (vodka) Well, he's kinda aggressive. And a BO.
avoid = Akonyl (Genta) Tht's not a hint in the role Genta, but that Akonyl avoided to be killed for so long XD He was almost the one who was killed, but they changed the target on the last minute. And he was never voted for lynching either Wink
B: beaten = Beastly (Shinichi); Well, he was lynched and beaten by a mob :x
C: confidence = Commi-ninja (KID(Akai)). Fit's for both roles. And can be interpreted for other roles too. Also possible for Gin or maybe even Vermouth. So it's a small clue.
confusion = Conia (takagi); His plans are so confusing that it even confuses the GM D: Can also be interpreted as a BO who confuses the town.
camouflage = Ctu (Vermouth(Eisuke)); Can be for KID or Vermouth or another BO that is hiding in the town.
D: despair = Detective Tommy (James); He's being accused. So it fits whether he's town or BO. Because you'll be desperate then and feel despair Grin
E: enthusiastic = Elika12 (Mitsuhiko); Also a small hint. But I think it's not that obvious (I hope)
H: help = Holmes (Akemi); Well, this one is interesting. I wrote a small story for the BO and in that Akemi is in Beika City to rob a bank. But since she's already here she has to help out the others in killing townspeople. And on the other hand she's forced to work for the BO (DC story wise) and thus needs help for herself too.
J: jeopardize = James Rye (Calvados); It could mean to be a treat for both sides, either for BO or for town.
K: kind = KainTheVampire (Sonoko); This one is a bit irritating. But I didn't want to give a big clue on Sonoko. Since she doesn't have any active abilities and her purpose is to stay alive or to defend her friend. But Sonoko is kind too, right? ;p
L: leaving = Laurell (Ran); Well, I made that hint before I knew that they use APTX on Laurell XD So it wasn't intended to hint on his death. But more like Shiniche left Ran (in DC) and died in the mafia game too. And it should hint on Makoto too. Since he's able to leave Japan.
N: no-more= nomemory (Sherry); well, it should be clear? Grin
P: passionate = pofa (Heiji); Heiji is hot-blooded. So passionate. Well, that's also a hint on other roles (Yumi, Ran, Sonoko?)
S: sacrifice = Schillok (Megure); First one to die, so a "sacrifice". Could be interpreted as a protecting role too
selfless = Sebolains (Kazuha); She has the charm and gives it to others in order to protect them. So she's selfless. Can also hint on other protection roles.
x: x-tinct = xpon (Camel); He's not playing D: Still didn't hear anything from him ^^"

edit: looks like this was already posted. :V

[Detective Tommy]

@Akonyl. LOL, she sent me the EXACT same thing. xD

[Abs.]

Abs. I always knew you send that PM because I told James Rye about playing with the victim. You just ended being my arresting victim for Night 3...

LOL that PM was a bit of crazy unpredictably to complement James Rye's playing style.  ::)

Also!  It does not matter what the GM intended with the hints (LOL) what matters is what most people would think of the hints  

See: Significance of the non-rotten apple.

[Detective Tommy]

See: Significance of the non-rotten apple.

1. Day:
fresh apple = hint on Calvados (James) who killed Schillok (Megure). Vodka is made from Apples too. But Calvados is made from apples (made only from apples I think) and that was said in DC too. Akai said that and compared him to Vermouth who's the rotten apple Wink

[Akonyl]

Also!  It does not matter what the GM intended with the hints (LOL) what matters is what most people would think of the hints  

See: Significance of the non-rotten apple.

I know, right D:

but I've already blamed her for my death so I'm fine with it.

and yeah, I wouldn't have thought to actually look up what calvados is made from with the whole apple hint

[Abs.]

See: Significance of the non-rotten apple.

1. Day:
fresh apple = hint on Calvados (James) who killed Schillok (Megure). Vodka is made from Apples too. But Calvados is made from apples (made only from apples I think) and that was said in DC too. Akai said that and compared him to Vermouth who's the rotten apple Wink

Exactly.  Most people just thought it was Vodka or Vermouth, no one suspected Calvados

[Detective Tommy]

Did Kleene post all her explanations of the hints? (In this thread?)

[Conia]

What about the silver necklace on Night 2?
I hit my head trying to figure out that one, but nothing came to mind D:

[Abs.]

What about the silver necklace on Night 2?
I hit my head trying to figure out that one, but nothing came to mind D:

I just suspected it was Vermouth, since that seems like the kind of thing Vermouth would have worn.