Mafia - Round 9 (Town wins!)

[Detective Tommy]

I honestly don't know about Beastly. He might be Gin, or he might not be an investigator at all and just waited till today to make some stuff up, knowing he'll get the suitcase tonight. Or they might be real. There's not much way to check if he's really an investigator now that he might get the suitcase, unless he's willing to post his results like this every day (which he shouldn't, because it could get a lot of people killed). So he's revealing a lot, but not really anything that can be checked.

Trying not to interfere with the game too much, but: There is a new ability (given to an old role) that can do exactly that: Investigate things that people did in the past. But I won't blame you for not knowing about considering Kleene introduced it right before the round started,

And what has this role?
But letting Beastly survive one night, if he is Gin can be crucial to the game.

James of the FBI can do that though he can only investigate once.

That is if he is Gin, if he´s Akai who also has 5 investigation as night action then he would be a great loss.

We could play *safe* (funny word for that situation) and all vote for xpon. xpon is still the last one who didn´t wrote anything at all. Or did someone got a pm from xpon? Or did he told the GM he´s out of the game for a while?

Or we all vote for whoever we want and watch the result.^g^

We have about 3 hours left, should be enough for a decision.

How would his investigation help us?

But there is absolutely no way we can prove whether he is Gin or Akai.

They both have 5 investigations and they both have BO scent...

[pofa]

As I said above, there's interrogation. Akai would come back "not BO." Of course, if there's a Gin, he could slander and mess up the results, so an interrogator would have to work with someone like Okiya, Sherry, or DBs to prove he's not Gin or Vermouth.

[Detective Tommy]

Let's hope we can lynch a BO.
If Beastly is Akai, we would've lost a good member...


And we need an interrogator to check him.

[Kleene Onigiri]

I didn't get any PM or didn't hear anything from xpon (even on other threads) after he applied on the other thread... So I guess he didn't log in till today? Since he has to go to an internet cafe to come online it's possible he didn't manage till now. Maybe he doesn't even know he's playing?

Anyway, I don't wanna protect  him or anything. And maybe he's also just silent. So in case he keeps on playing silent from this post on it's not my fault if you didn't kill/lynch him from this post onward.
Since he could be BO or town. So you can lynch/kill him anyway. Even if he can't protect himself from accusations.

[Detective Tommy]

I didn't get any PM or didn't hear anything from xpon (even on other threads) after he applied on the other thread... So I guess he didn't log in till today? Since he has to go to an internet cafe to come online it's possible he didn't manage till now. Maybe he doesn't even know he's playing?

Anyway, I don't wanna protect  him or anything. And maybe he's also just silent. So in case he keeps on playing silent from this post on it's not my fault if you didn't kill/lynch him from this post onward.
Since he could be BO or town. So you can lynch/kill him anyway. Even if he can't protect himself from accusations.

Let's say xpon got the dream, would it be possibly to give it to someone else now?
Cause it's kind of unfair...

[Kleene Onigiri]

I didn't get any PM or didn't hear anything from xpon (even on other threads) after he applied on the other thread... So I guess he didn't log in till today? Since he has to go to an internet cafe to come online it's possible he didn't manage till now. Maybe he doesn't even know he's playing?

Anyway, I don't wanna protect  him or anything. And maybe he's also just silent. So in case he keeps on playing silent from this post on it's not my fault if you didn't kill/lynch him from this post onward.
Since he could be BO or town. So you can lynch/kill him anyway. Even if he can't protect himself from accusations.

Let's say xpon got the dream, would it be possibly to give it to someone else now?
Cause it's kind of unfair...

If xpon comes back then 2 people would have gotten the same dream. So no D: XD
And it's always possible that someone lost his i-net and that one got a dream.

[Detective Tommy]

I didn't get any PM or didn't hear anything from xpon (even on other threads) after he applied on the other thread... So I guess he didn't log in till today? Since he has to go to an internet cafe to come online it's possible he didn't manage till now. Maybe he doesn't even know he's playing?

Anyway, I don't wanna protect  him or anything. And maybe he's also just silent. So in case he keeps on playing silent from this post on it's not my fault if you didn't kill/lynch him from this post onward.
Since he could be BO or town. So you can lynch/kill him anyway. Even if he can't protect himself from accusations.

Let's say xpon got the dream, would it be possibly to give it to someone else now?
Cause it's kind of unfair...

If xpon comes back then 2 people would have gotten the same dream. So no D: XD
And it's always possible that someone lost his i-net and that one got a dream.

Crap, that dream could be a huge help.

I haven't voted a lynch yet. Anyone have any ideas who to vote for?

[CTU]

I didn't get any PM or didn't hear anything from xpon (even on other threads) after he applied on the other thread... So I guess he didn't log in till today? Since he has to go to an internet cafe to come online it's possible he didn't manage till now. Maybe he doesn't even know he's playing?

Anyway, I don't wanna protect  him or anything. And maybe he's also just silent. So in case he keeps on playing silent from this post on it's not my fault if you didn't kill/lynch him from this post onward.
Since he could be BO or town. So you can lynch/kill him anyway. Even if he can't protect himself from accusations.

Let's say xpon got the dream, would it be possibly to give it to someone else now?
Cause it's kind of unfair...

If xpon comes back then 2 people would have gotten the same dream. So no D: XD
And it's always possible that someone lost his i-net and that one got a dream.

Crap, that dream could be a huge help.

I haven't voted a lynch yet. Anyone have any ideas who to vote for?

Maybe Beastly? Since he has been in the BO in most of the games so far.

[pofa]

I didn't get any PM or didn't hear anything from xpon (even on other threads) after he applied on the other thread... So I guess he didn't log in till today? Since he has to go to an internet cafe to come online it's possible he didn't manage till now. Maybe he doesn't even know he's playing?

Anyway, I don't wanna protect  him or anything. And maybe he's also just silent. So in case he keeps on playing silent from this post on it's not my fault if you didn't kill/lynch him from this post onward.
Since he could be BO or town. So you can lynch/kill him anyway. Even if he can't protect himself from accusations.

Let's say xpon got the dream, would it be possibly to give it to someone else now?
Cause it's kind of unfair...

If xpon comes back then 2 people would have gotten the same dream. So no D: XD
And it's always possible that someone lost his i-net and that one got a dream.

Crap, that dream could be a huge help.

I haven't voted a lynch yet. Anyone have any ideas who to vote for?

Maybe Beastly? Since he has been in the BO in most of the games so far.

Although that's not a great reason to lynch him, it looks like a lot of people are going to vote Beastly. Maybe I'll do it too, since if we all vote together we'll at least get someone. Since there have been so many claims made today, I think it would be better to lynch someone than to refrain, so we'll have an idea of who to trust next. And while it's possible to prove Beastly's claim to be a town investigator, it would take several roles working together to do so...it might be easier to lynch him.

Although if Beastly's Akai and we lynch him, it looks like Holmes is dead too. I don't know if that's a good thing or not.  We could always go with conia's plan and lynch Abs., since we'll know exactly who to distrust if he's town.

[Detective Tommy]

@Pofa, it looks like most of the players are sleeping right now.
And won't be able to change their vote by the time today ends.

Maybe I'll just leave my vote blank..

[CTU]

I didn't get any PM or didn't hear anything from xpon (even on other threads) after he applied on the other thread... So I guess he didn't log in till today? Since he has to go to an internet cafe to come online it's possible he didn't manage till now. Maybe he doesn't even know he's playing?

Anyway, I don't wanna protect  him or anything. And maybe he's also just silent. So in case he keeps on playing silent from this post on it's not my fault if you didn't kill/lynch him from this post onward.
Since he could be BO or town. So you can lynch/kill him anyway. Even if he can't protect himself from accusations.

Let's say xpon got the dream, would it be possibly to give it to someone else now?
Cause it's kind of unfair...

If xpon comes back then 2 people would have gotten the same dream. So no D: XD
And it's always possible that someone lost his i-net and that one got a dream.

Crap, that dream could be a huge help.

I haven't voted a lynch yet. Anyone have any ideas who to vote for?

Maybe Beastly? Since he has been in the BO in most of the games so far.

Although that's not a great reason to lynch him, it looks like a lot of people are going to vote Beastly. Maybe I'll do it too, since if we all vote together we'll at least get someone. Since there have been so many claims made today, I think it would be better to lynch someone than to refrain, so we'll have an idea of who to trust next. And while it's possible to prove Beastly's claim to be a town investigator, it would take several roles working together to do so...it might be easier to lynch him.

Although if Beastly's Akai and we lynch him, it looks like Holmes is dead too. I don't know if that's a good thing or not.  We could always go with conia's plan and lynch Abs., since we'll know exactly who to distrust if he's town.

Wile I do agree it may not be the best option. It is the only thing I can think of.

[Detective Tommy]

Wile I do agree it may not be the best option. It is the only thing I can think of.

You can lynch Abs?

[Detective Tommy]

I for one think Beastly is not BO, and believe we shouldn't vote him.
Too many people accused him of being BO, without a really good reason.

[Kleene Onigiri]

30 more mins till next phase

[James Rye]

I don´t really know who to vote to be lnyched, so i will just go with xpon. Why not? It will reduce the list and the rest does talk and make it a bit possible to decide who could be maybe a BO or not. By xpon is that impossible.