Mafia--Round 8 (BO WINS)

The home to DCTP Forum Mafia as well as any other type of random forum game that you can conjure up.
Locked
User avatar
Detective Tommy

Posts:
2465

Re: Mafia--Round 8 (Day 2)

Post by Detective Tommy »

nomemory wrote:
Holmes wrote: So, we can assume the one who claims to be Sherry is a girl or who seems to be a girl, as Detective Tommy used "her".
But then again people misuse her and him all the time, and it could be her since it's Sherry.

I for one am still note sure if there is a Sherry or not. But then again right now I'm not really sure about anything.
At this point, I think the roles/rules has too many favors for the BO. :P
But I used she referring to Sherry. This helps prevent giving away the role's identity.

@Ctu - I'm not sure what day/night he told me...

"Well, a child's curiosity and a detective's spirit of inquiry... Do have much in common, after all..." - Tooru Amuro

CTU
*punches Xpon*

Posts:
321

Re: Mafia--Round 8 (Day 2)

Post by CTU »

Detective Tommy wrote:
nomemory wrote:
Holmes wrote: So, we can assume the one who claims to be Sherry is a girl or who seems to be a girl, as Detective Tommy used "her".
But then again people misuse her and him all the time, and it could be her since it's Sherry.

I for one am still note sure if there is a Sherry or not. But then again right now I'm not really sure about anything.
At this point, I think the roles/rules has too many favors for the BO. :P
But I used she referring to Sherry. This helps prevent giving away the role's identity.

@Ctu - I'm not sure what day/night he told me...
well I kinda agree with the rules favoring the ORG, but if you saved the PM you can always check it and look at the send date
Image
Kleene Onigiri wrote: Mafia: Where you fight with unicorns and puppies as your weapons.
xGinx

Posts:
1937

Re: Mafia--Round 8 (Day 2)

Post by xGinx »

Detective Tommy wrote:
nomemory wrote:
Holmes wrote: So, we can assume the one who claims to be Sherry is a girl or who seems to be a girl, as Detective Tommy used "her".
But then again people misuse her and him all the time, and it could be her since it's Sherry.

I for one am still note sure if there is a Sherry or not. But then again right now I'm not really sure about anything.
At this point, I think the roles/rules has too many favors for the BO. :P
But I used she referring to Sherry. This helps prevent giving away the role's identity.

@Ctu - I'm not sure what day/night he told me...
Again, no solid prove against me and yet you're trying to get me lynched even when I'm a Townie, maybe trying too much ?? Isn't that supicious?? Maybe Is that I'm right about Holmes being BO and you're desperatly trying to protect him (Kleene), Am I right??
Image
Anonnymus wrote:[...] Prof decided to rape a giant juice maker using a feather of ostrich [...]
User avatar
Detective Tommy

Posts:
2465

Re: Mafia--Round 8 (Day 2)

Post by Detective Tommy »

xGinx wrote:
Detective Tommy wrote:
nomemory wrote:
Holmes wrote: So, we can assume the one who claims to be Sherry is a girl or who seems to be a girl, as Detective Tommy used "her".
But then again people misuse her and him all the time, and it could be her since it's Sherry.

I for one am still note sure if there is a Sherry or not. But then again right now I'm not really sure about anything.
At this point, I think the roles/rules has too many favors for the BO. :P
But I used she referring to Sherry. This helps prevent giving away the role's identity.

@Ctu - I'm not sure what day/night he told me...
Again, no solid prove against me and yet you're trying to get me lynched even when I'm a Townie, maybe trying too much ?? Isn't that supicious?? Maybe Is that I'm right about Holmes being BO and you're desperatly trying to protect him (Kleene), Am I right??
Considering 5 people know my role already, and most of the BO do too, I am not protecting anyone.

I was told that you had scent by Sherry.
Then Sherry told me that you and Conia wanted to vote Holmes as BO.

This confused me, because I thought you, Conia and Holmes were BO. But now.. I'm doubtful.


And I was again, only stating the things that were told to me.
It's anyone's choice whether to believe. I mentioned that Sherry might be lying and BO.
So you need to chill, because I didn't tell anyone to lynch you. And I always mention my source might be BO.


-edit- I just checked the date/time of the PM, and it was June 8th. Yesterday, which was Night 2?
Last edited by Detective Tommy on June 9th, 2010, 8:46 pm, edited 1 time in total.

"Well, a child's curiosity and a detective's spirit of inquiry... Do have much in common, after all..." - Tooru Amuro

User avatar
Kleene Onigiri
Community Rice Warrior
*punches Akonyl*

Posts:
2479

Re: Mafia--Round 8 (Day 2)

Post by Kleene Onigiri »

Common. How easy can it be?

vote xginx

possible results
1) xGinx is a role with scent. He denied to have been followed,so he wouldn't be Akai
2) xGinx is a townie without scent. Thus the fake sherry is BO. If I don't tell who that fake sherry is, then I'll be in the BO
Meaning, you either kill a BO or you find out about a BO.

And actually, conia knows who's sherry too and said that he knows to someone else (which I didn't know)

So, if xGinx is innocent, then you will find out fake sherrys identity from me, conia or tommy

If sherry dies from aptx today, you'll know that I, conia (or tommy) are suspicious of being  BO.

So, if I tell people my sources, aka, who is sherry, then the possibility of Sherry dieing will increase. And the suspects will increase too


So, please the ones who pmed me please tell me if you vote for xGinx or not
Image
Keyhole drawn by Yuri Iwamoto <3
Spoiler: Secret Santa gift from Commi-Ninja <3
A Black Organization Christmas Carol (need to fix the link)
3DS Friend Code: 4141 3202 3514

༼ つ ◕_◕ ༽つ Giff holidays
CTU
*punches Xpon*

Posts:
321

Re: Mafia--Round 8 (Day 2)

Post by CTU »

Detective Tommy wrote:
xGinx wrote:
Detective Tommy wrote:
nomemory wrote:
Holmes wrote: So, we can assume the one who claims to be Sherry is a girl or who seems to be a girl, as Detective Tommy used "her".
But then again people misuse her and him all the time, and it could be her since it's Sherry.

I for one am still note sure if there is a Sherry or not. But then again right now I'm not really sure about anything.
At this point, I think the roles/rules has too many favors for the BO. :P
But I used she referring to Sherry. This helps prevent giving away the role's identity.

@Ctu - I'm not sure what day/night he told me...
Again, no solid prove against me and yet you're trying to get me lynched even when I'm a Townie, maybe trying too much ?? Isn't that supicious?? Maybe Is that I'm right about Holmes being BO and you're desperatly trying to protect him (Kleene), Am I right??
Considering 5 people know my role already, and most of the BO do too, I am not protecting anyone.

I was told that you had scent by Sherry.
Then Sherry told me that you and Conia wanted to vote Holmes as BO.

This confused me, because I thought you, Conia and Holmes were BO. But now.. I'm doubtful.


And I was again, only stating the things that were told to me.
It's anyone's choice whether to believe. I mentioned that Sherry might be lying and BO.
So you need to chill, because I didn't tell anyone to lynch you. And I always mention my source might be BO.


-edit- I just checked the date/time of the PM, and it was June 8th. Yesterday, which was Night 2?
Night 2 so it is still possible it is a fake Sherry. So Until I hear or see evidence otherwise I will believe Ai might really be Bourbon trying to get us to kill another innocent townie.
Image
Kleene Onigiri wrote: Mafia: Where you fight with unicorns and puppies as your weapons.
xGinx

Posts:
1937

Re: Mafia--Round 8 (Day 2)

Post by xGinx »

Kleene Onigiri wrote: Common. How easy can it be?

vote xginx

possible results
1) xGinx is a role with scent. He denied to have been followed,so he wouldn't be Akai
2) xGinx is a townie without scent. Thus the fake sherry is BO. If I don't tell who that fake sherry is, then I'll be in the BO
Meaning, you either kill a BO or you find out about a BO.

And actually, conia knows who's sherry too and said that he knows to someone else (which I didn't know)

So, if xGinx is innocent, then you will find out fake sherrys identity from me, conia or tommy

If sherry dies from aptx today, you'll know that I, conia (or tommy) are suspicious of being  BO.

So, if I tell people my sources, aka, who is sherry, then the possibility of Sherry dieing will increase. And the suspects will increase too


So, please the ones who pmed me please tell me if you vote for xGinx or not
Trust her, after all she was the one who, as BO, modified the dream last round so we vote and lynch Paix who was Townie xD .... That really makes me believe in you ;D ;D LOL
Image
Anonnymus wrote:[...] Prof decided to rape a giant juice maker using a feather of ostrich [...]
User avatar
Kleene Onigiri
Community Rice Warrior
*punches Akonyl*

Posts:
2479

Re: Mafia--Round 8 (Day 2)

Post by Kleene Onigiri »

Ctu wrote:
Detective Tommy wrote:
xGinx wrote:
Detective Tommy wrote:
nomemory wrote:
Holmes wrote: So, we can assume the one who claims to be Sherry is a girl or who seems to be a girl, as Detective Tommy used "her".
But then again people misuse her and him all the time, and it could be her since it's Sherry.

I for one am still note sure if there is a Sherry or not. But then again right now I'm not really sure about anything.
At this point, I think the roles/rules has too many favors for the BO. :P
But I used she referring to Sherry. This helps prevent giving away the role's identity.

@Ctu - I'm not sure what day/night he told me...
Again, no solid prove against me and yet you're trying to get me lynched even when I'm a Townie, maybe trying too much ?? Isn't that supicious?? Maybe Is that I'm right about Holmes being BO and you're desperatly trying to protect him (Kleene), Am I right??
Considering 5 people know my role already, and most of the BO do too, I am not protecting anyone.

I was told that you had scent by Sherry.
Then Sherry told me that you and Conia wanted to vote Holmes as BO.

This confused me, because I thought you, Conia and Holmes were BO. But now.. I'm doubtful.


And I was again, only stating the things that were told to me.
It's anyone's choice whether to believe. I mentioned that Sherry might be lying and BO.
So you need to chill, because I didn't tell anyone to lynch you. And I always mention my source might be BO.


-edit- I just checked the date/time of the PM, and it was June 8th. Yesterday, which was Night 2?
Night 2. So Until I hear otherwise I will believe  Ai might really be Bourbon trying to get us to kill another innocent townie.
.
?

If sherry follows someone on day 1. then she'll get the results on night 2. And saying that on night 2 is correct

Mafia starts with Night 1, day 1, night 2, day 2....
so there is no chance for sherry to get results before night 2....
Image
Keyhole drawn by Yuri Iwamoto <3
Spoiler: Secret Santa gift from Commi-Ninja <3
A Black Organization Christmas Carol (need to fix the link)
3DS Friend Code: 4141 3202 3514

༼ つ ◕_◕ ༽つ Giff holidays
User avatar
Kleene Onigiri
Community Rice Warrior
*punches Akonyl*

Posts:
2479

Re: Mafia--Round 8 (Day 2)

Post by Kleene Onigiri »

xGinx wrote:
Kleene Onigiri wrote: Common. How easy can it be?

vote xginx

possible results
1) xGinx is a role with scent. He denied to have been followed,so he wouldn't be Akai
2) xGinx is a townie without scent. Thus the fake sherry is BO. If I don't tell who that fake sherry is, then I'll be in the BO
Meaning, you either kill a BO or you find out about a BO.

And actually, conia knows who's sherry too and said that he knows to someone else (which I didn't know)

So, if xGinx is innocent, then you will find out fake sherrys identity from me, conia or tommy

If sherry dies from aptx today, you'll know that I, conia (or tommy) are suspicious of being  BO.

So, if I tell people my sources, aka, who is sherry, then the possibility of Sherry dieing will increase. And the suspects will increase too


So, please the ones who pmed me please tell me if you vote for xGinx or not
Trust her, after all she was the one who, as BO, modified the dream last round so we vote and lynch Paix who was Townie xD .... That really makes me believe in you ;D ;D LOL
So, because I was BO last game I'm BO again this game? That's a reasonable explanation?
Image
Keyhole drawn by Yuri Iwamoto <3
Spoiler: Secret Santa gift from Commi-Ninja <3
A Black Organization Christmas Carol (need to fix the link)
3DS Friend Code: 4141 3202 3514

༼ つ ◕_◕ ༽つ Giff holidays
Akonyl
Community Hero

Posts:
4200

Re: Mafia--Round 8 (Day 2)

Post by Akonyl »

I'd just like to say that somewhere in these recent pages is a not-so-sound piece of logic but I won't say it because I don't know which way this lynch vote is going :O
xGinx

Posts:
1937

Re: Mafia--Round 8 (Day 2)

Post by xGinx »

Kleene Onigiri wrote:
xGinx wrote:
Kleene Onigiri wrote: Common. How easy can it be?

vote xginx

possible results
1) xGinx is a role with scent. He denied to have been followed,so he wouldn't be Akai
2) xGinx is a townie without scent. Thus the fake sherry is BO. If I don't tell who that fake sherry is, then I'll be in the BO
Meaning, you either kill a BO or you find out about a BO.

And actually, conia knows who's sherry too and said that he knows to someone else (which I didn't know)

So, if xGinx is innocent, then you will find out fake sherrys identity from me, conia or tommy

If sherry dies from aptx today, you'll know that I, conia (or tommy) are suspicious of being  BO.

So, if I tell people my sources, aka, who is sherry, then the possibility of Sherry dieing will increase. And the suspects will increase too


So, please the ones who pmed me please tell me if you vote for xGinx or not
Trust her, after all she was the one who, as BO, modified the dream last round so we vote and lynch Paix who was Townie xD .... That really makes me believe in you ;D ;D LOL
So, because I was BO last game I'm BO again this game? That's a reasonable explanation?
Is as good as you telling everybody to vote me when even you don't know if the person who is claiming to be Sheery is not a BO himself. As reasonable as that ... also what I said shows that you are quite good at modifying things to mislead people in another direction than the BO and make them vote for a Townie like you already did.

As reasonable as yours ;D ;D
Image
Anonnymus wrote:[...] Prof decided to rape a giant juice maker using a feather of ostrich [...]
User avatar
Detective Tommy

Posts:
2465

Re: Mafia--Round 8 (Day 2)

Post by Detective Tommy »

I give up, I wish I had a better role..
Because I think this game has already been determined.

"Well, a child's curiosity and a detective's spirit of inquiry... Do have much in common, after all..." - Tooru Amuro

CTU
*punches Xpon*

Posts:
321

Re: Mafia--Round 8 (Day 2)

Post by CTU »

Kleene Onigiri wrote:
Ctu wrote:
Detective Tommy wrote:
xGinx wrote:
Detective Tommy wrote:
nomemory wrote:
Holmes wrote: So, we can assume the one who claims to be Sherry is a girl or who seems to be a girl, as Detective Tommy used "her".
But then again people misuse her and him all the time, and it could be her since it's Sherry.

I for one am still note sure if there is a Sherry or not. But then again right now I'm not really sure about anything.
At this point, I think the roles/rules has too many favors for the BO. :P
But I used she referring to Sherry. This helps prevent giving away the role's identity.

@Ctu - I'm not sure what day/night he told me...
Again, no solid prove against me and yet you're trying to get me lynched even when I'm a Townie, maybe trying too much ?? Isn't that supicious?? Maybe Is that I'm right about Holmes being BO and you're desperatly trying to protect him (Kleene), Am I right??
Considering 5 people know my role already, and most of the BO do too, I am not protecting anyone.

I was told that you had scent by Sherry.
Then Sherry told me that you and Conia wanted to vote Holmes as BO.

This confused me, because I thought you, Conia and Holmes were BO. But now.. I'm doubtful.


And I was again, only stating the things that were told to me.
It's anyone's choice whether to believe. I mentioned that Sherry might be lying and BO.
So you need to chill, because I didn't tell anyone to lynch you. And I always mention my source might be BO.


-edit- I just checked the date/time of the PM, and it was June 8th. Yesterday, which was Night 2?
Night 2. So Until I hear otherwise I will believe  Ai might really be Bourbon trying to get us to kill another innocent townie.
.
?

If sherry follows someone on day 1. then she'll get the results on night 2. And saying that on night 2 is correct

Mafia starts with Night 1, day 1, night 2, day 2....
so there is no chance for sherry to get results before night 2....
True, but she could have stated her role to somebody before then. If she told somebody on night one then there would be no way for it to be Bourbon. Also has anybody interrogated her to see if she is ORG or not or tried to confirm her identity in any way?
Image
Kleene Onigiri wrote: Mafia: Where you fight with unicorns and puppies as your weapons.
xGinx

Posts:
1937

Re: Mafia--Round 8 (Day 2)

Post by xGinx »

Detective Tommy wrote: I give up, I wish I had a better role..
Because I think this game has already been determined.
Not quite, If we lynch Holmes (BO) tonight we can still win, but not with that actitud of yours xD
Image
Anonnymus wrote:[...] Prof decided to rape a giant juice maker using a feather of ostrich [...]
User avatar
Kleene Onigiri
Community Rice Warrior
*punches Akonyl*

Posts:
2479

Re: Mafia--Round 8 (Day 2)

Post by Kleene Onigiri »

Oh, btw. Kain was Kid disguised as Araide. And someone told me that xGinx said that he can heal.
Sherry said that Tommy said that his interrogation friend got a "not BO" from xGinx.
But it's possible for Vermouth to disguise as araide too! There as a round where I as vermouth and Kid disguised both as ran.

Also, we know from tommy that there is Gin in the game. so xGinx could have been slandered.
I have gathered a lot of information. Thus I deducted a lot and I'm sure xGinx is a BO.

I was never as persistent in accusing someone as in this case. I wouldn't do that as a BO, because that's too suspicious. And I could just sacrifice a BO member and make me look inocent instead, But as you cans see, I don't do that and keep my target, who is xGinx
Image
Keyhole drawn by Yuri Iwamoto <3
Spoiler: Secret Santa gift from Commi-Ninja <3
A Black Organization Christmas Carol (need to fix the link)
3DS Friend Code: 4141 3202 3514

༼ つ ◕_◕ ༽つ Giff holidays
Locked