Mafia--Round 8 (BO WINS)

[Conia]

[quote="Kleene Onigiri"]
So, we need another one to vote for huh?
In case there is makoto in the game (and reads this):
-May choose to protect any number of people at day. If one of the protected people is going to get lynched, he will jump in and stop the lynching. Since he's much better in self-defence than Ran, he will not die in the process. Therefore the meant-to-be-lynched stays alive (and his identity remains secret).

Meaning Makoto can protect everyone during the day today! So no one get's lynched which would resemble a tie. Of course you don't have to do that.

So, another clues we have is the dream. So lynching one of these would be a suggestion.
Another thing I thought about was, that pofa said that she'll give out hints.

What we got after night 1:
[quote]It takes a couple of hours for word-of-mouth to reach the outskirts of the village, but by breakfast-time the entire village of Beika is crowded into the open town hall building, staring in shock at the bloody scene before them.

“What was he doing out so late at night?â€

[Schillok]

But no DB will come out and say they're DB.

Why not? A DB could be either Ayumi, Genta or Mitsuhiko, so the chance of getting killed by APTX is low.
I am not sure if there is any other way to prove xpons claim otherwise. The DB could show that you and him are really town. Or they could prove that you are both BO.


It is getting late, and there are 3 suspects: xpon, Conia or Holmes. We need to decide for one now. Are we trying our chances with one of the two from the dream? Or do we wait a night to confirm their roles first and lynch xpon first?

I suggest if there are DB willing to check xpon we should go for the dream. Otherwise I suggest xpon.

[Commi-Ninja]

i didn't say anything about lynching you XD i just didn't know about the thing about BO and best friends
and for all i know you can still be Vermouth... ^^

and what i meant with other best friend is:
if we listen to what xpon said about him being Sonoko... i don't think his best friends is you...
so the other best friend is the one that isn't Sonoko, that's what i meant ^^

Well, if I lie and said I was xpon's best friend... and if it isn't true, then xpon would let you know.
And if I lied.. then I automatically go under suspicion and I'll be lynched.

Well, If Xpon is lying and he is BO then we get for sure at least another BO (you) and maybe another one (Paix) who defended him too and if he's Townie then we have a Townie to trust (You) and maybe another one (Paix) .... Sounds good enought to risk us to vote him right?

But we have a bigger lead. Commi's dream has 2 known false, 2BO and 1Townie.
If we lynch one of the BO from his dream, it's a higher chance than suspicion lynching..

I agree, but I still don't trust xpon either.
Which would leave Holmes or conia.  If we lynch one and they turn out to be a townie, the other should be B.O., as Ctu informed me that Yumi is not his role.

[Detective Tommy]

But no DB will come out and say they're DB.

Why not? A DB could be either Ayumi, Genta or Mitsuhiko, so the chance of getting killed by APTX is low.
I am not sure if there is any other way to prove xpons claim otherwise. The DB could show that you and him are really town. Or they could prove that you are both BO.


It is getting late, and there are 3 suspects: xpon, Conia or Holmes. We need to decide for one now. Are we trying our chances with one of the two from the dream? Or do we wait a night to confirm their roles first and lynch xpon first?

I suggest if there are DB willing to check xpon we should go for the dream. Otherwise I suggest xpon.

We should go for the dream.
Because, the chances of me being killed by BO tonight is high.
And if you kill xpon, then Sonoko's ability goes to waste.

I agree, but I still don't trust xpon either.
Which would leave Holmes or conia.  If we lynch one and they turn out to be a townie, the other should be B.O., as Ctu informed me that Yumi is not his role.

For the dream, the 3 people that claimed their roles were wrong...
Of those 3, they were all town. So if it's false.. there is possibility that they are BO.

[Holmes]

Is anyone suspicious? Don´t know who to lynch.

[Schillok]

I agree, but I still don't trust xpon either.
Which would leave Holmes or conia.  If we lynch one and they turn out to be a townie, the other should be B.O., as Ctu informed me that Yumi is not his role.

So... take the 44% chance that either of them is BO and we get it right? Or wait until tomorrow to get it to 100%, and lynch xpon today to see if he was telling the truth or not?
What should we do?

[Kleene Onigiri]

Continuing my deduction of pofas post:

What akonyl posted:

I thought we agreed I'd get every ability

Damn, I forgot. Hang on, I'll fix it.

thanks. I'm not sure how else you expect me to kill everyone when I can't snipe them from england.

it is only about 5966 MI anybody can make that shot


lol

well geez, we can't all be as excellent snipers as you are, Korn.

Why?  He pretty much came right out at the beginning last time saying he was Sherry.

this is true. So, who knows, I guess.

I'm not Gin.
Wait, do all the BO members know the other BO members?
Why wouldn't you want Vermouth as your best friend? o.o
Slightly confused, again..

All BO members know all other BO members.
Sonoko doesn't want Vermouth as a best friend because Vermouth is evil.

You're still not fooling me, Gin.

I'd like to know what the new players think so far ..... Anyone want to express your thoughts??

I'm afraid to speak in the thread, lol.

but that's all the fun!

Haha, the game just started so it's not exactly exciting yet. xD

you would say that, because you haven't killed anyone... GIN!

you're less suspicious than xpon because me thinking you're suspicious is based on how suspicious I think xpon is. Given how suspicious I think his posts look, I'm suspicious of your willingness to make a pact with him so easily.

you're also less suspicious than xpon because you said a total of 6 words.

as for vermouth, that is also very true. However, depending on how many people make the alliance you may be able to sniff out that odd dissenting voice and lynch them later. But either way, that doesn't seem like a problem since nobody else has mentioned forming the alliance and I've yet to get any PMs about it, so I don't think it's gonna happen.
as for lovers, pretending to investigate the same things as your lover wouldn't work because each person has to investigate people investigating themselves, and the other investigators would get false reports back when they investigate " investigates me".

Don't know, last game xpon was acting quite suspicious as well but he ended up being the role he claimed. Of course his little play confused us more than it helped...

The main problem is that forming the alliance requires a start. A start without any non-investigators, because to be blunt... at the moment the most likely role that comes to my mind when I heard that you wanted all investigators to contact you, is Irish.

honestly, last game xpon wasn't all that suspicious imo (I might be biased because I knew he was a townie), I just found reasons that I could call him suspicious for. As for me being Irish, I'm not sure why you think that, because my plan doesn't require people to say if they're FBI/police/detective/shinichi/satou/etc, just that they can investigate. There was a self-proclaimed investigator that PMed me (and probably PMed you all also), so if you want to make a pact with them instead of me, feel free.

also, the reason xpon seems suspicious isn't just because he wants to make an alliance, it's because he's specifically looking for a detective to prove his innocence in order to form an alliance. To me, xpon's posts scream "I am anokata or I have Gin slandering me, I want a detective to check me out because I know I'll pop up innocent". His way of speech also makes me think he's lying, however I won't go into detail on that.

Best reason XD So putting it simply, I'm less suspicious because I just agreed without much explanation which I usually do i guess?

I haven't noticed this, but either way trusting someone too easily isn't a good idea.

Oh right @lovers. Well, I thought the investigation thingy wouldn't be like a circle in investigation other people etc. But if you decide who will investigate who and you're a BO, then you could make it look like the BO can investigate (pairing BOs to "investigate" each other) D: Although that's kinda risky.

the idea is that every person investigates every other person inside the pact, thus you don't need to rely on anybody's word other than your own. So, there would be no way to make it look like anything. Of course, this pact can't be more than 4 people (or yumi, who can only do 2), but that would probably not be a problem. Also, because there's only 5 hours left until the next phase, I don't think this is all gonna happen anyway.

So people that Akonyl accused of being BO:
Detective Tommy as Gin and Ctu as Korn

People that Akonyl found suspicious:
xpon and Kleene Onigiri (damn you a-chan D:)

Well, I have to go to bed soon too.

Since Ctu isn't yumi, we have a good chance for Holmes or conia. If people go for my deduction, we also have Tommy and Ctu... and xpon and me D:

[xGinx]

Is anyone suspicious? Don´t know who to lynch.

Only 3, Xpon (Claiming to be Sonoko but then PMing Schillok saying he wasn't Sonoko), Conia and You. Who you going to vote??

[Detective Tommy]

I agree, but I still don't trust xpon either.
Which would leave Holmes or conia.  If we lynch one and they turn out to be a townie, the other should be B.O., as Ctu informed me that Yumi is not his role.

So... take the 44% chance that either of them is BO and we get it right? Or wait until tomorrow to get it to 100%, and lynch xpon today to see if he was telling the truth or not?
What should we do?

If you lynch xpon, his ability will be wasted.
If you go with the dream tonight, theres a chance we can get a BO. It's 100% higher chance than lynching xpon..
And then let's see what happens tonight.

So people that Akonyl accused of being BO:
Detective Tommy as Gin and Ctu as Korn

People that Akonyl found suspicious:
xpon and Kleene Onigiri (damn you a-chan D:)

Well, I have to go to bed soon too.

Since Ctu isn't yumi, we have a good chance for Holmes or conia. If people go for my deduction, we also have Tommy and Ctu... and xpon and me D:

I know for sure, me and xpon aren't. Just saying..
Let's just go with the dream tonight. If we accidently kill a townie, then tomorrow you can lynch me.

[KainTheVampire]

i've already voted i did it a long time ago ^^

but anyway, i need to sleep now since i'm going up early tomorrow (and i'm saying this since xpon will accuse me of being suspicious because i'm not saying anything -.-')
so good night good and bad guys  i hope you sleep well when you're going to bed later XD

[Detective Tommy]

i've already voted i did it a long time ago ^^

but anyway, i need to sleep now since i'm going up early tomorrow (and i'm saying this since xpon will accuse me of being suspicious because i'm not saying anything -.-')
so good night good and bad guys  i hope you sleep well when you're going to bed later XD

I seriously hope you made a good choice....... Which I have a feeling you didn't.
And you can always change your lynch vote.

[xGinx]

Continuing my deduction of pofas post:

What akonyl posted:



So people that Akonyl accused of being BO:
Detective Tommy as Gin and Ctu as Korn

People that Akonyl found suspicious:
xpon and Kleene Onigiri (damn you a-chan D:)

Well, I have to go to bed soon too.

Since Ctu isn't yumi, we have a good chance for Holmes or conia. If people go for my deduction, we also have Tommy and Ctu... and xpon and me D:

Six suscpects but only 3 looks really suspicious and we have more chance of lynching a BO that way: Detective Tommy (Who might be lying and covering Xpon so noone figures out him being BO, also waited until the 15th time we asked him to give us an answer), Xpon (Who I usually trust but he claimed to be Sonoko and then say he wasn't, if he isn't Sonoko then Detective Tommy might also be lying as well) and Holmes (I don't see him as a threat just for a dream that we don't know if it wasn't modified, if it's true if he lied)

---

I'll ask you again Kain, plz tell me what the answer of your investigation was, that might help us much.

[Commi-Ninja]

You forgot about conia, there.

[KainTheVampire]

i've already voted i did it a long time ago ^^

but anyway, i need to sleep now since i'm going up early tomorrow (and i'm saying this since xpon will accuse me of being suspicious because i'm not saying anything -.-')
so good night good and bad guys  i hope you sleep well when you're going to bed later XD

I seriously hope you made a good choice....... Which I have a feeling you didn't.
And you can always change your lynch vote.

i can? o.O
thanks for the info XD
i changed my mind about who i want to lynch you see.... so i just have to write that to Pofa?

[Detective Tommy]

i've already voted i did it a long time ago ^^

but anyway, i need to sleep now since i'm going up early tomorrow (and i'm saying this since xpon will accuse me of being suspicious because i'm not saying anything -.-')
so good night good and bad guys  i hope you sleep well when you're going to bed later XD

I seriously hope you made a good choice....... Which I have a feeling you didn't.
And you can always change your lynch vote.

i can? o.O
thanks for the info XD
i changed my mind about who i want to lynch you see.... so i just have to write that to Pofa?

Yes, you just tell him you want to change your vote and tell him the new person..