DCTP Forums

Last time, Captured in Her Eyes completely destroyed The Jolly Roger in the Deep Azure. This time, we have another lopsided seeming matchup.

Movie 5: Countdown to Heaven


vs.

Movie 10: The Private Eyes, Requiem


The thread that explains the contest

The bracket that shows how pairings are determined and which movies have been eliminated:

5 better win this, even though I doubt it will, since 10 is basically fanservice.

Movie 10.
About the 5th, I didn't like the car part and Gin confusing Sonoko with Shiho just by the similar hairstyle.

PhoenixTears wrote: 5 better win this, even though I doubt it will, since 10 is basically fanservice.

I think five has won pretty much every poll/contest it's been in, so I wouldn't be too nervous (yet).

I voted for 10 entirely because 5 will beat factually better earlier movies otherwise.

I don't mind the fanservice aspect of 10.

Mostly I just really don't care much for Countdown to Heaven.  It's not a bad movie, but there are plenty that are better both with plot and plot-execution.

5, duh.
10 had no unity in it, really. Most of the time I was thinking why a certain part had to be in it.

Commi-Ninja wrote: Mostly I just really don't care much for Countdown to Heaven.  It's not a bad movie, but there are plenty that are better both with plot and plot-execution.

This.

kkslider5552000 wrote: I voted for 10 entirely because 5 will beat factually better earlier movies otherwise.

I agree that Countdown has a reputation that eclipses its quality by a decent amount, but when the gulf in quality is so large, I can't quite come around to this sort of logic, though I certainly understand it.

dilbertschalter wrote:

kkslider5552000 wrote: I voted for 10 entirely because 5 will beat factually better earlier movies otherwise.

I agree that Countdown has a reputation that eclipses its quality by a decent amount, but when the gulf in quality is so large, I can't quite come around to this sort of logic, though I certainly understand it.

Well 10 will lose soon enough regardless so...

5 will win!!! I swear it!

10 was great, but 5 was EPIC.

humm, I'd say ten, since 5 wasn't all that awesome....
(I mean... that trick with the car... just wut?)

Both are overrated but 5 is better.

5 because of the Physics part ^_^
And there's BO in it too.
I don't like 10. I was bored the whole movie.