Discussion Thread: Detective Conan Files 818-824 "Mystery Tr

[asanez2008]

Spoiler:

Do you think that she will use the same hat if she is scar Akai? It'd be too obvious. What about Scar Akai stealing the hat just for making her seem suspicious?

Spoiler:

I didn't even suspect her of being scar Akai. Well i do think that scar Akai might have stole it but not to make her suspicious though. Maybe scar Akai went to Sera's room and took her hat for some reason.
 

[Chekhov MacGuffin]

Do you think that she will use the same hat if she is scar Akai? It'd be too obvious. What about Scar Akai stealing the hat just for making her seem suspicious?

I didn't even suspect her of being scar Akai. Well i do think that scar Akai might have stole it but not to make her suspicious though. Maybe scar Akai went to Sera's room and took her hat for some reason.

The train has a formal/semiformal clothing dresscode based on what everyone else is wearing. A cap would be unacceptable, so Scar Akai upgraded to fedora.

[asanez2008]

Spoiler:

Do you think that she will use the same hat if she is scar Akai? It'd be too obvious. What about Scar Akai stealing the hat just for making her seem suspicious?

Spoiler:

I didn't even suspect her of being scar Akai. Well i do think that scar Akai might have stole it but not to make her suspicious though. Maybe scar Akai went to Sera's room and took her hat for some reason.
 

Spoiler:

The train has a formal/semiformal clothing dresscode based on what everyone else is wearing. A cap would be unacceptable, so Scar Akai upgraded to fedora.

Spoiler:

You're right he is wearing a Fedora. But I don't think he have the right hat for his disguise. http://imgsrc.baidu.com/forum/pic/item/ ... 345b6c.jpg
There's someone behind scar Akai with the same dress as him. But that person have a hat that similar to a cap.
That's why i think maybe scar Akai stole it from Sera.
http://imgsrc.baidu.com/forum/pic/item/ ... cb3e80.jpg
Look, Sera have a hat similar to what scar Akai wearing. Then it was gone during the time Conan and the rest meet her inside the train.
http://imgsrc.baidu.com/forum/pic/item/ ... cebf98.jpg
It's weird...it's all about hats, hats, hats

[Chekhov MacGuffin]

The train has a formal/semiformal clothing dresscode based on what everyone else is wearing. A cap would be unacceptable, so Scar Akai upgraded to fedora.

You're right he is wearing a Fedora. But I don't think he have the right hat for his disguise. http://imgsrc.baidu.com/forum/pic/item/ ... 345b6c.jpg
There's someone behind scar Akai with the same dress as him. But that person have a hat that similar to a cap.
That's why i think maybe scar Akai stole it from Sera.
http://imgsrc.baidu.com/forum/pic/item/ ... cb3e80.jpg
Look, Sera have a hat similar to what scar Akai wearing. Then it was gone during the time Conan and the rest meet her inside the train.
http://imgsrc.baidu.com/forum/pic/item/ ... cebf98.jpg
It's weird...it's all about hats, hats, hats

A fedora is pretty much the nicest, formal, modern, man's hat available that conceals one's face. There aren't many other non silly options (a bowler?, a tophat? ) up to the standard of dress that would work in this setting. The guy behind Scar Akai is a steward who works for the train and the cap is part of his uniform. Agasa's hat (seen on pg 4) disappeared as well. Sera and Agasa probably took them off because they were polite. Scar Akai is being sneaky and has decided to ignore the rule about hats indoors.

[lol]

On the whole hat thing,

Spoiler:

we can actually see Akai's eyes from under the hat a little here.
Also the culprit's hat is very similar to Amuro's hat...as seen here. Not saying that Amuro is the killer because he doesn't have a reason to kill a random guy on the train but just throwing that out there in the hat conversation  :P

[GinRei]

Spoiler:

The train has a formal/semiformal clothing dresscode based on what everyone else is wearing. A cap would be unacceptable, so Scar Akai upgraded to fedora.

Okay, this just made me think of something that sonoci needs to draw:

Spoiler:

Remember when he smirked at Chianti in the red shirt case?  Okay, slap a fedora on him with one of those giant ass feathers.  Now have him give her a two-finger salute, and maybe add a few "gentleman sparkles" (ala Armstrong from FMA) and you got comedy gold.

[APTX37]

hey guys,,,,,i've always been an anime watcher but i've decided recently to move to manga,,,,,,,mostly because of my lack of pations
why am i telling u this right?? well its because i dont get how did u get the 818 file while it's Supposed to be released on the 23rd
i thought the answear would be in the spoilers but i really dont want to spoil this file because am very very excited for it,,,,,thuogh i've already spoiled that there is no shiho (((((

[Partsu]

we cheat...
they ain't called spoilers for nothing you know...


No I don't know where/how DCTP gets them...

[Nanatsu no Ko]

Spoiler:

Is there a possibility that this Scar Akai actually is Akai? The way the hat covers his eyes makes me wonder.

[believer08]

Spoiler:

Is there a possibility that this Scar Akai actually is Akai? The way the hat covers his eyes makes me wonder.

Spoiler:

It makes no sense to me... Chek's theories explain why He's probably not The real one

[Nanatsu no Ko]

Spoiler:

Is there a possibility that this Scar Akai actually is Akai? The way the hat covers his eyes makes me wonder.

Spoiler:

It makes no sense to me... Chek's theories explain why He's probably not The real one

Spoiler:

Just to be clear, where can I find Chek's theories on this Scar Akai (I've only seen Chek's train location theories for this case). I am assuming that this Scar Akai is not the same as the previous Scar Akai. Chek's theory is that Okiya is actual Akai, correct? Was there something that indicated Okiya is in a certain location this case?

[shihokudo]

ASDOVINAODINAOIDNOAIFNWOERHA
I'M OVEREXCITED NOW

[Chekhov MacGuffin]

Just to be clear, where can I find Chek's theories on this Scar Akai (I've only seen Chek's train location theories for this case). I am assuming that this Scar Akai is not the same as the previous Scar Akai. Chek's theory is that Okiya is actual Akai, correct? Was there something that indicated Okiya is in a certain location this case?

The full analysis of the case will be posted for the English release, so there isn't a 818 Chek's theory, yet.

With the standard absence of English disclaimer, I see no reason to believe that anyone, this scar Akai included, is different from their normal identities. I think this guy is Amuro/Bourbon. Scar Akai is wearing nicer/weirder clothes because the dresscode is better. The scar is different because Gosho draws the scar with variability. If you make a collage of all the Scar Akai scars you will see it changes panel to panel. Even if you want to assume the scar is different that doesn't mean the guy underneath the disguise is different.

As for Okiya, I am assuming he is on the train because the plot demand it, but he hasn't shown up yet because Gosho didn't want to try to cram everyone in this chapter.

[believer08]

Spoiler:

Just to be clear, where can I find Chek's theories on this Scar Akai (I've only seen Chek's train location theories for this case). I am assuming that this Scar Akai is not the same as the previous Scar Akai. Chek's theory is that Okiya is actual Akai, correct? Was there something that indicated Okiya is in a certain location this case?

Spoiler:

The full analysis of the case will be posted for the English release, so there isn't a 818 Chek's theory, yet.

With the standard absence of English disclaimer, I see no reason to believe that anyone, this scar Akai included, is different from their normal identities. I think this guy is Amuro/Bourbon. Scar Akai is wearing nicer/weirder clothes because the dresscode is better. The scar is different because Gosho draws the scar with variability. If you make a collage of all the Scar Akai scars you will see it changes panel to panel. Even if you want to assume the scar is different that doesn't mean the guy underneath the disguise is different.

As for Okiya, I am assuming he is on the train because the plot demand it, but he hasn't shown up yet because Gosho didn't want to try to cram everyone in this chapter.

Spoiler:

Okiya will probably show up in the second file of this case or even after. Or, he is actually here, with a disguise. We can't say for sure now. Maybe he'll surprise us

[sonoci]

Spoiler:

Just to be clear, where can I find Chek's theories on this Scar Akai (I've only seen Chek's train location theories for this case). I am assuming that this Scar Akai is not the same as the previous Scar Akai. Chek's theory is that Okiya is actual Akai, correct? Was there something that indicated Okiya is in a certain location this case?

Spoiler:

The full analysis of the case will be posted for the English release, so there isn't a 818 Chek's theory, yet.

With the standard absence of English disclaimer, I see no reason to believe that anyone, this scar Akai included, is different from their normal identities. I think this guy is Amuro/Bourbon. Scar Akai is wearing nicer/weirder clothes because the dresscode is better. The scar is different because Gosho draws the scar with variability. If you make a collage of all the Scar Akai scars you will see it changes panel to panel. Even if you want to assume the scar is different that doesn't mean the guy underneath the disguise is different.

As for Okiya, I am assuming he is on the train because the plot demand it, but he hasn't shown up yet because Gosho didn't want to try to cram everyone in this chapter.

Spoiler:

Okiya will probably show up in the second file of this case or even after. Or, he is actually here, with a disguise. We can't say for sure now. Maybe he'll surprise us

Spoiler:

Everyone be on the lookout for any characters cooking cream stew at inopportune moments!

:X