Anyone else here think Kogoro knows that Conan uses him?

Forum reserved for discussing specific points of the story—mostly from the manga. Be warned, these discussions will be current with the manga and will spoil many plot lines for anime-centric fans.
User avatar
Chekhov MacGuffin
Community Scholar
BAGA BGEGD EDBDEG A

Posts:
2684

Re: Anyone else here think Kogoro knows that Conan uses him?

Post by Chekhov MacGuffin »

mangaluva wrote: I think Conan might drop it soon, I think a while back he was talking to Agasa about the dart taking longer to take effect or something.
He was wondering with Agasa about why the dart didn't affect Gin as well as he thought it would have after the Haido City Hotel case, but I can't think of another time Conan wondered about it...
Last edited by Chekhov MacGuffin on March 15th, 2010, 10:30 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Abs.
DCTP Staff Hero

Posts:
3270

Re: Anyone else here think Kogoro knows that Conan uses him?

Post by Abs. »

Chekhov MacGuffin wrote:
mangaluva wrote: I think Conan might drop it soon, I think a while back he was talking to Agasa about the dart taking longer to take effect or something.
He was wondering with Agasa about why the dart didn't affect Gin as well as he thought it would have after the Haido City Hotel case, but I can't think of another time Conan wondered about it...
Must have been an AO then.
Your opinion is always requested in Abs.' Random Polls of Whenever
User avatar
mangaluva
Fangirl, Pokefreak, Grammar Roman, Movie Geek

Posts:
5246
Contact:

Re: Anyone else here think Kogoro knows that Conan uses him?

Post by mangaluva »

Abs. wrote:
Chekhov MacGuffin wrote:
mangaluva wrote: I think Conan might drop it soon, I think a while back he was talking to Agasa about the dart taking longer to take effect or something.
He was wondering with Agasa about why the dart didn't affect Gin as well as he thought it would have after the Haido City Hotel case, but I can't think of another time Conan wondered about it...
Must have been an AO then.
They were at an onsen or something and it took a minute to affect Kogoro, I swear. Am I the only one who remembers this? WAS IT BUT A DREAM?
User avatar
Hybrid Speed

Posts:
8

Re: Anyone else here think Kogoro knows that Conan uses him?

Post by Hybrid Speed »

I personally think Kogoro knows more then he lets on, but that's just me.

And not just about Conan using him for deduction shows.
Image
PokerFace312
(ノ◕ヮ◕)ノ*:・゚✧

Posts:
1360

Re: Anyone else here think Kogoro knows that Conan uses him?

Post by PokerFace312 »

mangaluva wrote:
They were at an onsen or something and it took a minute to affect Kogoro, I swear. Am I the only one who remembers this? WAS IT BUT A DREAM?
I actually just watched the episode for that! It was the one with the little kid actor who was looking for his mom. When Conan shot Kogoro with the watch, Kogoro didn't react at first, instead he just asked if there were mosquitos there. THEN he got knocked out! ;D
Last edited by Anonymous on March 17th, 2010, 7:54 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Image
My Fanfiction          My tumblr          My MAL
User avatar
mangaluva
Fangirl, Pokefreak, Grammar Roman, Movie Geek

Posts:
5246
Contact:

Re: Anyone else here think Kogoro knows that Conan uses him?

Post by mangaluva »

ShinRanFTW wrote:
mangaluva wrote:
They were at an onsen or something and it took a minute to affect Kogoro, I swear. Am I the only one who remembers this? WAS IT BUT A DREAM?
I actually just watched the episode for that! It was the one with the little kid actor who was looking for his mom. When Conan shot Kogoro with the watch, Kogoro didn't react at first, instead he just asked if there were mosquitos there. THEN he got knocked out! ;D
Yay! I'm not imagining things! :D
soratothamax
Bang.....

Posts:
899
Contact:

Re: Anyone else here think Kogoro knows that Conan uses him?

Post by soratothamax »

Yes, Kogoro seems to be much more clever than he lets on....

But hey, what the butt, he might as well milk it. conan's getting him paid.... ;D
ImageImageImage
Leonawriter

Posts:
20

Re: Anyone else here think Kogoro knows that Conan uses him?

Post by Leonawriter »

I agree with Mangaluva, in that Kogoro's smart enough, but he's just too lazy to figure it out - and that Conan's his insurance.  I think that he does realise that several things are off, though.  He's noticed the prick of the stun darts several times, not just on the case with the kid movie star and the White Day case.  Not to mention that in one of the cases shortly before Ran first openly confronts Conan about his identity, Ran tells her father to his face not to bother Conan while he works.  Only saying that because Kogoro was there, and while I feel that he didn't know about Shinichi then, it's something he definitely saw, which Ran brought to his attention.  Plus the various other times she's had suspicions with her father around.
Spoiler: file 725
Also, the last couple of pages of file 725.  Conan's right by that dead body.  Note that it's Conan who says that the man's dead, and yet either because that's where the file cuts off or some other unknown reason, he doesn't get bopped on the head for staying so close to the body.  Also note that Kogoro believes him... though that might just be because the kid's been on enough crime scenes to know when a dead body is dead.
Last edited by Chekhov MacGuffin on September 4th, 2010, 10:53 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
King InuYasha

Posts:
18

Re: Anyone else here think Kogoro knows that Conan uses him?

Post by King InuYasha »

Leonawriter wrote: I agree with Mangaluva, in that Kogoro's smart enough, but he's just too lazy to figure it out - and that Conan's his insurance.  I think that he does realise that several things are off, though.  He's noticed the prick of the stun darts several times, not just on the case with the kid movie star and the White Day case.  Not to mention that in one of the cases shortly before Ran first openly confronts Conan about his identity, Ran tells her father to his face not to bother Conan while he works.  Only saying that because Kogoro was there, and while I feel that he didn't know about Shinichi then, it's something he definitely saw, which Ran brought to his attention.  Plus the various other times she's had suspicions with her father around.
Spoiler:
Also, the last couple of pages of file 725.  Conan's right by that dead body.  Note that it's Conan who says that the man's dead, and yet either because that's where the file cuts off or some other unknown reason, he doesn't get bopped on the head for staying so close to the body.  Also note that Kogoro believes him... though that might just be because the kid's been on enough crime scenes to know when a dead body is dead.
Which one is the White Day case?

Though, personally, I think that Kogoro doesn't want his bubble to burst from under him. The man loves acting the fool, even the audience and Conan think that he is a fool. But Kogoro is not really a fool, he is quite smart. But I think the separation from his wife and the loss of his job as a police detective caused him to become the way he is...
ImageImage
xGinx

Posts:
1937

Re: Anyone else here think Kogoro knows that Conan uses him?

Post by xGinx »

King InuYasha wrote:
Which one is the White Day case?
Files #725-726-727
Image
Anonnymus wrote:[...] Prof decided to rape a giant juice maker using a feather of ostrich [...]
Boxcar Children
Osorezan Revoir/The black thousand-paper-cranes

Posts:
346

Re: Anyone else here think Kogoro knows that Conan uses him?

Post by Boxcar Children »

Im gald someone metion this. cuase Ive had this idea for some time now.
"what if Kogoro figers out that conan is useing him." just like you said.
I say it could happen. but theres two out comes of it bad and good. And well it mostly ponits to bad.
and not alot of people what this to happen I know. But Im saying it mitte be intresting if it does.
Image
My Deviantart page==â–ºhttp://boxcarchildren.deviantart.com/
User avatar
mangaluva
Fangirl, Pokefreak, Grammar Roman, Movie Geek

Posts:
5246
Contact:

Re: Anyone else here think Kogoro knows that Conan uses him?

Post by mangaluva »

King InuYasha wrote:
Leonawriter wrote: I agree with Mangaluva, in that Kogoro's smart enough, but he's just too lazy to figure it out - and that Conan's his insurance.  I think that he does realise that several things are off, though.  He's noticed the prick of the stun darts several times, not just on the case with the kid movie star and the White Day case.  Not to mention that in one of the cases shortly before Ran first openly confronts Conan about his identity, Ran tells her father to his face not to bother Conan while he works.  Only saying that because Kogoro was there, and while I feel that he didn't know about Shinichi then, it's something he definitely saw, which Ran brought to his attention.  Plus the various other times she's had suspicions with her father around.
Spoiler:
Also, the last couple of pages of file 725.  Conan's right by that dead body.  Note that it's Conan who says that the man's dead, and yet either because that's where the file cuts off or some other unknown reason, he doesn't get bopped on the head for staying so close to the body.  Also note that Kogoro believes him... though that might just be because the kid's been on enough crime scenes to know when a dead body is dead.
Which one is the White Day case?

Though, personally, I think that Kogoro doesn't want his bubble to burst from under him. The man loves acting the fool, even the audience and Conan think that he is a fool. But Kogoro is not really a fool, he is quite smart. But I think the separation from his wife and the loss of his job as a police detective caused him to become the way he is...
Did you read Ellen Brand's "An Unprofessional Opinion" too? Because she said that stuff about him.

(Also, InuPapa is EPIC WIN! *hi5*)
User avatar
King InuYasha

Posts:
18

Re: Anyone else here think Kogoro knows that Conan uses him?

Post by King InuYasha »

mangaluva wrote:
King InuYasha wrote:
Leonawriter wrote: I agree with Mangaluva, in that Kogoro's smart enough, but he's just too lazy to figure it out - and that Conan's his insurance.  I think that he does realise that several things are off, though.  He's noticed the prick of the stun darts several times, not just on the case with the kid movie star and the White Day case.  Not to mention that in one of the cases shortly before Ran first openly confronts Conan about his identity, Ran tells her father to his face not to bother Conan while he works.  Only saying that because Kogoro was there, and while I feel that he didn't know about Shinichi then, it's something he definitely saw, which Ran brought to his attention.  Plus the various other times she's had suspicions with her father around.
Spoiler:
Also, the last couple of pages of file 725.  Conan's right by that dead body.  Note that it's Conan who says that the man's dead, and yet either because that's where the file cuts off or some other unknown reason, he doesn't get bopped on the head for staying so close to the body.  Also note that Kogoro believes him... though that might just be because the kid's been on enough crime scenes to know when a dead body is dead.
Which one is the White Day case?

Though, personally, I think that Kogoro doesn't want his bubble to burst from under him. The man loves acting the fool, even the audience and Conan think that he is a fool. But Kogoro is not really a fool, he is quite smart. But I think the separation from his wife and the loss of his job as a police detective caused him to become the way he is...
Did you read Ellen Brand's "An Unprofessional Opinion" too? Because she said that stuff about him.

(Also, InuPapa is EPIC WIN! *hi5*)
Yeah I did. But I have some other ideas to add to that. Earlier on in the thread, it was mentioned that Megure said that cases went cold while he worked with Kogoro. I suspect that he and his wife were having marital problems way before the incident described in Movie 2, and this affected his performance as a police detective just prior to the incident. With that, he lost his job, his wife, and the respect of his daughter and fellow colleagues. His personality makes him think everything is his fault, and so he becomes clinically depressed.

Throughout the course of the series, Kogoro has suspected Conan of being more than a normal child, though a couple of examples I've not heard raised before:

* When Conan explains to everyone how Mr. Kawashima was killed (~11min46sec of Ep 11). Kogoro remarks, "When did he become so-..." with a rather shocked look on his face.

* When Kogoro is tricked into thinking he is going crazy after being put in the hospital for injuring his leg, he admits to blacking out and not remembering how he solved the case. Incidentally, in the English version, this is first time we are told of the equivalent of Nemuri no Kogoro "The Sleeping Sleuth".
ImageImage
User avatar
mangaluva
Fangirl, Pokefreak, Grammar Roman, Movie Geek

Posts:
5246
Contact:

Re: Anyone else here think Kogoro knows that Conan uses him?

Post by mangaluva »

King InuYasha wrote:
mangaluva wrote:
King InuYasha wrote:
Leonawriter wrote: I agree with Mangaluva, in that Kogoro's smart enough, but he's just too lazy to figure it out - and that Conan's his insurance.  I think that he does realise that several things are off, though.  He's noticed the prick of the stun darts several times, not just on the case with the kid movie star and the White Day case.  Not to mention that in one of the cases shortly before Ran first openly confronts Conan about his identity, Ran tells her father to his face not to bother Conan while he works.  Only saying that because Kogoro was there, and while I feel that he didn't know about Shinichi then, it's something he definitely saw, which Ran brought to his attention.  Plus the various other times she's had suspicions with her father around.
Spoiler:
Also, the last couple of pages of file 725.  Conan's right by that dead body.  Note that it's Conan who says that the man's dead, and yet either because that's where the file cuts off or some other unknown reason, he doesn't get bopped on the head for staying so close to the body.  Also note that Kogoro believes him... though that might just be because the kid's been on enough crime scenes to know when a dead body is dead.
Which one is the White Day case?

Though, personally, I think that Kogoro doesn't want his bubble to burst from under him. The man loves acting the fool, even the audience and Conan think that he is a fool. But Kogoro is not really a fool, he is quite smart. But I think the separation from his wife and the loss of his job as a police detective caused him to become the way he is...
Did you read Ellen Brand's "An Unprofessional Opinion" too? Because she said that stuff about him.

(Also, InuPapa is EPIC WIN! *hi5*)
Yeah I did. But I have some other ideas to add to that. Earlier on in the thread, it was mentioned that Megure said that cases went cold while he worked with Kogoro. I suspect that he and his wife were having marital problems way before the incident described in Movie 2, and this affected his performance as a police detective just prior to the incident. With that, he lost his job, his wife, and the respect of his daughter and fellow colleagues. His personality makes him think everything is his fault, and so he becomes clinically depressed.

Throughout the course of the series, Kogoro has suspected Conan of being more than a normal child, though a couple of examples I've not heard raised before:

* When Conan explains to everyone how Mr. Kawashima was killed (~11min46sec of Ep 11). Kogoro remarks, "When did he become so-..." with a rather shocked look on his face.

* When Kogoro is tricked into thinking he is going crazy after being put in the hospital for injuring his leg, he admits to blacking out and not remembering how he solved the case. Incidentally, in the English version, this is first time we are told of the equivalent of Nemuri no Kogoro "The Sleeping Sleuth".
You're probably right about Kogoro and Eri. Ran's been known to say that they split because of "conflicting personalities" XDXD

I think Kogoro could work it out, if he really thought about it. He's thought that he recognizes Conan's face from when Ran was in grade school, after all. He just doesn't want to think about it XD
User avatar
kirite
Cookie-Eating Moderating Machine
Chillin'

Posts:
1762
Contact:

Re: Anyone else here think Kogoro knows that Conan uses him?

Post by kirite »

I don't think Kogoro knows.  The reason why I say this is because Sonoko and Yamamura has the same pattern as Kogoro after being used by Conan.  Confusion, acceptance, and then total self disillusion xD.

This establishes the "normal".  As it is normal for a kid to wear a bowtie and run around crime scenes it's normal for people to pretend they solved a case even though they don't remember anything from it. 
Hey, I have an idea, let's have a THIS SUCKS / NO THIS SUCKS / NO YOU / NO YOU argument for a couple pages, that will really be great. - Ingmar
Post Reply