File 688!!

Forum reserved for discussing specific points of the story—mostly from the manga. Be warned, these discussions will be current with the manga and will spoil many plot lines for anime-centric fans.
Post Reply
DCAddict

Posts:
6

File 688!!

Post by DCAddict »

Hello everyone, its my first post here... I am used to visiting dctp.ws all the time but never could be bothered to create an account.

I just read File 688, and it seems that Kasakura Nami is indeed the culprit, seeing the empty seats next to her, which could be her boyfriend and somebody else's seats. Which is pretty sad since observing Shiratori's yet another fail at romance.

However, I want to ask your opinion on this:
The way Goshyo shows Ayumi making Sakura flowers gives me the feeling that perhaps the real girl in Shiratori's memories is actually Ayumi's mother or her older sister (go on, hit me).

Anyway, that's my thought.
rensyphon

Posts:
9

Re: File 688!!

Post by rensyphon »

Why does Conan normally have a photographic memory, then the one time when it's something even a normal person would remember (someone in the seat in front of them getting up during the movie), he can't recall what happened?
Kristantei

Posts:
56
Contact:

Re: File 688!!

Post by Kristantei »

rensyphon wrote: Why does Conan normally have a photographic memory, then the one time when it's something even a normal person would remember (someone in the seat in front of them getting up during the movie), he can't recall what happened?
Can't pay attention to everything. Especially with Ayumi and Ai suddenly clinging to you.

I plan to post more about my deductions now that I've seen this chapter, but it seems pretty obvious what Shiratori asked Takagi to look for. Possibly his original drink that was drugged.
rensyphon

Posts:
9

Re: File 688!!

Post by rensyphon »

So, any chance she didn't do it?  I mean, she's the only suspect, and all the evidence overwhelmingly points to her.  BUT, Gosho is a romantic who wants everyone to have the love of a childhood friend that he missed out on.  I can't help but to think that he might find a way to acquit her, if not from the crime, then at least from wrongdoing.
mitsuhiko2

Posts:
73

Re: File 688!!

Post by mitsuhiko2 »

rensyphon wrote: So, any chance she didn't do it?  I mean, she's the only suspect, and all the evidence overwhelmingly points to her.  BUT, Gosho is a romantic who wants everyone to have the love of a childhood friend that he missed out on.  I can't help but to think that he might find a way to acquit her, if not from the crime, then at least from wrongdoing.
Or find another childhood friend for Shiratori... maybe Yumi? XD

Shiratori already knows it's her. He's just having trouble admitting it.
chubs191
Queen of Randomness

Posts:
151

Re: File 688!!

Post by chubs191 »

mitsuhiko2 wrote: Shiratori already knows it's her. He's just having trouble admitting it.
I feel so bad for him... :(
He needs a hug.
Grammar Nazis Unite (GNU)
[img width=500 height=223]http://i145.photobucket.com/albums/r205 ... 60copy.jpg[/img]
H...Haibara
Just kidding.

Posts:
105

Re: File 688!!

Post by H...Haibara »

Oh, no it's her. Shiratori knows she's the killer too, so he's torn.
DCAddict

Posts:
6

Re: File 688!!

Post by DCAddict »

Maybe a good line could be:

Shiratori: "It's you ---"
Conan: "But you were wrong. You missed a crucial clue. The real culprit is himself! It was a frame suicide!"

Being hopeful here...
themarble1
sad detective

Posts:
41

Re: File 688!!

Post by themarble1 »

assumption:
I think the little girl that  Shiratori met was actually Yumi i mean think about it they do look similar.
A detective who corners someone with logic, but lets them commit suicide is no different than the murderer- Conan Edogawa
rensyphon

Posts:
9

Re: File 688!!

Post by rensyphon »

DCAddict wrote: Maybe a good line could be:

Shiratori: "It's you ---"
Conan: "But you were wrong. You missed a crucial clue. The real culprit is himself! It was a frame suicide!"

Being hopeful here...
I thought about that, but it doesn't seem like the kind of wound that could have come from suicide.  Besides, Gosho never has conclusions without hints - if it were suicide, there'd be clues.
LDCF
i see u

Posts:
256

Re: File 688!!

Post by LDCF »

DCAddict wrote: Maybe a good line could be:

Shiratori: "It's you ---"
Conan: "But you were wrong. You missed a crucial clue. The real culprit is himself! It was a frame suicide!"

Being hopeful here...
haha! i also hope it will be like that! :3

well, by the way, Yumi is not the only one who's possible to be the girl of Shiratori's memories . . . these people are possible too! :D

this is kobayashi-san, the detective boys' teacher: well, that's only my opinion :D i just thought that she's possible because Ayumi thought that she looks like Satou.
Last edited by LDCF on April 14th, 2009, 12:49 am, edited 1 time in total.
Image
Kristantei

Posts:
56
Contact:

Re: File 688!!

Post by Kristantei »

I posted my deduction thoughts on the new chapter in the thread I made for 687. I'd post it here as well, but that would be too repetitive.
Now that I know for sure that Shiratori fell asleep it all falls together. It also helps to know that the seats surrounding them were empty. I couldn't see that in the previous chapter.
Post Reply