IHKF wrote:1... LOL xD Yeah. That sounds... interesting...
But I'm sure there would be some way to scientifically explain how Shinichi and Conan separated. If we, in reality, were able to find a way to travel to the future, then I'm pretty sure Gosho could explain possibly flawed cloning. XD
But it is impossible to travel to the future. Which results we would have to result to cloning - which IS possible nowadays. Though not in the way you probably mean.
Cloning is not able to create an exact replica. We won't suddenly have 2 Conans (or 1 Conan and 1 Shinichi). We would have Conan/Shinichi and a clone of Conan/Shinichi.
Now we can assume a crazy conspiracy: Shinichi is a genetically engineered human. This would explain his superior intelligence, perceptiveness and fitness. Of course he isn't the only one - he is just one of many clones. That would explain Kaito, who looks so similar to him and also has superior traits. Out there there must be even more clones, likely the same age as Shinichi or maybe even Ayumis age (if the program continued for 10 years).
But even then: There is only one Conan/Shinichi. Either Ran or Ayumi would have to end up without him and instead with someone who looks like him and likely behaves similar to him - but would not have their shared memories. They sure might make a good couple despite those missing links to their past, but... it is still not the same.
2. Not immediately, yes, but who says it will be immediate? XD I don't think Gosho would do that with the way he has recently continued Ayumi's crush on Conan. (In other words, him holding her hand, her cowering behind him, him grabbing her arm in the snow...) He's laid it down so that Ayumi has a strong crush on Conan and she wouldn't take it easy for him to leave. He keeps Ayumi as a very important character. That's why I think he won't do that (and if he does, that is horrible HORRIBLE writing).
Unfortunately him helping and protecting Ayumi so far is due to his tendency to protect everyone...
While it surely enforces Ayumis feelings for him, it does not prevent her from having to give him up once he gets out of her reach (because "Conan left forever" or because she knows that he returned to being Shinichi).
But it also means that him protecting her is nothing special, nothing that would develop the pairing any more than at what it currently is. And to be honest, Ayumis crush is less and less mentioned in the series. Maybe because Gosho has no idea what to do with this pairing, maybe because he realized that he has no easy way out of this situation that leaves a true happy ending for Ayumi and Shinichi and Ran. After all it was introduced early in the series, but the more he developed it the harder it gets to get rid of it. Especially now since Ayumi has become more subtle when approaching Conan. She was pretty open in the beginning, but now she is keeping much more to herself. Problem is that it has been shown that she still has those feelings and they seem stronger than ever before.
*sigh* Poor Ayumi-chan. Get a clue Conan: Your 16 annual movie is approaching and you are not getting your older body back. You would be 33 already now. And Ayumi 23.
3. He wouldn't be forced to give up on her, in fact, he could hang onto the memories and not really move past that event in his life by choice. If he wanted to he could even end it all to be with her (although I doubt it since he's... you know... the whole justice type. But then that's what I mean when I say he goes crazy.)
When Ran is dead he couldn't be together with her anymore.
Again, I don't like the feeling that Ayumi wouldn't have gotten to be with Conan if Ran didn't die. Because that makes it seem like his love for her is inferior and she is only second choice. But I want him to deliberately chose Ayumi OVER Ran.
I would like to see him having issues between deciding to stay with Ran OR Ayumi, really.
Well, he said he was going to miss the DBs when he thought that Alcohol could make him grow up again.

But yes, this is what I mean. I want him to feel like he has a choice, not like Ran is his only destiny and he has to get the antidote as quickly as possible...