Mafia--Round 8 (BO WINS)

[KainTheVampire]

I was told that xGinx had a "scent",

May I know who's your trustworthy source?? One of the suspects?? Maybe the BO who modified the dream the last round so we vote for Paix?? Holmes, who's one of the suspects??

---

Btw, akai can have a "scent" right??

I am getting PM by most of the players.
None of them are reliable sources. But someone said you have a scent.

And you probably aren't Akai. But it's a guess. Because you said
"Btw, akai can have a "scent" right??"
But if you were Akai, you would probably say "I could be Akai though, right?"
But that's just my interpretation...

i have to agree with Tommy =/

[xGinx]

[quote="Detective Tommy"]
I was told that xGinx had a "scent",

May I know who's your trustworthy source?? One of the suspects?? Maybe the BO who modified the dream the last round so we vote for Paix?? Holmes, who's one of the suspects??

---

Btw, akai can have a "scent" right??

I am getting PM by most of the players.
None of them are reliable sources. But someone said you have a scent.

And you probably aren't Akai. But it's a guess. Because you said
"Btw, akai can have a "scent" right??"
But if you were Akai, you would probably say "I could be Akai though, right?"
But that's just my interpretation...

I think it was a rethorical question...
[/quote]

Not only that, I don't want to claim nothing, I'm just pointing that you aren't saying who told you that so, as long as I know, some BO could have told you that just to make you suspect of me and I'm also pointing that certain Town roles can also have scents so it really means nothing.

[Detective Tommy]

[quote="xGinx"]
[quote="Detective Tommy"]
I was told that xGinx had a "scent",

May I know who's your trustworthy source?? One of the suspects?? Maybe the BO who modified the dream the last round so we vote for Paix?? Holmes, who's one of the suspects??

---

Btw, akai can have a "scent" right??

I am getting PM by most of the players.
None of them are reliable sources. But someone said you have a scent.

And you probably aren't Akai. But it's a guess. Because you said
"Btw, akai can have a "scent" right??"
But if you were Akai, you would probably say "I could be Akai though, right?"
But that's just my interpretation...

I think it was a rethorical question...
[/quote]

Not only that, I don't want to claim nothing, I'm just pointing that you aren't saying who told you that so, as long as I know, some BO could have told you that just to make you suspect of me and I'm also pointing that certain Town roles can also have scents so it really means nothing.
[/quote]

I told you that it was possible the person that told me was BO. I have no allies currently...
And I knew that. The person told me you could be Akai. I was just stating what I was told.

[nomemory]

[quote="xGinx"]
[quote="Detective Tommy"]
I was told that xGinx had a "scent",

May I know who's your trustworthy source?? One of the suspects?? Maybe the BO who modified the dream the last round so we vote for Paix?? Holmes, who's one of the suspects??

---

Btw, akai can have a "scent" right??

I am getting PM by most of the players.
None of them are reliable sources. But someone said you have a scent.

And you probably aren't Akai. But it's a guess. Because you said
"Btw, akai can have a "scent" right??"
But if you were Akai, you would probably say "I could be Akai though, right?"
But that's just my interpretation...

I think it was a rethorical question...
[/quote]

Not only that, I don't want to claim nothing, I'm just pointing that you aren't saying who told you that so, as long as I know, some BO could have told you that just to make you suspect of me and I'm also pointing that certain Town roles can also have scents so it really means nothing.
[/quote]
I does mean something since it's only a few townie roles who have a scent. It would be good to know if the claim that you to have a scent is true or not.

[Detective Tommy]

[quote="Detective Tommy"]
[quote="xGinx"]
[quote="Detective Tommy"]
I was told that xGinx had a "scent",

May I know who's your trustworthy source?? One of the suspects?? Maybe the BO who modified the dream the last round so we vote for Paix?? Holmes, who's one of the suspects??

---

Btw, akai can have a "scent" right??

I am getting PM by most of the players.
None of them are reliable sources. But someone said you have a scent.

And you probably aren't Akai. But it's a guess. Because you said
"Btw, akai can have a "scent" right??"
But if you were Akai, you would probably say "I could be Akai though, right?"
But that's just my interpretation...

I think it was a rethorical question...
[/quote]

Not only that, I don't want to claim nothing, I'm just pointing that you aren't saying who told you that so, as long as I know, some BO could have told you that just to make you suspect of me and I'm also pointing that certain Town roles can also have scents so it really means nothing.
[/quote]
I does mean something since it's only a few townie roles who have a scent. It would be good to know if the claim that you to have a scent is true or not.
[/quote]

I'm sorry. I have no way to know whether this person is lying or telling the truth.
And I cannot risk him being killed either.
And none of the people that PM me can be trusted.

[xGinx]

May I know who's your trustworthy source?? One of the suspects?? Maybe the BO who modified the dream the last round so we vote for Paix?? Holmes, who's one of the suspects??

---

Btw, akai can have a "scent" right??

I am getting PM by most of the players.
None of them are reliable sources. But someone said you have a scent.

And you probably aren't Akai. But it's a guess. Because you said
"Btw, akai can have a "scent" right??"
But if you were Akai, you would probably say "I could be Akai though, right?"
But that's just my interpretation...

I think it was a rethorical question...
[/quote]

Not only that, I don't want to claim nothing, I'm just pointing that you aren't saying who told you that so, as long as I know, some BO could have told you that just to make you suspect of me and I'm also pointing that certain Town roles can also have scents so it really means nothing.
[/quote]
I does mean something since it's only a few townie roles who have a scent. It would be good to know if the claim that you to have a scent is true or not.
[/quote]

You should ask that to Tommy's source or Tommy who looks like really enjoys of accusing me lately even when he's not sure if he can trust his source. I'm not risking me to die with APTX just to defend myself from a false acussation.

---

[quote="Detective Tommy wrote:

[quote="Detective Tommy"]
[quote="xGinx"]
[quote="Detective Tommy"]
I was told that xGinx had a "scent",

May I know who's your trustworthy source?? One of the suspects?? Maybe the BO who modified the dream the last round so we vote for Paix?? Holmes, who's one of the suspects??

---

Btw, akai can have a "scent" right??

I am getting PM by most of the players.
None of them are reliable sources. But someone said you have a scent.

And you probably aren't Akai. But it's a guess. Because you said
"Btw, akai can have a "scent" right??"
But if you were Akai, you would probably say "I could be Akai though, right?"
But that's just my interpretation...

I think it was a rethorical question...
[/quote]

Not only that, I don't want to claim nothing, I'm just pointing that you aren't saying who told you that so, as long as I know, some BO could have told you that just to make you suspect of me and I'm also pointing that certain Town roles can also have scents so it really means nothing.
[/quote]

I told you that it was possible the person that told me was BO. I have no allies currently...
And I knew that. The person told me you could be Akai. I was just stating what I was told.
[/quote]

If you know all that why don't you make sure you are %100 sure before making an accusaition??

[Detective Tommy]

@xGinx

I didn't say "xGinx has scent, he is BO, let's all lynch him!!!!!" All I said was someone told me you had a scent.
Everyone should know that my sources are not reliable.
They don't have to listen, but it's just something someone told me..

And there is NO WAY AT ALL, to make sure my sources are 100% reliable.
They can all be BO lying. Or they can all be town.

Also, xGinx, did you receive a PM that you were followed?

[xGinx]

@xGinx

I didn't say "xGinx has scent, he is BO, let's all lynch him!!!!!" All I said was someone told me you had a scent.
Everyone should know that my sources are not reliable.
They don't have to listen, but it's just something someone told me..

And there is NO WAY AT ALL, to make sure my sources are 100% reliable.
They can all be BO lying. Or they can all be town.

Also, xGinx, did you receive a PM that you were followed?

Actually, there's a way, you can ask the DBs to check the roles (I think there's at least someone who claimed to be a DB in the players you talk to), If they are who they claim to be then they're reliable.

If you want to make sure they are really DBs then tell them a role and make them check it, acording to their answer you can tell if they're lying or not.

[nomemory]

@xGinx: dbs can only check roles in this way:
nomemory is GOD
pofa is anokata

if someone is disguised or the role is wrong it will come back false, at least that's how I remember it.

[Detective Tommy]

@xGinx

I didn't say "xGinx has scent, he is BO, let's all lynch him!!!!!" All I said was someone told me you had a scent.
Everyone should know that my sources are not reliable.
They don't have to listen, but it's just something someone told me..

And there is NO WAY AT ALL, to make sure my sources are 100% reliable.
They can all be BO lying. Or they can all be town.

Also, xGinx, did you receive a PM that you were followed?

Actually, there's a way, you can ask the DBs to check the roles (I think there's at least someone who claimed to be a DB in the players you talk to), If they are who they claim to be then they're reliable.

If you want to make sure they are really DBs then tell them a role and make them check it, acording to their answer you can tell if they're lying or not.

Nobody has claimed to be DB yet.
What if the roles that people claim to be are lies and they're BO?

And what if the person claiming to be DB, and the person I tell them to check are both BO.
They can chat together to trick me..


Also, if the DB is BO and I tell them a person+role to check.
They can use APTX on that person the next day.

[xGinx]

@xGinx

I didn't say "xGinx has scent, he is BO, let's all lynch him!!!!!" All I said was someone told me you had a scent.
Everyone should know that my sources are not reliable.
They don't have to listen, but it's just something someone told me..

And there is NO WAY AT ALL, to make sure my sources are 100% reliable.
They can all be BO lying. Or they can all be town.

Also, xGinx, did you receive a PM that you were followed?

Actually, there's a way, you can ask the DBs to check the roles (I think there's at least someone who claimed to be a DB in the players you talk to), If they are who they claim to be then they're reliable.

If you want to make sure they are really DBs then tell them a role and make them check it, acording to their answer you can tell if they're lying or not.

Nobody has claimed to be DB yet.
What if the roles that people claim to be are lies and they're BO?

And what if the person claiming to be DB, and the person I tell them to check are both BO.
They can chat together to trick me..

Also, if the DB is BO and I tell them a person+role to check.
They can use APTX on that person the next day.

Nobody directly claimed to be DB but Kain actually said a few interesting things and gave some interesting answers when I posted asking her to tell me the answers of her Investigation as a DB. I think she's one of the DBs (Idk wich one, and even if I knew i wouldn't post it just to protect her from APTX). Of course, I'm not sure of her being DB but it's the only one I suspect of being DB so far. Maybe you want to talk to her, I can also tell you that she isn't alone, she is in some kind of an alliance.

[Conia]

[quote="Detective Tommy"]
@xGinx

I didn't say "xGinx has scent, he is BO, let's all lynch him!!!!!" All I said was someone told me you had a scent.
Everyone should know that my sources are not reliable.
They don't have to listen, but it's just something someone told me..

And there is NO WAY AT ALL, to make sure my sources are 100% reliable.
They can all be BO lying. Or they can all be town.

Also, xGinx, did you receive a PM that you were followed?

Actually, there's a way, you can ask the DBs to check the roles (I think there's at least someone who claimed to be a DB in the players you talk to), If they are who they claim to be then they're reliable.

If you want to make sure they are really DBs then tell them a role and make them check it, acording to their answer you can tell if they're lying or not.

Nobody has claimed to be DB yet.
What if the roles that people claim to be are lies and they're BO?

And what if the person claiming to be DB, and the person I tell them to check are both BO.
They can chat together to trick me..

Also, if the DB is BO and I tell them a person+role to check.
They can use APTX on that person the next day.

Nobody directly claimed to be DB but Kain actually said a few interesting things and gave some interesting answers when I posted asking her to tell me the answers of her Investigation as a DB. I think she's one of the DBs (Idk wich one, and even if I knew i wouldn't post it just to protect her from APTX). Of course, I'm not sure of her being DB but it's the only one I suspect of being DB so far. Maybe you want to talk to her, I can also tell you that she isn't alone, she is in some kind of an alliance.
[/quote]

Well, this is obvious, since there can't be only 1 DB in the game.

[Detective Tommy]

Even if you prevent her from dying through APTX, they can kill her tonight.
Knowing that she is DB at all, makes it a possibility that she'll die...

[KainTheVampire]

I don't want to die darn it! D:

and wouldn't it be smarter to lynch me during the day instead? >.<
since DBs only can investigate during daytime... =/
so if i really am a DB, i can't do anything to hurt BO right now anyway... =/

[Akonyl]

Because this was a ruling-related error, I feel this is a minor detail which I'm allowed to mention even though I'm dead:

And we also know that there is Gin in the game. And afaik someone said that he was intimidated/tricked? Since Akonyl died, it couldn't have been him who did that. So there is probably a vodka in the game too (if we can believe what that person said (and I dunno who it was anymore XD))

Tricking happens before killing. So if only one person was tricked/intimidated there is no Vodka in the game. Or both Eisuke and Vodka tricked the same victim.
But if there are two tricked victims then there is a Vodka in the game for sure.

Although it is true that tricking happens before killing, at the time of my death the interpretation of the ruling was that tricking happening before killing was only in the case that you were going to trick the murderer. So, at the time of my death, the rule stated that if you got killed, your action wouldn't happen that night.

Thus, last night, an Eisuke-related tricking was impossible because I was killed. I think I made pofa realize the error or her ways, but I'm not exactly sure if she decided to change the ruling back or stick with it since it's already been in affect this game.