Mafia Mafia Mafia! (New Thread Exists)

[Akonyl]

So, I was going to point out some information (Sonoko is conia btw, and I'm his best friend), but I realized it's pretty pointless to say, because basically:

(this is all based on there only being 3 total BO members though, although I don't think that there would be 4 because that would just be an insane amount of mafia for a game imo)
(it also takes into account that yumi actually set up two lovers and didn't just forget to do it)

If my trick tonight is successful, we know the (I'm guessing final) BO member's identity and the town wins if they all believe me, 3 town votes vs the 2 lover votes.

If it isn't, and one person (non-lover, not me) dies, then there are 4 people left. Two of them are lovers, and will vote with each other, making them unlynchable. If we stalemate on the lynching, I have a 50/50 chance of being able to trick the mafia the next night, and me and the non-lover townie can stalemate for eternity.

if it isn't, and one person dies (me), there are 4 people left, two of which are lovers. The lovers will get a stalemate lynch vote and will eventually have the BO kill off the other players and will get a Lovers' win. In this situation, conia would know who the BO member is, however there's a 50/50 chance he's a lover and would lie anyway, so it's not much use believing him.

If it isn't, and two people (the lovers) die, then there are 3 people left, one of which is me. There is a 50/50 chance we lynch the correct remaining person (given they don't lynch me), and if we lynch either one of them, it's me + the BO member, who will stalemate for eternity.

So basically, unless I got anything wrong, tonight is a big roll of the die and I hope I chose the right person :O

[Conia]

I love when this posts arise

[Callid]

End of Night 5

Once again, the merry light of the sun shines upon Beika. *plays Morning Mood by Edvard Grieg*
However, the people in town aren't able to enjoy the beautiful sunrise - a scream sounds through the streets, showing proof of another death. When they finally arrive at the crime scene, they find conia dead on the floor. From the well-filled wallet and the many love letters found in here possessions, it is easy to resolve that the dead conia was Sonoko.

An enraged Akonyl leads them up to the gallows, where they decide who will be held responsible for her terrible death...

Start of Day 5

[Callid]

Xcommando has received an official last warning due to a heavy violation of the The-dead-don't-talk rule.
If this happens again, he will get banned from all future games.

[Akonyl]

Alright then. So, I didn't trick the right person, but that means Holmes is not in the BO.

So, attention to the remaining non-lover (or, Poor Lover) townie, you should PM me and tell me who you are because if we wanna have any chance to stalemate this then we need to put our votes together.

[Akonyl]

and actually, I just realized that I'm almost positive commi-ninja is the BO

so I'm just gonna vote commi-ninja.

[Commi-Ninja]

Then I'm gonna vote Akonyl. 

[mangaluva]

Oh dear... we're hemmoraghing (sp?) townspeople fast. Who will be next?

[Callid]

This gets ... interesting!

Don't forget to vote!

[Akonyl]

well here's the thing

we lynched gin, right? The following night, Sakina died. However, that night, I tricked mangaluva, so she can't be the last BO
and obviously, I tricked holmes last night and somebody died so he can't be the last BO

so basically it's gotta be you, unless there's 4 BO.

[Commi-Ninja]

This is as long as we're assuming YOU'RE not the last B.O. member.

[Akonyl]

If I am, then who's the trickster?

I'm sure you've all seen that your night actions were messed up by someone, if you have night actions.

Not to mention I was the first person to mention anything about xcommando and bluekaitou in the thread, I could understand a BO lynching one of their own to gain trust, but not all of them except themselves.

[Commi-Ninja]

Unless they had a specific motive.  (i.e. Lover's win rather than Mafia win.)

[Akonyl]

true, but I would say it would be best to wait until the end to kill off the final guy, as if something randomly happens and you get killed, you can still hope to get the mafia win anyway.

[Callid]

true, but I would say it would be best to wait until the end to kill off the final guy, as if something randomly happens and you get killed, you can still hope to get the mafia win anyway.

No, you can't. The lovers win ONLY when they are alive at the end. So, if Gin and Agasa were in love, and they got killed and the final result is a townsfolk victory, Agasa had still lost. However, they mustn't be the only ones alive (just alive...).
Therefore, the lovers win in case of any stalemate (as long as they are alive).