ESPIONAGE: Campaign Round - DETECTIVES AND CIVILIANS WIN!

[shinichi'sapprentice]

...

HOW IN THE WORLD DID THE OTHER SPY FIGURE OUT THAT I WAS NOT REALLY THE DETECTIVE?! @_@

This one theory came to my mind this morning after I had seen the current situation:
D3, the other spy tried to kill Raifuujin and that way understood that she was the other spy. Then when you said you had cleared Raifuujin, both spies knew you were lying and didn´t want to waste a kill on you.

As for my list, I do have Jecka there.

ah. right! thanks!

i think i need sleep @__@

EDIT: HOLD IT! really nice theory there! can somebody please go through all 30 pages of this thread and find who tried to say Raifuujin might not be a spy or tried to protect her or something... i think i have it in my notes too but not sure... zzz

[Nemomon]

SA, You forever will be my god for writing such a long and deeply thought message .

I have no idea who to vote. Whether or not You, SA, were a Detective, it would be useful for the Spies to kill You. Without You all the players probably would vote randomly. So it is kind of weird that Yu have survived this long. Though, it could be that they wanted You to stay alive, because if the random voting would be in motion, they would die even without knowing that.

Anyway, I have kind of doubts against Moon Raven and Jellitto. Don't know why. Probably vote against either of them. Unless someone has a better idea who might be the other spy.

[MoonRaven]

...I've overreacted and had a sneaky post? God, what have I written. *goes to read*

EDIT: Exactly what is so suspicious about my posts(whichever you are refering to)

[Nemomon]

I didn't say anything about Your posts, Moony. I didn't state anywhere that they were suspicious. I just stated that You might be a spy, for example because of how You went along with everybody.

[Jellitto]

@Moon This one:

Gee, nice... I just woke up and came to see the results and what do I see? I'm being nominated for a lynch... Sorry, for not being useful before... School is killing my strategic thinking here. And it's not my fault the people I vote happen to die! I just have a bad luck just like in that one mafia game where as soon as I allied someone, that someone died...

Might be just my opinion / misunderstanding but that's what came to mind when writing my thoughts.

[shinichi'sapprentice]

*tried to sleep*

*failed...* xD

btw... by *sneaky posts, i meant RMed or whatever... i do not like saying 'RMed' so there... and i think it's supposed to be *sneak post but it sounds weird so i always end up typing *sneaky instead. anyway...

*attempts to get some sleep again*

*sneaky post from Jellitto :v xD

[MoonRaven]

@Moon This one:

Gee, nice... I just woke up and came to see the results and what do I see? I'm being nominated for a lynch... Sorry, for not being useful before... School is killing my strategic thinking here. And it's not my fault the people I vote happen to die! I just have a bad luck just like in that one mafia game where as soon as I allied someone, that someone died...

Might be just my opinion / misunderstanding but that's what came to mind when writing my thoughts.

oh, that one... I guess I managed to start the day with a wrong foot or something...

[dumytru]

My list is kind of awesome. Haha. Totally not posting it, but @SA: I have Jecka on my list.

Edit: In case somebody's wondering, I'm still pretty confused and I'm trying to think about what happened here.
That's why I'm not saying very much (also because I have another midterm this week and I really need to study).

[dumytru]

can somebody please go through all 30 pages of this thread and find who tried to say Raifuujin might not be a spy or tried to protect her or something... i think i have it in my notes too but not sure... zzz

I said I trust Raifuu as an answer to your question (but that's because you said you cleared her).

Here and here.

[MoonRaven]

hmm.. do you think Jecka cleared me at some point? She did give me +4 on Day 4...

I only know realized that.

[dumytru]

hmm.. do you think Jecka cleared me at some point? She did give me +4 on Day 4...

I only know realized that.

That's because we needed to control the lynch.

[MoonRaven]

hmm.. do you think Jecka cleared me at some point? She did give me +4 on Day 4...

I only know realized that.

That's because we needed to control the lynch.

But then why me? People were suspecting me at that point and Jecka wasn't exactly the last person to pick the voting slot...

[dumytru]

This isn't getting us anywhere.
We have to avoid random-voting. Let's decide on a somebody and lynch them.

Random-voting will get us nowhere.


My thoughts on players:

~shinichi'sapprentice
Fuji said he's not-evil, most likely, so maybe she investigated him.
If SA tried to kill Raifuu D3, (remember he then posed as Detective that had cleared Raifuu), that would actually make sense. Raifuu would know SA's not the Detective and wouldn't bother killing him.

That being said, I have my suspicions, but I trust him.

~MoonRaven
She's trying to prove herself when we should be looking for the spy.

~Jellitto
Kinda spy-like, kinda civilian.

~Stopwatch
Oh, she could be a spy, but I started trusting her since last phase. Fuji also maybe investiated her.

~MDavid
He acts civilian-like.
He did some questionable things, but not spy-like things.

~Nemomon
His reaction when he was going to be arrested was very civilian-like.

Conclusion

My prime suspects are Jellitto and MoonRaven. Then MDavid and Nenomon, then Stopwatch and SA.
For me, the first two are most likely to be the spies, then last four are most likely civilian.

And thus, I'm inclined to vote Jellitto.
Though, if you guys decide to lynch elsebody, I'm going to join as well.

[MoonRaven]

... I'm not trying to prove myself or anything! I just noticed something and asked an opinion about it. And because I know I'm being suspected since the beginning I'm trying to quide pointing fingers to some other direction since I'm not a spy. Isn't that what anyone else would do?

[Stopwatch]

Given what SA said about those who saved me being next on the lynch (or something similar) I doubt Fuji would've just saved me based on nothing :V. So, either a Spy result on Raifuu or a not Spy result on me. It's obvious which one I would like to be true :V.

And I was hinting Detective in preparation for a proper claim, but if SA was fake-claiming (as turned out to be the case) then that could backfire so badly. Speaking of, SA, I mentioned before about you not being killed was weird, right? I probably missed it if you've said so already, but who were your investigations?

MoonRaven, in this situation, how do you think the remaining Spy would be acting? Also, what's your read on MDavid?