my point is that we've never seen first aid do anything, so to change it because of it being "overpowered" or something is pretty silly because it hasn't been overpowered yet.Ctu wrote:Which is? That nobody has ever went the saved by first aid round yet?Akonyl wrote:exactly my pointCtu wrote:True...although has anybody ever been saved by first aid before?Akonyl wrote:I'm still questioning why you want to change it when we haven't even seen how its effective use actually turns things out, though.Ctu wrote: Well if you saw in the thread then I suggested that the first aid injured status would only last for 24 hours or 2 phases like a suspension for police![]()
well first aid still learns the ID of the ORG member but heal dose not
Mafia - Round 10 Psycho Edition (Town Wins)
-
- Community Hero
Posts: 4200
Re: Mafia - Round 10
- Schillok
- GCA UAC U AUG AUA
Posts: 699
Re: Mafia - Round 10
I only suggested changing how Araide's heal works - I was just worried that healing the correct player is already powerful enough, but learning the identity of the attacker as well means that the mafia will get very far behind - with just one lucky guess.Akonyl wrote: my point is that we've never seen first aid do anything, so to change it because of it being "overpowered" or something is pretty silly because it hasn't been overpowered yet.
It looks like Araide and the victim did not learn the identity of the attacker anyway. So my changes were not necessary.
First aid was just changed to be more similar to healing. If healing does not find out identities then first aid should be the same. It is easier (both for the players and the GM).
It is not overpowered. Just the consequences of a correct use are devastating for the BO. Especially when we try to keep the number of BO as low as possible.

-
- That was expected from my Silver Bullet
Posts: 422
- Conia
- Yurikochan's Husband
- Conan Shuuichi
Posts: 5194
Re: Mafia - Round 10
I'll take my decision on Saturday. Wait for me!Ctu wrote:I'll wait to hear for Conia firstxpon wrote: Conia will join in saturday.. so it 18.....
nomemory 1 others 0.nomemory wrote: I'm pretty sure he's a he.
My gender is in my profile

New record!Beastly wrote: Add me in

- nomemory
- TheElderNom
Posts: 804
Re: Mafia - Round 10
1 point to me =D I belive Schillok is male to btw, but I might be confusing him(her) with someone else but I can't remeber who.
"Sick of tea?! That's like being sick of breathing!" - Iroh (Avatar - The Last Airbender)
- Grawwbear
Posts: 127
Re: Mafia - Round 10
I know the feeling, Conia. I really do. Do you need another bearhug, or would you like me to just stay over here?conia wrote:
nomemory 1 others 0.
My gender is in my profile![]()
3DS FC: 1177 7926 3041
- Conia
- Yurikochan's Husband
- Conan Shuuichi
Posts: 5194
Re: Mafia - Round 10
Naah, I'm used to it. My username tends to confusionRohoph wrote:I know the feeling, Conia. I really do. Do you need another bearhug, or would you like me to just stay over here?conia wrote:
nomemory 1 others 0.
My gender is in my profile![]()


- Kleene Onigiri
- Community Rice Warrior
- *punches Akonyl*
Posts: 2479
Re: Mafia - Round 10
especially f there is a conina in the forum and you pm him/her instead XDconia wrote:Naah, I'm used to it. My username tends to confusionRohoph wrote:I know the feeling, Conia. I really do. Do you need another bearhug, or would you like me to just stay over here?conia wrote:
nomemory 1 others 0.
My gender is in my profile![]()
![]()

Keyhole drawn by Yuri Iwamoto <3
Spoiler: Secret Santa gift from Commi-Ninja <3
༼ つ ◕_◕ ༽つ Giff holidays
- Conia
- Yurikochan's Husband
- Conan Shuuichi
Posts: 5194
Re: Mafia - Round 10
Oh yeah...Kleene Onigiri wrote:especially f there is a conina in the forum and you pm him/her instead XDconia wrote:Naah, I'm used to it. My username tends to confusionRohoph wrote:I know the feeling, Conia. I really do. Do you need another bearhug, or would you like me to just stay over here?conia wrote:
nomemory 1 others 0.
My gender is in my profile![]()
![]()
/facepalm

-
Posts: 73
Re: Mafia - Round 10
Mafia Historical Participation Table
Username
PS: Well done Akonyl, Beastly, Ctu, and Holmes for playing in every single round!
PPS: It took longer than you'd think to do this
Includes up until Round 9
Username
Player
Game Master
Total
Abs.4
0
4
Akonyl7
2
9
Beastly9
0
9
Bluekaito14126
0
6
Blufberg2
0
2
Callid5
1
6
Chekhov MacGuffin1
0
1
Commi-Ninja6
0
6
conia6
2
8
c-square1
0
1
Ctu9
0
9
Detective Tommy2
0
2
Elika123
0
3
Holmes9
0
9
James Rye1
0
1
KainTheVampire2
0
2
Kleene Onigiri6
1
7
Laurell3
0
3
mangaluva4
0
4
Nomemory4
0
4
Paix6722
0
2
pofa5
1
6
ranger2
0
2
Sakina3
2
5
Schillok5
0
5
Sebolains2
0
2
TheBlind2
0
2
Xcommando6
0
6
xGinx2
0
2
xpon4
0
4
PS: Well done Akonyl, Beastly, Ctu, and Holmes for playing in every single round!
PPS: It took longer than you'd think to do this

Last edited by Sebolains on July 1st, 2010, 3:06 pm, edited 1 time in total.
'Songs of Myself' by Walt Whitman wrote:You shall no longer take things at second or third hand, nor look through
the eyes of the dead, nor feed on the spectres in books,
You shall not look through my eyes either, nor take things from me,
You shall listen to all sides and filter them from your self.
Poem by Emily Dickinson wrote:Success is counted sweetest
By those who ne'er succeed.
To comprehend a nectar
Requires sorest needs.
-
- *punches Xpon*
Posts: 321
Re: Mafia - Round 10
Unless I missed somebody then we have 18 players in this game
ps: I am going to have to put that list on the first page
ps: I am going to have to put that list on the first page

well sorry I thought you said something about it before I guess I was wrong...tho your name dose not help matters lolconia wrote:Naah, I'm used to it. My username tends to confusionRohoph wrote:I know the feeling, Conia. I really do. Do you need another bearhug, or would you like me to just stay over here?conia wrote:
nomemory 1 others 0.
My gender is in my profile![]()
![]()
Kleene Onigiri wrote: Mafia: Where you fight with unicorns and puppies as your weapons.
- Grawwbear
Posts: 127
Re: Mafia - Round 10
Just wondering. Am I on the Hall of Fame just because I joined the 10th round?
3DS FC: 1177 7926 3041
-
- *punches Xpon*
Posts: 321
Re: Mafia - Round 10
that is a secretRohoph wrote: Just wondering. Am I on the Hall of Fame just because I joined the 10th round?
Kleene Onigiri wrote: Mafia: Where you fight with unicorns and puppies as your weapons.
- Detective Tommy
Posts: 2465
Re: Mafia - Round 10
I'll join this game. I have time 
What time is the phase change?

What time is the phase change?
"Well, a child's curiosity and a detective's spirit of inquiry... Do have much in common, after all..." - Tooru Amuro
-
- *punches Xpon*
Posts: 321
Re: Mafia - Round 10
Well it is set to 5:pm EST (-5GMT), but if enough people would like it pushed back A few more Hours (I can do 5-10PM EST (-5GMT) then I could change it)Detective Tommy wrote: I'll join this game. I have time
What time is the phase change?
Kleene Onigiri wrote: Mafia: Where you fight with unicorns and puppies as your weapons.