"Mafia Round 21," or, "Boom With A View!" (BO and Bomber win

[xpon]

i am still alive???

no brutal kill from parkur?

[CTU]

i am still alive???

no brutal kill from parkur?

that will be saved for round 22

[xpon]

[KangarooGirl]

Good game, town. Especially Yuriko, Parkur and Kirby. You guys made it difficult for us at the end. (But townies, please don't tell other people your roles so quickly next time)

Also congrats to breva

@miaka: I think you did really well too. I hope you'll continue to play.

[Schillok]

Well... to bad we lost, but with this number of APTX deaths this was expected (and deserved) to happen, even with all the successful arresting.

Poor PT (Sonoko)... befriending Sonoko sure is a hard fate and there was nothing that could be done against the poisoning.

Well, even myself managed to get killed this game by APTX. I guess it was bad luck that Kleene was Anokata out of all players who could fake her investigate ability. Being interrogate later by Edo is unfortunate, which pretty much sealed my fate. So at least it wasn't me being sloppy with who I told what. Or was it really just a bluff by the BO? In that case... what should I have done differently as Kir if I heard that someone interrogated me as BO? In retrospective I should have claimed being slandered, but what if I were contacted by a townie instead? It could also have ended badly, especially when they find out the real slandering target. Though, next time I will probably handle it differently.  

I still wonder why Parkur, who I contacted day 3 never replied when I sent him everything and did not even try to cooperate. I think we could have done a lot if we were working together. Th


Answering the questions from the excel file:
If a traveler gets lynched: The lynching fails, the votes should be shown but all survive. Which is why I would prefer if when  the lynching gets stopped by a protector the votes would also be shown.
Deduction/Spy should not be able to be investigated. Just wondering though: Why did spy have only 6 targets, but observe had 7 (with 2 players already dead at that time)? This seems kinda unfair. And why did the number decrease to only 4 the second and third time spy was used?
Also, we should really think about super-frighten-discombobulation-power-protection-that-lasts-for-6-phases, aka Detention, once more. Because it is way to powerful, especially in the hands of a character like Satô, who has other strong abilities (and no real weakness) already.


Well.... I will join the next game and hopefully learn from my failures.

[CTU]

Well... to bad we lost, but with this number of APTX deaths this was expected (and deserved) to happen, even with all the successful arresting.

Poor PT (Sonoko)... befriending Sonoko sure is a hard fate and there was nothing that could be done against the poisoning.

Well, even myself managed to get killed this game by APTX. I guess it was bad luck that Kleene was Anokata out of all players who could fake her investigate ability. Being interrogate later by Edo is unfortunate, which pretty much sealed my fate. So at least it wasn't me being sloppy with who I told what. Or was it really just a bluff by the BO? In that case... what should I have done differently as Kir if I heard that someone interrogated me as BO? In retrospective I should have claimed being slandered, but what if I were contacted by a townie instead? It could also have ended badly, especially when they find out the real slandering target. Though, next time I will probably handle it differently. 

I still wonder why Parkur, who I contacted day 3 never replied when I sent him everything and did not even try to cooperate. I think we could have done a lot if we were working together. Th


Answering the questions from the excel file:
If a traveler gets lynched: The lynching fails, the votes should be shown but all survive. Which is why I would prefer if when  the lynching gets stopped by a protector the votes would also be shown.
Deduction/Spy should not be able to be investigated. Just wondering though: Why did spy have only 6 targets, but observe had 7 (with 2 players already dead at that time)? This seems kinda unfair. And why did the number decrease to only 4 the second and third time spy was used?
Also, we should really think about super-frighten-discombobulation-power-protection-that-lasts-for-6-phases, aka Detention, once more. Because it is way to powerful, especially in the hands of a character like Satô, who has other strong abilities (and no real weakness) already.


Well.... I will join the next game and hopefully learn from my failures.

ok I will add you

[KangarooGirl]

@Schillok: I actually slandered you the night Edo interrogated you so that was good luck on your part, probably, because it accidentally made you look town. Lol. We didn't know for sure that you would be interrogated that night anyway or we'd have been able to APTX you earlier. And so, yes, it was actually a bluff. Funnily enough, some of the BO thought you might have been faking Kir even after you'd sent Kleene all your info.

[Schillok]

@Schillok: I actually slandered you the night Edo interrogated you so that was good luck on your part, probably, because it accidentally made you look town. Lol. We didn't know for sure that you would be interrogated that night anyway or we'd have been able to APTX you earlier. And so, yes, it was actually a bluff. Funnily enough, some of the BO thought you might have been faking Kir even after you'd sent Kleene all your info.

I should have done that. It would have been so great.
I mean, if I were not Kir this game.

So yeah, as it turned out I should have claimed that I got slandered. The next time I am in that situation I will consider this.

[Kleene Onigiri]

Yay for the Pink Organization \o/ (I renamed it, that's why the pink avatars :3)

APTXing:

@Schillok: Yeah, it was a bluff. Because we wanted to divide the votes somehow, and we knew parkur had an alliance, you were the only one we knew that you had investigate and that you probably didn't trust DT so much. So we said that you got interrogated as BO.
I was surprised when you said you're Kir XD

Tho I thought you're Akai or Kir, because you played kinda defensive (at least I got the feeling somehow, but I think you were quite busy too)

Also, I think Kir should keep Investigation AND S. Investigation, because once she's interrogated and someone tells on the thread, she's dead for sure :V


@PT: Well, we knew from Dus she was Sonoko :x Tho she suspected Dus early on, so we had to waste steal on targets we already knew about so that PT doesn't bust Dus instantly :V

@Mystery: She told her friends Miikosan and Rachzzz that she's yusaku (and we investigated it). But even without Deduction being able to be investigated, we would have known (so that didn't matter much.)

@Nomemory: She told me she has a night ability and that her ability "is good wen targeted on the right one". So we though it could be protect/heal/tricking mainly. Later on the tricksters died, and she said she can't trick.
We observed Nom as an adult. And she also healed DT on the night he asked to get healed/protected in the thread. We randomly investigated that and got it right :V
That's why Nom got APTXed as Araide (since there wasn't any VoR for a long time besides Dus VoR. So we guessed she's not Kobayashi)

@CTU: Observed as a teenager. And he told (miiko?) someone that he's female long ago too. I was also followed after I contacted CTU :V So our guess was that he's Kazuha, but since we did 2 other APTXes, that weren't for 100%, we didn't want to risk to loose all 3 APTX on one day. So we killed him the next night instead.

@blurf: He told someone (afaik Miiko again?) that he'll give me a gem. We wanted to investigate that (but missed giving out the order for that :x). But I got a Gem, so we assumed he's Jirokichi (was also observed as an Adult afaik)

@Rachzzzz: Told Miiko that he's Agasa early on and also gave her the bow-tie+watch once :V

@miaka: our first failed APTX :V We stole a gun and car-keys from her. We also knew she can observe. So, probability wise, it was more likely that she's Camel :V But she was Jodie in the end D:
Damn math...

@DT: Claimed Shinichi. But we knew he can investigate and was observed as a Child later on too (and spy told us there is Conan :V)

@Holmes: I also PMed Holmes if he wants to get investigated. He answered with a PM that he has a BO/town action. So we assumed he can observe/stake-out.
And Spy told us there is Camel too.




@Commi: we assumed she could be a healer or Traveler. Since she didn't die :V And I wasn't a suspect (so no Ran Protection). But she died the next night ^^"

@Yurikochan: We detected KID. And she later told hopeless and me that she's KID. I got her to steal the Gem I got Night 1 :3 I think that made her trust me a lot at the beginning too :x She also told us, that a police, that isn't Nakamori, got in contact with jirokichi. Too bad she didn't tell who it was D:
She also dodged our poisoning :V


I think this was the first round with so many prison releases and re-arresting XD

[Tanner-kun]

Good game everyone. xD

[Dus]

Also, congrats, BO! Except you, Dus.

I thought you had forgiven me? Also, now that you're back to life...

Still, well played town. I didn't think it would be this close in the end, especially when we could have poisoned 5 people day 1.
I still don't think getting arrested on purpose was the best of plans, since it meant that Yuriko couldn't vote either and arresting me instead of re-arresting her would definitely have been preferable. Not voting today wasn't a good idea either: Had we gotten our APTX wrong, we would have lost the game.

[Yurikochan]

@Kleene: Actually it was Tommy's weirdness that made me gravitate more to trusting you. I wouldn't
have told you the police officer's name no matter what cause I'm tight lipped. And when I got Miaka's result from Tommy I knew you had to be Anokata, cause he did that round 15. With claiming Genta when he was Mitsuhiko. He could have lied yes. But it was you or him. And you creeped meout just a little bit and I fed you and Hayley lots of fake information. I still love you. but I was disappointed in the town. more than anything with the lack of votes when I pmmed people! XD!

Also PS: you may want to talk to Akonyl about stealing girl's panties. <3

Shihokudo: Why do you always pick on me.

[Schillok]

Still, well played town. I didn't think it would be this close in the end, especially when we could have poisoned 5 people day 1.
I still don't think getting arrested on purpose was the best of plans, since it meant that Yuriko couldn't vote either and arresting me instead of re-arresting her would definitely have been preferable. Not voting today wasn't a good idea either: Had we gotten our APTX wrong, we would have lost the game.

Well, for some reason pofa had not put my vote into his excel file. He could have missed more votes as well.If we had one police remaining we could have arrested XCom though... and might have turned things around with some luck. You monsters, killing poor Ayumi-chan even though you didn't have to. (You three are on my revenge list anyway... so let me just bold your names on it for the future. )

Still: I hope the town will finally learn not to just hope on their good luck and just tell their role that quickly. Yeah, I told my role as well but at least I had good reasons to do so. And at least Parkur and Yurikochan were town. Just Kleene was the wrong decision, I didn't expect a BO bluff and expected a real interrogation.
At least I was able to play a full game as town again.


Though, somehow I doubt people will change their ways about telling others their role, claiming that hoping on sheer luck is their "tactic". On the other hand there are others like Parkur who did not even bother answering after I sent him everything I knew and tried to ally him...

[Dus]

Well, for some reason pofa had not put my vote into his excel file.

You were APTXed, so your vote didn't count.

[xpon]

and all of you call me a person who leak infos.......



and pofa did made me go KAABBBBOM!!!!!