Mafia! Mafia! Mafia! Character Role Discussions

[Kleene Onigiri]

I don't like this sudden death thing D:

and no comment on the house search? D:

I don't care for it much..also I guess that means nobody has any prob with a false house arrest leading to just a 24 hour suspension

Lawsuits?
Bomb planting and bomb diffusing?

I thought this was a simple murder game, it's starting to sound more and more like an action/thriller movie.

That's it we also need a car chase.

lol but I guess I can say that if the ORG members don't pick on a cause of death I might use a car bomb

I still think the 24h penalty will make it too powerful D:
Since you will know for sure that's it 100% a BO or 100% a townie. So you always find either a BO or an ally. And if you tell the Townie that you found what action he/she made, he'll also believe you and you can make an easy alliance that way (without any distrust. And even sonoko has to fear that she befriend vermouth disguised as someone)

But it's up to you. It's just my thought about what could happen.

[CTU]

I don't like this sudden death thing D:

and no comment on the house search? D:

I don't care for it much..also I guess that means nobody has any prob with a false house arrest leading to just a 24 hour suspension

Lawsuits?
Bomb planting and bomb diffusing?

I thought this was a simple murder game, it's starting to sound more and more like an action/thriller movie.

That's it we also need a car chase.

lol but I guess I can say that if the ORG members don't pick on a cause of death I might use a car bomb

I still think the 24h penalty will make it too powerful D:
Since you will know for sure that's it 100% a BO or 100% a townie. So you always find either a BO or an ally. And if you tell the Townie that you found what action he/she made, he'll also believe you and you can make an easy alliance that way (without any distrust. And even sonoko has to fear that she befriend vermouth disguised as someone)

But it's up to you. It's just my thought about what could happen.

True, but I think removing the player from the police is just to big of a drawback for it to be used (has it ever been used before) but maybe just a 24 hour suspension with the removal of hour search for the rest of the game should work

[Kleene Onigiri]

I don't like this sudden death thing D:

and no comment on the house search? D:

I don't care for it much..also I guess that means nobody has any prob with a false house arrest leading to just a 24 hour suspension

Lawsuits?
Bomb planting and bomb diffusing?

I thought this was a simple murder game, it's starting to sound more and more like an action/thriller movie.

That's it we also need a car chase.

lol but I guess I can say that if the ORG members don't pick on a cause of death I might use a car bomb

I still think the 24h penalty will make it too powerful D:
Since you will know for sure that's it 100% a BO or 100% a townie. So you always find either a BO or an ally. And if you tell the Townie that you found what action he/she made, he'll also believe you and you can make an easy alliance that way (without any distrust. And even sonoko has to fear that she befriend vermouth disguised as someone)

But it's up to you. It's just my thought about what could happen.

True, but I think removing the player from the police is just to big of a drawback for it to be used (has it ever been used before) but maybe just a 24 hour suspension with the removal of hour search for the rest of the game should work

Yeah, or a fixed about of house searches (like APTX)

@house search:
I thought about changing it too after I changed arresting.
But giving it a 24h(2 phases) penalty instead of having Megure revealed isn't good imo.
Because if you succeed, then you'll find out a BO and can arrest him/lynch him. But if you do a house search on a townie, you'll have a penalty and can't use the house search for the next night. But the night after that.
But Megure will also find out a Ally instantly without having any doubts! Because house search reveals the role, actions etc. Even if it didn't reveal that, Megure would still know that it's a townie because it wasn't a BO (who did crimes etc.) and got a penalty.

But I also think revealing Megures identity and becoming a commoner with a failed House search is too much. But instead of a 24h penalty, I think Megure just shouldn't be able to use the house search anymore once he made a false house search.
So if Megure is lucky, he could find out all BO's in a row (but that's unlikely). And if he's unlucky, he'll loose his house search ability after the 1. use. But for that he get's a reliable ally he doesn't have to doubt. And he can still arrest and use investigations.

Another idea I had is to give Megure a set number of house searches he can do. (like 1/3 * players) Whether it's a "false" or "right" house search wouldn't matter then.

[xpon]

The lover should win if their side wins..

so if town+town = town wins

so if Bo + BO = BO wins

but if they are BO + Town. they can win if they are alive and kill the others player?

it too hard... how about the lover wins whoever wins.. if they are 2 side lover....

[Kleene Onigiri]

The lover should win if their side wins..

so if town+town = town wins

so if Bo + BO = BO wins

but if they are BO + Town. they can win if they are alive and kill the others player?

it too hard... how about the lover wins whoever wins.. if they are 2 side lover....

well, a dead lover can't win anyway ;p

[Schillok]

The lover should win if their side wins..

so if town+town = town wins

so if Bo + BO = BO wins

but if they are BO + Town. they can win if they are alive and kill the others player?

it too hard... how about the lover wins whoever wins.. if they are 2 side lover....

A lovers win is one of the hardest tasks possible.

But seriously... getting the town-partner killed during night 2? Even with the BO-partner being Akemi - the lowest Mafia rank - from my experience there should be enough talk among the mafia members so that the BO-partner should have been able to direct the killing away from his/her lover.
Of course unless it was some kind of last-minute decision from the BO leader.

[Grawwbear]

As some people have said, they [some people] think the dreams are overpowered. I suggested in the prediction thread that perhaps, instead of the person receiving the dream posting whatever was said in the dream in their own words, that person can only state one thing from the dream in their own words?

Again, just a suggestion.

[Conia]

As some people have said, they [some people] think the dreams are overpowered. I suggested in the prediction thread that perhaps, instead of the person receiving the dream posting whatever was said in the dream in their own words, that person can only state one thing from the dream in their own words?

Again, just a suggestion.

Well, you can't control what people say in PMs, so we need another alternative.

[xpon]

The lover should win if their side wins..

so if town+town = town wins

so if Bo + BO = BO wins

but if they are BO + Town. they can win if they are alive and kill the others player?

it too hard... how about the lover wins whoever wins.. if they are 2 side lover....

well, a dead lover can't win anyway ;p

not for this round 

---

The lover should win if their side wins..

so if town+town = town wins

so if Bo + BO = BO wins

but if they are BO + Town. they can win if they are alive and kill the others player?

it too hard... how about the lover wins whoever wins.. if they are 2 side lover....

A lovers win is one of the hardest tasks possible.

But seriously... getting the town-partner killed during night 2? Even with the BO-partner being Akemi - the lowest Mafia rank - from my experience there should be enough talk among the mafia members so that the BO-partner should have been able to direct the killing away from his/her lover.
Of course unless it was some kind of last-minute decision from the BO leader.

maybe because i blackmailed them and told that i will reveal all their role.. ha ha ha

[Yurikochan]

I'd love to join in the game if you need another person. ^^ Gomen ne, if I'm not supposed to post here, but please help. I'm quite excited, and I never actually played this version!

[Conia]

I'd love to join in the game if you need another person. ^^ Gomen ne, if I'm not supposed to post here, but please help. I'm quite excited, and I never actually played this version!

For now, you'll have to wait till the actual Round is over. Stay tuned to learn more and get ready for the next Round ^^

[Yurikochan]

No problem, thank you for the fast response, I'll watch whats going on in the game so I can learn it better too.

[xpon]

btw.. we can learn better if we know who is BO and who is townie.. after we die

[Detective Tommy]

btw.. we can learn better if we know who is BO and who is townie.. after we die

Horrible idea. Because someone can cheat and PM someone alive and give them answers.

[Abs.]

I think it's really sad to think that people would be cheating in a Mafia game played for fun on a Detective Conan forum.

Dead players can get the results at the end of the game, just like the alive players.