Haibara Ai = Irene Adler

Forum reserved for discussing specific points of the story—mostly from the manga. Be warned, these discussions will be current with the manga and will spoil many plot lines for anime-centric fans.
HayleyStark
We're all evil eyed yawny kids

Posts:
88

Haibara Ai = Irene Adler

Post by HayleyStark »

I noticed in recent chapters how Haibara takes the detective part , even replacing Conan in a one or two cases (680, 713) This reminded me a lot of Irene Adler from Sherlock Holmes, the only woman who matches Sherlock's skills, and gained his unbounded admiration. Irene steals once, outwitting Holmes before he could catch her. This parallels Haibara's 'Sherry' past to some extent.

Not to mention the appearance and personality of Haibara, you can tell she is easily identical to Irene. Auburn curled hair, a beauty to die for, and a very independent sharp woman who is not afraid to show her wit. But as the manga progresses, Haibara changes. She finds happiness and friendship. She's not just the cold smart girl, but someone who has friends, and likes mysteries, watching football and helping people with love turmoils (ch 705). No more sorrow in Ai. ;D

Irene Adler
Image

As Conan, Sherlock is cold and a total failure when it comes to expressing passion, with the exception of that woman. In one incidence Sherlock demanded a photo of her as the only payment for solving a case, and it remained one of his most prized possessions.  

Sad thing is...Irene doesn't end up with Sherlock, she gets married to another man. I think this brings us to lack of emotional expression on the detective's part. In the manga, Haibara showed her disapproval more than once about Conan's secrecy. Sometimes it's too vague to tell who's the girl she's referring to...Ran or herself. (ch 690)
Image

EDITED...
Last edited by HayleyStark on August 29th, 2010, 6:18 am, edited 1 time in total.
"Do you have to say something about everything?"
-Haibara Ai to Conan
Abs.
DCTP Staff Hero

Posts:
3270

Re: Haibara Ai = Irene Adler

Post by Abs. »

Kaito Kid = Irene Adler
Your opinion is always requested in Abs.' Random Polls of Whenever
Beastly
That was expected from my Silver Bullet

Posts:
422

Re: Haibara Ai = Irene Adler

Post by Beastly »

Sherlock Holmes= Aoko  :)
Image
HayleyStark
We're all evil eyed yawny kids

Posts:
88

Re: Haibara Ai = Irene Adler

Post by HayleyStark »

Beastly wrote: Sherlock Holmes= Aoko  :)
Who's Aoko?  ;D
"Do you have to say something about everything?"
-Haibara Ai to Conan
HayleyStark
We're all evil eyed yawny kids

Posts:
88

Re: Haibara Ai = Irene Adler

Post by HayleyStark »

Abs. wrote: Kaito Kid = Irene Adler
Nooooo....Kid is Arsene Lupin. Shame on you
"Do you have to say something about everything?"
-Haibara Ai to Conan
Holmes
Erabareshi Kodomotachi

Posts:
1291

Re: Haibara Ai = Irene Adler

Post by Holmes »

HayleyStark wrote:
Beastly wrote: Sherlock Holmes= Aoko  :)
Who's Aoko?  ;D
Ran´s twin ... well ... they look much alike as Shinichi and Kaito. A classmate of Kaito (in love with him) and daughter of Nakamouri-keibu.
My drawings thread :) Holmes´Drawings

Image
*Amazing banner done by KaitoGirl, thank you very much! :D*
Abs.
DCTP Staff Hero

Posts:
3270

Re: Haibara Ai = Irene Adler

Post by Abs. »

Kaito Kid, the only man who matches Conan's skills, and gained his unbounded admiration. Kid was a thief, outwitting Conan in stealing a large jewel before he could catch him.
Fixed it for you  ;D
Your opinion is always requested in Abs.' Random Polls of Whenever
Beastly
That was expected from my Silver Bullet

Posts:
422

Re: Haibara Ai = Irene Adler

Post by Beastly »

Abs. wrote:
Yusaku Kudo, the only man who matches Conan's skills, and gained his unbounded admiration. Yusaku was a writer, outwitting Conan in detective worksbefore Conan can find the culprit, Yusaku already know it
Fixed it for you  ;D
Fixed it for you  ;)
Image
HayleyStark
We're all evil eyed yawny kids

Posts:
88

Re: Haibara Ai = Irene Adler

Post by HayleyStark »

Holmes wrote: Ran´s twin ... well ... they look much alike as Shinichi and Kaito. A classmate of Kaito (in love with him) and daughter of Nakamouri-keibu.
Thanks I know her but I just rarely ever see her in DC manga so I can't tell what's all the Kid/ Aoko fanfiction is about.
"Do you have to say something about everything?"
-Haibara Ai to Conan
Beastly
That was expected from my Silver Bullet

Posts:
422

Re: Haibara Ai = Irene Adler

Post by Beastly »

HayleyStark wrote:
Holmes wrote: Ran´s twin ... well ... they look much alike as Shinichi and Kaito. A classmate of Kaito (in love with him) and daughter of Nakamouri-keibu.
Thanks I know her but I just rarely ever see her in DC manga so I can't tell what's all the Kid/ Aoko fanfiction is about.
She's always there the girl who hates KID... The one that always say Stealing is a crime you know... And she's always the only KID hater in every Kid's heist
Image
HayleyStark
We're all evil eyed yawny kids

Posts:
88

Re: Haibara Ai = Irene Adler

Post by HayleyStark »

BTW, Irene doesn't work as a thief in the novels (unlike the film) . She steals once though.
"Do you have to say something about everything?"
-Haibara Ai to Conan
Kor
Administrator

Posts:
3051

Re: Haibara Ai = Irene Adler

Post by Kor »

HayleyStark wrote:
Holmes wrote: Ran´s twin ... well ... they look much alike as Shinichi and Kaito. A classmate of Kaito (in love with him) and daughter of Nakamouri-keibu.
Thanks I know her but I just rarely ever see her in DC manga so I can't tell what's all the Kid/ Aoko fanfiction is about.
...read the Magic Kaito manga then  :P
Image
Beastly
That was expected from my Silver Bullet

Posts:
422

Re: Haibara Ai = Irene Adler

Post by Beastly »

But Ai havent beaten Conan in any form except in Science...
Image
User avatar
Misztina

Posts:
976
Contact:

Re: Haibara Ai = Irene Adler

Post by Misztina »

Yeah, Irene Adler wasn't a thief in the novel at all, and only appeared physically once. Poor her, portraying her as a thief >.>

What did she stole HayleyStark? I can't remember that part.

Heiji cannot be Mycroft. I think Mycroft should be Yusaku, since Mycroft is better than Holmes if I'm not mistaken.
Abs.
DCTP Staff Hero

Posts:
3270

Re: Haibara Ai = Irene Adler

Post by Abs. »

Beastly wrote: But Ai havent beaten Conan in any form except in Science...
Wit.
Your opinion is always requested in Abs.' Random Polls of Whenever
Locked