Rate the avatar and signature of the person above you

[Holmes]

both 8

[Boxcar Children]

A: 8 coan Vs Gin
S: 5

[Azu]

9 each 

I love your avatar and (supposingly you drew that) siggy is pretty... :3

[Tanner-kun]

a:7/10
s:6/10

[Moriarty]

a: ?/10  (can't see it using this browser)
s: 7/10

[Holmes]

A: 9
S: 5

[Callid]

A: 8 (-1 size, -1 perfect)
S: 4 (-1 perfect, -3 no image, -2 meagre)

[xGinx]

A: 6/10

S: 8/10

[Conia]

A:8
S:6(too big 0_0)

[baka1412]

A : 8

S : 6 (cause i don't recognize the anime..)

[Callid]

A: 9 (-1 size). I'd like to give a 10, but it's simply too large.
S: 8 (-2 different sharpness (and original resolution?))

Yes, both are considered "perfect".

[Holmes]

A: 7
S: 9

[mangaluva]

A:8
S: 6 (interesting, but a bit longwinded)

[Tanner-kun]

8 and 8

[Holmes]

A: 8.5
S: 7.5