Mafia Mafia Mafia! Pt. 2! (Game 4: Town wins!)

[Abs.]

Ofc they could also pull a mindtrick and just 2 people vote, and hope that someone else votes the same. And the rest of the BO doesn't vote at all or vote for a BO member to look innocent.

That "someone else" could have been me!  And if Holmes turned out to be innocent, I'd be the one lynched the next day!  I'm onto you and your devious plans that you have explained in painstaking detail in this open thread... 

[Kleene Onigiri]

Ofc they could also pull a mindtrick and just 2 people vote, and hope that someone else votes the same. And the rest of the BO doesn't vote at all or vote for a BO member to look innocent.

That "someone else" could have been me!  And if Holmes turned out to be innocent, I'd be the one lynched the next day!  I'm onto you and your devious plans that you have explained in painstaking detail in this open thread...  

Well, i dunno if you would be targeted, since there would be 3 people that voted for him (holmes). If we got a BO then it would be a 1/3 chance for everyone of us (me, akonyl and abs) to get targeted by the BO (since you can see who voted). If we got someone innocent we wouldn't be targeted by the bo, but targeted by the townspeople. And the BO would abuse that for their benefit.


Edit: damn typos XD Don't write drunk and sleepy lol XD

[Akonyl]

Ofc they could also pull a mindtrick and just 2 people vote, and hope that someone else votes the same. And the rest of the BO doesn't vote at all or vote for a BO member to look innocent.

That "someone else" could have been me!  And if Holmes turned out to be innocent, I'd be the one lynched the next day!  I'm onto you and your devious plans that you have explained in painstaking detail in this open thread...   :-\

you just have to have to talk your way out of it is all. I mean, look back at game 2, when I made that huge post declaring your guilt and got you lynched and it turned out you were innocent, I managed to get out of being lynched myself.

[TheBlind]

it is also a loss because no org members were killed ether ...they are still free to do there evil deeds

It was not a win to me either, because the culprit went free.

I rather have the board remain the same than to lose a piece. The more time that passes, the more advantage we gain over the Black Organization as it means more moves being made and more unification of the village(aka to weed them out).

Town, I fear for my life tonight, so I will not be discreet about what I know, because it must be known. Last night, Callid was killed by either Holmes or Commi-Ninja. This is not guesswork, this is not lies, this is fact. True story.

If it was Holmes, then he will be dealt with promptly. However, if this is false, then the killer was Commi-Ninja and should be lynched as such.

Now I know you ask, "but why should we trust you, Akonyl?", and I know you don't have one right now, because you don't know if I'm a townie or a BO member. However, only one circumstance  requires that you trust me (that Commi-Ninja did it), and if that's the case you'll have plenty of reason to know I'm not in the BO when I'm dead. If Holmes did it, then I don't need your help anyway.

So your two suspects are Holmes and Commi-Ninja?
This is getting interesting. If you die, your words become true and the town can eliminate at least two members but if they are a lie, you successfully diverted the attention of the town and used us to take out one of our own(perhaps someone vital). The only price you would pay is your own life as we would come after you in the end...but I don't think that would be a problem for you. So...Ak----just like someone I know.

I'll wait for this proof you have promised before I make my judgment on your Akonyl as you seem to be a shade of gray...but a shade of gray that leans towards the light.

[Akonyl]

So your two suspects are Holmes and Commi-Ninja?
This is getting interesting. If you die, your words become true and the town can eliminate at least two members but if they are a lie, you successfully diverted the attention of the town and used us to take out one of our own(perhaps someone vital). The only price you would pay is your own life as we would come after you in the end...but I don't think that would be a problem for you. So...Ak----just like someone I know.

I'll wait for this proof you have promised before I make my judgment on your Akonyl as you seem to be a shade of gray...but a shade of gray that leans towards the light.

not "at least two members". Only one of them is the killer, but I don't know which one it is.

[TheBlind]

Well, i dunno if you would be targeted, since there would be 3 people that voted for him (holmes). If we got a BO then it would be a 1/3 chance for everyone of us (me, akonyl and abs) to get targeted by the BO (since you can see who voted). If we got someone innocent we wouldn't be targeted by the bo, but targeted by the townspeople. And the BO would abuse that for their benefit.


Edit: damn typos XD Don't write drunk and sleepy lol XD

X-commando says he trust you...why would that be?
Now let's see how you operate in the light, in the open Kleene?!

[Conia]

So your two suspects are Holmes and Commi-Ninja?
This is getting interesting. If you die, your words become true and the town can eliminate at least two members but if they are a lie, you successfully diverted the attention of the town and used us to take out one of our own(perhaps someone vital). The only price you would pay is your own life as we would come after you in the end...but I don't think that would be a problem for you. So...Ak----just like someone I know.

I'll wait for this proof you have promised before I make my judgment on your Akonyl as you seem to be a shade of gray...but a shade of gray that leans towards the light.

not "at least two members". Only one of them is the killer, but I don't know which one it is.

Just as you said, we have to wait till tomorrow to know that...

[TheBlind]

not "at least two members". Only one of them is the killer, but I don't know which one it is.

So you can only guarantee one?
Interesting, so if you are wrong, you have an escape route and if you are right, well at worst you just sold out a member to secure everyone's trust. It's a brilliant strategical move...if that is your intentions.
*Breaks character*

.....This is fun, . So, do games actually stale mate for this long or is this a first?
It seems like both sides are stuck in a battle of wits than action. It could all change on who the B.O. kills tonight though, as I predict they are going to mess up and make a move that is going to give them away.

[Holmes]

not "at least two members". Only one of them is the killer, but I don't know which one it is.

So you can only guarantee one?
Interesting, so if you are wrong, you have an escape route and if you are right, well at worst you just sold out a member to secure everyone's trust. It's a brilliant strategical move...if that is your intentions.
*Breaks character*

.....This is fun, . So, do games actually stale mate for this long or is this a first?
It seems like both sides are stuck in a battle of wits than action. It could all change on who the B.O. kills tonight though, as I predict they are going to mess up and make a move that is going to give them away.

See? Mafia game is quite interesting, you should have played the first time you were invited 

[pofa]

I don't think it's stalemated that long--it's only been one day. I'm interested to see what Akonyl thinks will be proven tomorrow, though. Hopefully whatever it is will help us band together on a lynching tomorrow. Callid's spirit cries out for vengeance, after all.

[Akonyl]

I could also role call and be less vague about what I'm saying, but the vagueness makes it fun

[Commi-Ninja]

I don't think it's stalemated that long--it's only been one day. I'm interested to see what Akonyl thinks will be proven tomorrow, though. Hopefully whatever it is will help us band together on a lynching tomorrow. Callid's spirit cries out for vengeance, after all.

I'm curious as well.  I'd also like to know what reason Akonyl has for accusing me of being in the Black Organization.

[Abs.]

Damn I can't wait to find out whether Akonyl dies or not! 

[Sakina]

It's amusing how everybody's calling Akonyl's death.  xD  Will he die?  Tune in in an hour and find out!

[Akonyl]

I don't think it's stalemated that long--it's only been one day. I'm interested to see what Akonyl thinks will be proven tomorrow, though. Hopefully whatever it is will help us band together on a lynching tomorrow. Callid's spirit cries out for vengeance, after all.

I'm curious as well.  I'd also like to know what reason Akonyl has for accusing me of being in the Black Organization.

I'd like to make this clear because yall are somewhat misconstruing what I'm saying.

What I'm saying is that either Holmes or Commi-Ninja killed Callid, only one of them. However, both of them could be in the BO by chance, but I know nothing about that, just that one of them/you killed Callid. And if my attempt to take care of Holmes goes awry, then it means that Commi-Ninja did it.