Rating the Detective Conan Movies (Results are in!)

[Kamite]

Movie 1 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 2 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 3 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 4 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 5 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 6 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 7 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 8 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 9 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 10 : ✩✩✩
Movie 11 : ✩✩
Movie 12 : ✩✩
Movie 13 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 14 : ✩✩
Movie 15 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 16 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 17 : ✩✩✩✩

[Jellitto]

Movie 1 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 2 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 3 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 4 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 5 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 6 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 7 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 8 : ✩✩✩
Movie 9 : ✩✩✩
Movie 10 : ✩✩✩
Movie 11 : ✩✩
Movie 12 : ✩✩
Movie 13 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 14 : ✩✩
Movie 15 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 16 : ✩✩
Movie 17 : ✩✩✩

[DevilsClaw1991]

Movie 1 : ✩✩✩½
Movie 2 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 3 : ✩✩✩
Movie 4 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 5 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 6 : ✩✩✩½
Movie 7 : ✩✩✩½
Movie 8 : ✩✩✩½
Movie 9 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 10 : ✩✩✩
Movie 11 : ✩✩✩
Movie 12 : ✩✩✩½
Movie 13 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 14 : ✩✩✩
Movie 15 : ✩✩✩✩½
Movie 16 : ✩✩✩½
Movie 17 : ✩✩✩
Movie 18 : Haven' Seen it (YET^^)

[Kudo Shinchi]

Movie 1: ✩✩✩✩
Movie 2: ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 3: ✩✩✩✩1/2
Movie 4: ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 5: ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 6: ✩✩✩✩
Movie 7: ✩✩✩1/2
Movie 8: ✩✩✩✩
Movie 9: ✩✩✩✩1/2
Movie 10: ✩✩✩✩
Movie 11: ✩✩✩1/2
Movie 12: ✩✩✩✩
Movie 13: ✩✩✩✩1/2
Movie 14: ✩✩✩1/2
Movie 15: ✩✩✩✩
Movie 16: ✩✩✩✩
Movie 17: ✩✩✩✩1/2

[Wakarimashita]

So I compiled everyone's ratings, normalized the data, and analyzed it. Here is how respondents so far on average rate the movies to the nearest half star, with the results centered around 3 stars. (Scores vary between 0 and 5)

Movie 1 : ✩✩✩
Movie 2 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 3 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 4 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 5 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 6 : ✩✩½
Movie 7 : ✩✩✩½
Movie 8 : ✩✩✩
Movie 9 : ✩✩✩
Movie 10 : ✩✩½
Movie 11 : ✩✩
Movie 12 : ✩✩½
Movie 13 : ✩✩✩½
Movie 14 : ✩✩
Movie 15 : ✩✩½
Movie 16 : ✩✩½
Movie 17 : ✩✩½

The 3 most controversial movies (highest STDEV) are 6, 12, and 2
The three least controversial movies are 13, (17), 8, 9

Data about 16 and 17 is a bit iffy because a lot fewer people have seen those.

Spoiler:

Normalized average ratings:
5 3.915425565
4 3.826652238
3 3.803993252
2 3.756982663
7 3.317192782
13 3.257222696
8 3.205852438
1 2.994828059
9 2.904433143
10 2.74622434
15 2.740722394
6 2.736667768
17 2.697006274
12 2.407405114
16 2.330354511
14 2.097851752
11 1.889991202


Stdev (contraversialness)
13 0.178421842
17 0.226547189
8 0.238358861
9 0.266480964
4 0.281327944
1 0.289224639
7 0.303306189
10 0.305740047
11 0.306167594
5 0.31265545
14 0.31820004
15 0.326649153
16 0.334532629
3 0.342448376
2 0.36614313
12 0.399225406
6 0.408535951

14 and 11 at the bottom, 2-5 at the top, as it should be.

[Puto]

Movie 1 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 2 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 3 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 4 : ✩✩✩
Movie 5 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 6 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 7 : ✩✩✩
Movie 8 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 9 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 10 : ✩✩
Movie 11 : ✩
Movie 12 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 13 : ✩✩✩½
Movie 14 : ✩
Movie 15 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 16 : ✩✩

I can't really rate movie 17; I'm horribly biased against it because of the trouble we had subtitling it.

Updated!

[LeastGuilty]

Movie 1: ✩✩
Movie 2: ✩✩
Movie 3: ✩✩✩
Movie 4: ✩✩✩
Movie 5: ✩✩✩
Movie 6: ✩✩✩✩
Movie 7: ✩✩
Movie 8: ✩✩✩
Movie 9: ✩✩✩
Movie 10: ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 11: ✩✩
Movie 12: ✩✩✩
Movie 13: ✩✩✩✩
Movie 14: ✩✩
Movie 15: ✩✩✩
Movie 16: ✩✩
Movie 17: ✩✩

[red.orchid]

Movie 1 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 2 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 3 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 4 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 5 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 6 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 7 : ✩✩✩
Movie 8 : ✩✩✩
Movie 9 : ✩✩✩
Movie 10 :✩
Movie 11 : I haven't seen it yet.
Movie 12 : I haven't seen it yet.
Movie 13 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 14 : ✩
Movie 15 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 16 : ✩✩✩
Movie 17 : ✩✩✩½

I guess that's it ^^

[erina]

Movie 1: ✩✩✩✩
Movie 2: ✩✩✩
Movie 3: ✩✩✩✩
Movie 4: ✩✩✩✩
Movie 5: ✩✩✩✩
Movie 6: ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 7: ✩✩✩
Movie 8: ✩✩✩
Movie 9: ✩✩✩✩
Movie 10: ✩✩✩
Movie 11: ✩✩
Movie 12: ✩✩✩
Movie 13: ✩✩✩
Movie 14: ✩✩✩
Movie 15: ✩✩
Movie 16: ✩✩
Movie 17: ✩✩✩

[private]

For me all of them are good but there are just better than them
+ = the best
Movie 1 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 2 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 3 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 4 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 5 : ✩✩✩✩✩+
Movie 6 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 7 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 8 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 9 : ✩✩✩✩ 1/2
Movie 10 :✩✩✩✩✩+
Movie 11 : ✩✩✩
Movie 12 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 13 : ✩✩✩✩✩+
Movie 14 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 15 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 16 : ✩✩✩✩ 1/2
Movie 17 : ✩✩✩✩✩+
Movie 18 : (Though I don't watch the movie yet seems the trailer is good and revealed something) ✩✩✩✩✩+
Basically for me all movies are good and for the last rank in Movie 11

[Hakuoyuki]

Movie 1 : ✩✩✩✩½
Movie 2 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 3 : ✩✩✩
Movie 4 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 5 : ✩✩✩✩✩
Movie 6 : ✩✩✩
Movie 7 : ✩✩½
Movie 8 : ✩✩✩✩½
Movie 9 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 10 : ✩✩✩
Movie 11 : ✩✩✩✩
Movie 12 : ✩✩✩½
Movie 13 : ✩✩✩✩½
Movie 14 : ✩✩✩
Movie 15 : ✩✩✩½
Movie 16 : ✩✩✩
Movie 17 : ✩✩✩½

[irishock]

1: ✩✩
2: ✩✩✩✩1/2
3: ✩✩✩✩1/2
4: ✩✩✩ (didn't like the end at all)
5: ✩✩✩✩1/2
6: ✩✩✩✩
7: ✩✩✩1/2 (first hour too slow)
8: ✩✩✩
9: ✩✩✩✩1/2 (last half-hour was gold)
10: ✩✩1/2
11: ✩
12: ✩1/2
13: ✩✩✩
14: ✩ (Jesus Christ.)
15: ✩✩1/2
16: ✩
17: ✩✩

Updated!

[Kor]

1: ✩✩
2: ✩✩✩✩3/4
3: ✩✩✩✩3/4
4: ✩✩✩ (didn't like the end at all)
5: ✩✩✩✩3/4
6: ✩✩✩✩1/4
7: ✩✩✩3/4 (first hour too slow)
8: ✩✩✩
9: ✩✩✩✩1/2 (last half-hour was gold)
10: ✩✩1/2
11: -✩
12: ✩1/2
13: ✩✩✩
14: -✩✩ (Jesus Christ.)
15: ✩✩1/2
16: ✩
17: ✩✩

Is negative grading really necessary? I mean, if one star is the lowest grade possible, giving something a negative grade doesn't really mean much.

[Kikiko]

Just more people unable to follow a pretty simple set of rules. Though I'd love to see their essay on why Movie 14 was worse than 11.

[Chekhov MacGuffin]

Is negative grading really necessary? I mean, if one star is the lowest grade possible, giving something a negative grade doesn't really mean much.

It won't matter when I tally the new responses. I round up or down to 0 or 5.

Just more people unable to follow a pretty simple set of rules. Though I'd love to see their essay on why Movie 14 was worse than 11.

That's a bit strong. I rated 11 and 14 equally, but I give the edge to 11. I prefer Sonoko-Ran friendship drama over Kaitou Kid drama and I think 11 was more coherent in terms of overall use of characters in the plot. The cases and climaxes (climaces?) were equally nutty IMHO.