Page 1 of 1
L VS Shinichi/Conan
Posted: May 22nd, 2010, 3:17 am
by khj_621
forgive me if there's already a thread like this... I'm too lazy to look but please vote!! For you.. who do you think is??
IMPORTANT: GIVE YOUR REASON!!!
Re: L VS Shinichi/Conan
Posted: May 22nd, 2010, 3:58 am
by kate_49
Re: L VS Shinichi/Conan
Posted: May 22nd, 2010, 6:36 am
by MAYSEVENTEEN
lol Umm actually I've never read Death Note before, but I just watched the live action movies 1 & 2 and L: Change The World ^^ The actors are cool :p hehehe
Well, to answer the question, I think L's level of intelligence might be more....coz he's elder (O.O!)
In solving cases, L has been involved with people from around the world and not only in Japan.
So yeah, he might be more experienced in that case.
As for Shinichi, he's a normal school boy (unlike L who is super weird
but cute).
Shinichi isn't really exagerately clever, which is kinda true for Gosho sensei's story. Whereas in Death Note, you see a lot of supernatural things (say, the shinigami

)
Gosho-sensei based his story on a more natural sense (with so many "evidences" from Science), so perhaps Shinichi might be a better detective that way ^^" (though I voted for L ;p)
Re: L VS Shinichi/Conan
Posted: May 22nd, 2010, 10:18 am
by Rellik
I think there is one major reason why Shinichi/Conan is the greatest:
Re: L VS Shinichi/Conan
Posted: May 22nd, 2010, 1:50 pm
by Akonyl
I think L could beat up Conan in a fight.
Re: L VS Shinichi/Conan
Posted: May 22nd, 2010, 6:00 pm
by Kleene Onigiri
Akonyl wrote:
I think L could beat up Conan in a fight.
I disagree. Conan would stun him with his watch or distract him with sweets
I voted for Shinichi/Conan.
Because for me Shinichi is a "real" detective. He uses the hints and clues to find out the murderer.
L is more like a tactician/strategist than a detective. He also uses hints/clues to find out who Kira is. But he mostly uses traps and mind tricks to lure kira out.
Although Shinichi/Conan uses some mind tricks and traps too especially to capture/find the BO, he still relies more on facts/clues.
Re: L VS Shinichi/Conan
Posted: May 22nd, 2010, 6:35 pm
by Akonyl
Kleene Onigiri wrote:
Akonyl wrote:
I think L could beat up Conan in a fight.
I disagree. Conan would stun him with his watch or distract him with sweets
I voted for Shinichi/Conan.
Because for me Shinichi is a "real" detective. He uses the hints and clues to find out the murderer.
L is more like a tactician/strategist than a detective. He also uses hints/clues to find out who Kira is. But he mostly uses traps and mind tricks to lure kira out.
Although Shinichi/Conan uses some mind tricks and traps too especially to capture/find the BO, he still relies more on facts/clues.
When I say "could beat Conan in a fight", I mean street rules, so no stun watch or super shoes or any of that crazy stuff.
I mean, if we're gonna allow gadgets L could just shoot him. You saw what L did to that prisoner, he got him killed! And why? Because he had a useful name. L is one
cold dude.
Re: L VS Shinichi/Conan
Posted: May 22nd, 2010, 7:15 pm
by scineram
Narumi Ayumu.
Re: L VS Shinichi/Conan
Posted: May 22nd, 2010, 7:31 pm
by Kleene Onigiri
Akonyl wrote:
Kleene Onigiri wrote:
Akonyl wrote:
I think L could beat up Conan in a fight.
I disagree. Conan would stun him with his watch or distract him with sweets
I voted for Shinichi/Conan.
Because for me Shinichi is a "real" detective. He uses the hints and clues to find out the murderer.
L is more like a tactician/strategist than a detective. He also uses hints/clues to find out who Kira is. But he mostly uses traps and mind tricks to lure kira out.
Although Shinichi/Conan uses some mind tricks and traps too especially to capture/find the BO, he still relies more on facts/clues.
When I say "could beat Conan in a fight", I mean street rules, so no stun watch or super shoes or any of that crazy stuff.
I mean, if we're gonna allow gadgets L could just shoot him. You saw what L did to that prisoner, he got him killed! And why? Because he had a useful name. L is one
cold dude.
Well if it's street rules it's unfair for conan, since he's small (as a kid). The only chance for conan is to headbutt and make a critical hit into L's crotch

He can't reach anything else ;p
Re: L VS Shinichi/Conan
Posted: May 22nd, 2010, 9:14 pm
by Girl19
Another L
vsShinichi/DN
vsDC thread/debate..
Oh well, once again, I'm going with
Shinichi, obviously.
Re: L VS Shinichi/Conan
Posted: May 22nd, 2010, 9:17 pm
by c-square
Shinichi/Conan!
Why?
Because...
Re: L VS Shinichi/Conan
Posted: May 22nd, 2010, 9:28 pm
by pofa
Kleene Onigiri wrote:
Akonyl wrote:
Kleene Onigiri wrote:
Akonyl wrote:
I think L could beat up Conan in a fight.
I disagree. Conan would stun him with his watch or distract him with sweets
I voted for Shinichi/Conan.
Because for me Shinichi is a "real" detective. He uses the hints and clues to find out the murderer.
L is more like a tactician/strategist than a detective. He also uses hints/clues to find out who Kira is. But he mostly uses traps and mind tricks to lure kira out.
Although Shinichi/Conan uses some mind tricks and traps too especially to capture/find the BO, he still relies more on facts/clues.
When I say "could beat Conan in a fight", I mean street rules, so no stun watch or super shoes or any of that crazy stuff.
I mean, if we're gonna allow gadgets L could just shoot him. You saw what L did to that prisoner, he got him killed! And why? Because he had a useful name. L is one
cold dude.
Well if it's street rules it's unfair for conan, since he's small (as a kid). The only chance for conan is to headbutt and make a critical hit into L's crotch

He can't reach anything else ;p
I say it's fair for Conan to have his gadgets, as long as L is provided with several Red Bulls prior to the fight.
Re: L VS Shinichi/Conan
Posted: May 23rd, 2010, 12:10 am
by Akonyl
pofa wrote:
Kleene Onigiri wrote:
Akonyl wrote:
Kleene Onigiri wrote:
Akonyl wrote:
I think L could beat up Conan in a fight.
I disagree. Conan would stun him with his watch or distract him with sweets
I voted for Shinichi/Conan.
Because for me Shinichi is a "real" detective. He uses the hints and clues to find out the murderer.
L is more like a tactician/strategist than a detective. He also uses hints/clues to find out who Kira is. But he mostly uses traps and mind tricks to lure kira out.
Although Shinichi/Conan uses some mind tricks and traps too especially to capture/find the BO, he still relies more on facts/clues.
When I say "could beat Conan in a fight", I mean street rules, so no stun watch or super shoes or any of that crazy stuff.
I mean, if we're gonna allow gadgets L could just shoot him. You saw what L did to that prisoner, he got him killed! And why? Because he had a useful name. L is one
cold dude.
Well if it's street rules it's unfair for conan, since he's small (as a kid). The only chance for conan is to headbutt and make a critical hit into L's crotch

He can't reach anything else ;p
I say it's fair for Conan to have his gadgets, as long as L is provided with several Red Bulls prior to the fight.
I'd allow this, as it'd effectively make him impervious to the anesthetic.
Re: L VS Shinichi/Conan
Posted: May 23rd, 2010, 1:09 am
by ranger
Big surprise that Conan wins in a DC forum right?
I voted for L though, we actually had this debate a while ago in the fave anime char thread.
Re: L VS Shinichi/Conan
Posted: May 23rd, 2010, 2:09 am
by Girl19
ranger wrote:
Big surprise that Conan wins in a DC forum right?
If Conan doesn't win in a non DC forum, it's not because most people think L is better, it's only because Death Note is more popular than Detective Conan and most people would know L but not recognize Conan. And we all know that popularity has nothing to do with quality.