wkd wrote:"Why did Conan tell Miyano Akemi his true identity? Any reason?
A: Because Conan thinks that person is going to die anyway. What if
Akemi is taken to the hospital and brought back to life in a miracle!!!
http://www.detectiveconanworld.com/foru ... ews/page-5
I read this in the old Gosho interviews, I know some of his answers are to be taken as sarcasm, but there's an interfering point with this particular answer of his which made me take all of this into consideration that is:
Gosho doesn't kill main or recurring characters with a harmless animus. He just revealed Akai's death to be faked, andSpoiler:Toichi to also be alive, regardless of how he didn't appear as the latter and Akemi, but he's a character whose highly valued.
Anyway, Akemi as we know appeared twice, when she died she wasn't expected to be of much value latter on in the series but then Haibara appeared and she was extremely missing her sister, and Akai was literally touched by her death, at least from our perspective as Gosho wants us to see it, however how would it appear if we changed the point we look at the events from a larger view. What if Akemi meant what was written in the P.S message to Akai? "If we could get away from the organization.." what was the rest of the message? Could she be still alive and waiting for him? It hit me when I read the file of her death again, Gin left her still hanging unlike his ruthlessness when it comes to killing, could it be a mistake made deliberately like the one he did when he supposedly killed Shinichi? With Gosho's words up in the interview I think it's possible. Of course when you read this you'll say that she was dead and Conan was at the scene and her face was covered and it was on the paper and news and all, but could it be that the FBI covered the tracks and made it seem like she's dead so they can grant her the Witness Protection Program? She won't be able to contact her companions after that and she'll hang on waiting for Shuichi to get the organization down. The most irrelevant point is that Conan and Ran were there in front of her supposed corpse and Conan didn't know about the FBI's involvement back then. Anyway, Gosho's interview stirred things up in my mind a bit, but do you think that's possible? Wouldn't it be great if Akemi is still alive?
Wakarimashita wrote:That's not a plot hole, that's the floating timeline for you.
Regarding your idea.
Sorry, but your idea isn't very plausible. Her corpse was retrieved and surely underwent autopsy: they probably matched her fingerprints on the police database and confirmed her identity. Maybe they did some more extensive identification methods to make sure it was the same person.
This thread's "theory" isn't such a "theory" but more like a wild hypothesis which cannot offer that any convincing proof. Akemi's death happened very early in the manga and was the trigger for Haibara wanting to leave the BO. Akemi didn't expect Gin to kill her despite that she succeeded in her mission.
Spimer wrote:I agree that Conan could tell there and then that she was dead. And the ambulance rushed in right after so they could confirm her death on the scene.
And I couldn't say that her death has "potential" but more like it has its effects and sequels.
Just because Haibara has flashbacks about her that doesn't need to mean anything more than recalling her.
Spimer wrote:Maybe Gosho kinda forgot what Akemi did in the files she'd appeared and didn't have time to go over them before writing the Haibara debut case.
Akemi was actually desperate back then to regain the money the accomplice had stolen to be able to get out of the BO. Conan didn't do much then, he was toying with the transmitter Agasa had given him.
Akemi only came back to the agency on a second time and they went straight to the hideout of the accomplice so there wasn't a chance to speak much. Conan didn't do much either.
For some reason Akemi didn't look nervous it in the flashback of Haibara's introduction case despite that she was supossed to be: maybe she was doing her best to try to not to make Haibara panic.
In my opinion that's hardly anything that indicates that she expected the end result. If Gosho had wanted her death to be a fake he'd given us clues time ago.
Let's not forget that he initially didn't expect so much time to pass between Akemi's death and Haibara's debut since she was foreshadowed already back then.
That her death also became a motivation for Akai to have revenge on Gin was surely thought of as he worked up Akai's character.
Tantei San wrote:Does anyone feel that it is possible for Akemi to come back as Rumi Wakasa to lure someone, besides the only reason she is trying to be together with conan is to get close to Haibara? Anyone.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 13 guests