Detective Conan 575-576 (The Alibi of the Black Dress) Discu

[kkslider5552000]

The discussion of Manga based Anime cases is pointless. You can CLAIM you never read them and still might have directly or otherwise know. If you want to continue playing your game, then please wait for a two part AO case. Then there is no way for you or anyone to know the ending. But this just does not make sense. I might was well make a thread like this for anime cases that have names and say I think YOU did it.

first of all who are you talking to


second of all, what are you talking about

third of all, why?

[sstimson]

As this case has allready been discussed in the Manga section why not discuss it there after the anime of the manga case happens. It by the way is here http://forums.dctp.ws/viewtopic.php?t=1655.0

[Akonyl]

The discussion of Manga based Anime cases is pointless. You can CLAIM you never read them and still might have directly or otherwise know. If you want to continue playing your game, then please wait for a two part AO case. Then there is no way for you or anyone to know the ending. But this just does not make sense. I might was well make a thread like this for anime cases that have names and say I think YOU did it.

well, yeah. But if anyone actually secretly reads manga cases just so they could pretend to solve the anime versions, then... yeah.

not to mention, 2-part AOs are usually pretty simple compared to manga-based cases.

[Chekhov MacGuffin]

The discussion of Manga based Anime cases is pointless. You can CLAIM you never read them and still might have directly or otherwise know. If you want to continue playing your game, then please wait for a two part AO case. Then there is no way for you or anyone to know the ending. But this just does not make sense. I might was well make a thread like this for anime cases that have names and say I think YOU did it.

Hello totally random and uncalled for personal attack... ಠ_ಠ

[pofa]

The discussion of Manga based Anime cases is pointless. You can CLAIM you never read them and still might have directly or otherwise know. If you want to continue playing your game, then please wait for a two part AO case. Then there is no way for you or anyone to know the ending. But this just does not make sense.

Was this directed at me because I said I'd never read the manga case for these episodes? I...haven't. Like, for real.

I might was well make a thread like this for anime cases that have names and say I think YOU did it.

I don't understand this part.

As this case has allready been discussed in the Manga section why not discuss it there after the anime of the manga case happens. It by the way is here http://forums.dctp.ws/viewtopic.php?t=1655.0

Often the anime episodes are slightly (or not so slightly) different from the manga cases on which they're based. Combining the two could cause confusion and potentially spoil people who don't read the manga. 

[Akonyl]

I might was well make a thread like this for anime cases that have names and say I think YOU did it.

I don't understand this part.

the point of his post is that there's no reason to discuss the anime versions of cases that were previously in the manga and talk about points you solved etc, because you could have easily read the manga case to know the case, and then post like you're discussing it in here just to seem smart. Thus, if you want to talk about anime cases, talk about AO cases which haven't been shown in any form before, so people know you aren't cheating.

That of course begs the question, why would people cheat anyway.

Also, is it just me or does Chekhov's most recent post have its own scroll bar?

[Chekhov MacGuffin]

The discussion of Manga based Anime cases is pointless. You can CLAIM you never read them and still might have directly or otherwise know. If you want to continue playing your game, then please wait for a two part AO case. Then there is no way for you or anyone to know the ending. But this just does not make sense.

Was this directed at me because I said I'd never read the manga case for these episodes? I...haven't. Like, for real.

Nah, I think it was directed at Kkslider. I could be wrong through. (Warning links to manga spoiler board) Kkslider criticized Sstimson's questionable theory for being "STUPID. HORRIBLE. AWFUL. ETC." Sstimson was probably feeling a bit vindictive. I'll leave it up to you to figure out if Kkslider's assessment was fair or not as I already have an opinion on the theory and want to avoid biasing neutral peoples.

Also, is it just me or does Chekhov's most recent post have its own scroll bar?

It does. Maybe my tendency towards walls of text has influenced the core programming of DCTP to tack on large bars to anything I type?

Or maybe it was the invisible emoticon...

[sstimson]

The discussion of Manga based Anime cases is pointless. You can CLAIM you never read them and still might have directly or otherwise know. If you want to continue playing your game, then please wait for a two part AO case. Then there is no way for you or anyone to know the ending. But this just does not make sense. I might was well make a thread like this for anime cases that have names and say I think YOU did it.

Hello totally random and uncalled for personal attack... ಠ_ಠ

Not a personal attack.I do read and watch both. And the major points are the same for both. I find it tasteless to discuss a case that was already discussed a year ago. If you use the Anime Ao and want to discuss those, I have not trouble with that.But even while saving they do not ( And I can not prove either way ), the answers are ON THE BOARD IN THE MANGA section. The spoiler are there for all to see and this board might need a Anime spolier section as well as an manga spoiler section. Is there any way to prove they never lurked into the spoiler section?

The discussion of Manga based Anime cases is pointless. You can CLAIM you never read them and still might have directly or otherwise know. If you want to continue playing your game, then please wait for a two part AO case. Then there is no way for you or anyone to know the ending. But this just does not make sense.

Was this directed at me because I said I'd never read the manga case for these episodes? I...haven't. Like, for real.

NO not at you

I might was well make a thread like this for anime cases that have names and say I think YOU did it.

I don't understand this part.

I would not do this : Start a Thread to discuess The July 3 Manga based cases :The Hint of Black Thirteen

As this case has allready been discussed in the Manga section why not discuss it there after the anime of the manga case happens. It by the way is here http://forums.dctp.ws/viewtopic.php?t=1655.0


Often the anime episodes are slightly (or not so slightly) different from the manga cases on which they're based. Combining the two could cause confusion and potentially spoil people who don't read the manga. 

There is no real confusion as I said earlier the major plot points are the same

I might was well make a thread like this for anime cases that have names and say I think YOU did it.

I don't understand this part.

the point of his post is that there's no reason to discuss the anime versions of cases that were previously in the manga and talk about points you solved etc, because you could have easily read the manga case to know the case, and then post like you're discussing it in here just to seem smart. Thus, if you want to talk about anime cases, talk about AO cases which haven't been shown in any form before, so people know you aren't cheating.

That of course begs the question, why would people cheat anyway.

Also, is it just me or does Chekhov's most recent post have its own scroll bar?

You Get me and my points

@chekhov : this is the second time he has does this. And I can in my mind eye see him lurk and post

[Conia]

Or maybe it was the invisible emoticon...

Indeed, it was the emoticon. When you highlight it, you can see that there a "blank" space down the emoticon that is also highlighted

[Akonyl]

I might was well make a thread like this for anime cases that have names and say I think YOU did it.

I don't understand this part.

the point of his post is that there's no reason to discuss the anime versions of cases that were previously in the manga and talk about points you solved etc, because you could have easily read the manga case to know the case, and then post like you're discussing it in here just to seem smart. Thus, if you want to talk about anime cases, talk about AO cases which haven't been shown in any form before, so people know you aren't cheating.

That of course begs the question, why would people cheat anyway.

Also, is it just me or does Chekhov's most recent post have its own scroll bar?

You Get me and my points

I understand your points, but note that that doesn't mean I agree with them in any way.

[Chekhov MacGuffin]

Sstimson, you should avoid the random personal attacks though. It's rather immature.

Or maybe it was the invisible emoticon...

Indeed, it was the emoticon. When you highlight it, you can see that there a "blank" space down the emoticon that is also highlighted

I wonder if I can exploit that with long posts? This could be a good thing.

[Akonyl]

Sstimson, you should avoid the random personal attacks though. It's rather immature.

Or maybe it was the invisible emoticon...

Indeed, it was the emoticon. When you highlight it, you can see that there a "blank" space down the emoticon that is also highlighted

I wonder if I can exploit that with long posts? This could be a good thing.

I didn't even notice that guy. I'm glad to see you use the best emoticon in the world, though.

[Conia]

I would not do this : Start a Thread to discuess The July 3 Manga based cases :The Hint of Black Thirteen

There's some people, like me, who only watch DC Anime, so having this discussion threads aren't pointless...

[Abs.]

sstimson, you can easily solve this problem for yourself by not reading these discussion threads.

Why take the fun of discussing manga-based anime episodes away from folk just because there may be a possibility of some losers trying to make themselves appear smart?  We might as well not discuss any cases, because someone here might actually work with Aoyama and know what's coming up, but post as if they didn't.

[Akonyl]

We might as well not discuss any cases, because someone here might actually work with Aoyama and know what's coming up, but post as if they didn't.

shhhhhh