Mafia - Round 9 (Town wins!)

[Detective Tommy]

Why does everyone think I'm B.O.? 

Well that's okay, now that I'm arrested that means I can't be lynched or APTXed right?  I can now tell you guys my role.. I'm Eisuke.  I probably got arrested for tricking someone.  Which means I've figured it out.

conia probably did the arrest, because he posted that in the thread before the results came out.

If this is the case, he's probably Vermouth, disguised as a police.  James Rye is another B.O., probably Akemi.  Detective Tommy is the real James Black.

Who died last night?  The only one who kept exposing conia's lies: pofa. 

I know I'm making sense, because I'm telling you the truth as I see it.  Akonyl help me out here.  This is the thing we discussed. 

If Abs is really Eisuke and Akonyl is not BO, and I'm James Black = 3 Town.
That leaves us 9 players to figure out who is BO and who isn't.

Don't try to be the victim here. Because the dream of Night 1 points you as Vodka.

It can be 1 of the 4 false ones.

[Kleene Onigiri]

This round is a lot of fun

[Kleene Onigiri]

Btw. all PMs are send.

[Conia]

Why does everyone think I'm B.O.? 

Well that's okay, now that I'm arrested that means I can't be lynched or APTXed right?  I can now tell you guys my role.. I'm Eisuke.  I probably got arrested for tricking someone.  Which means I've figured it out.

conia probably did the arrest, because he posted that in the thread before the results came out.

If this is the case, he's probably Vermouth, disguised as a police.  James Rye is another B.O., probably Akemi.  Detective Tommy is the real James Black.

Who died last night?  The only one who kept exposing conia's lies: pofa. 

I know I'm making sense, because I'm telling you the truth as I see it.  Akonyl help me out here.  This is the thing we discussed. 

If Abs is really Eisuke and Akonyl is not BO, and I'm James Black = 3 Town.
That leaves us 9 players to figure out who is BO and who isn't.

Or, Abs. is Vodka, Akonyl is BO and is helping him and you're Vermouth disguised.
But I have to say I pacted an investigation with James Rye and the result came out false.

Don't try to be the victim here. Because the dream of Night 1 points you as Vodka.

It can be 1 of the 4 false ones.

Look carefully, please.

[Detective Tommy]

This round is a lot of fun

Not really, if everyone just lynched James Rye from the beginning.
It would be a lot simpler!

Depending on how many BO members there are, we might lose tonight.

[Detective Tommy]

Why does everyone think I'm B.O.? 

Well that's okay, now that I'm arrested that means I can't be lynched or APTXed right?  I can now tell you guys my role.. I'm Eisuke.  I probably got arrested for tricking someone.  Which means I've figured it out.

conia probably did the arrest, because he posted that in the thread before the results came out.

If this is the case, he's probably Vermouth, disguised as a police.  James Rye is another B.O., probably Akemi.  Detective Tommy is the real James Black.

Who died last night?  The only one who kept exposing conia's lies: pofa. 

I know I'm making sense, because I'm telling you the truth as I see it.  Akonyl help me out here.  This is the thing we discussed. 

If Abs is really Eisuke and Akonyl is not BO, and I'm James Black = 3 Town.
That leaves us 9 players to figure out who is BO and who isn't.

Or, Abs. is Vodka, Akonyl is BO and is helping him and you're Vermouth disguised.
But I have to say I pacted an investigation with James Rye and the result came out false.

I am James Black, so wrong.
Why can't Ctu be Chiba or Holmes be Vermouth?

Ok... then post his investigation and result.
Pofa suspected that James Rye and Conia are working together. And Kain was Akemi.
That's why I checked if Kain stole the item.

[spoiler]Dream 1:
Sebolains(Shinichi) --> False
Abs.(Vodka) -->
Ctu(Chiba) -->
Holmes(Vermouth) -->
pofa(Sherry) --> False


Dream 2:
James Rye(Akai) -->
pofa(Anokata) -->
KID(Commi-Ninja) -->
Ctu(Satou) -->
KainTheVampire(Heiji) -->[/spoiler]

[Akonyl]

@Kleene: I'm sure most people read it, I know I did at least.

Thanks. But seems it's still not clear enough. Looking into the rule section could have shown my mistake easily :p

you being the GM, you'd think you'd know what was in it.

So, do I get also the title "Fail GM" now? XD T-T

I don't think there's been any GM that hasn't made a mistake (except me, because I blamed mine on conia).

Or, Abs. is Vodka, Akonyl is BO and is helping him and you're Vermouth disguised.
But I have to say I pacted an investigation with James Rye and the result came out false.

I'd just like to say that me and Abs are in no way in cahoots with one another, we were just talking about how to possibly prove or disprove Rye's possible Kid-ness.

Anyway, the winner for the round 3 dream is.... me! In the dream are:
KainTheVampire (townie) - currently checkin this out.
Abs(Heiji) - HURR I WONDER IF THIS IS TRUE?!?
xpon(townie) - an unfortunate townie not to have, if true.
Detective Tommy (Tequila) - all signs point to false, considering nobody's claimed frightening yet.
James Rye (Chianti) - we'll find out today, I suppose.

So, depending on James Rye's death, the only people left for truthiness are xpon and Kain.

[Detective Tommy]

Abs said he was Eisuke.
Detective Tommy is James Black.

I still think xpon is BO.
Not sure about Kain.
Which leaves James Rye. Remember the beginning clue said there is a sniper. Chianti = sniper.

Don't know if you still trust me after today, but I had a thought after reading that note Laurell left.

According to the thread and PMs I got from them, conia asked JR last night to special investigate whether KainTheVampire killed Schillok on Night 1. I still don't know why conia suspected Kain, or if conia's even trustworthy, but Kain's description in the note is "Kind."

I would have figured that meant "Ran," but Ran is dead. In the series, Haibara describes her sister Akemi as "kind." If Kain is BO, maybe she is Akemi. We know from Laurell that both thieves (Akemi and Kid) stole from him on the same night (I think it was Night 2, need to check and make sure about what he said).

Again, it's not a sure thing, just speculation. And given that nomemory was Sherry, it seems like something Kleene might do for fun--making the "real life" sisters, sisters in the game.

[Commi-Ninja]

So... anyone else want to revisit the lynching we almost had on Day 2?  Still seems like a good idea... But if we lynch the wrong one, we'll probably lose.  On the other hand, if this continues like it is, we'll lose anyway, it'll just take a little bit longer.

[Detective Tommy]

I would also let you guys know, if you guys lynch a TOWN today, you might lose the game.
I suggest all the town to lynch James Rye.

[Abs.]

Don't worry Akonyl the town won't lynch you.  You have already proven yourself to be irrefutably town, and you have at least one other person that can back that up.

I guess what's left is whether you believe me or conia 

[Commi-Ninja]

Don't worry Akonyl the town won't lynch you.  You have already proven yourself to be irrefutably town, and you have at least one other person that can back that up.

I guess what's left is whether you believe me or conia 

Considering you were just arrested...  Just sayin'.

[Conia]

Don't worry Akonyl the town won't lynch you.  You have already proven yourself to be irrefutably town, and you have at least one other person that can back that up.

I guess what's left is whether you believe me or conia  :-\

It's either me or the guy behind the bars.

I still have to hear word from James Rye. Until then, I don't have a lynching target.

[Detective Tommy]

Okay, I know for a fact that James Rye is BO and I will continue my vote for him.
Not sure what role...

I think Conia is Vermouth and took a police's role. That's why he can arrest.

You guys make a mistake in lynching, and it's all over.

[Holmes]

Nice! A Mafia was arrested, but why don´t we know the role I remember the role would be revealed if arrested, I guess I´m wrong.
So, "Who is James Black?" debate will start in any moment.