Mafia - Round 9 (Town wins!)

[Commi-Ninja]

Hum, so is tommy still the suspicious one or what

gettin kinda confused what with you talking about who PMed who what and such.

I have half an hour before I gotta sleep D:

That's where I'm at, too.  I'm so lost on who to vote for right now...

[pofa]

Well, the fact that you (conia) readily admitted that you didn't investigate JR on Night 1 after faced with Tommy's results actually points to your innocence more than your guilt--If you and JR were in league, I would have expected you to accuse Tommy of lying to protect him.

Maybe conia's town, but wrong about JR?  :P

[Abs.]

I've got to hand it to you, Detective Tommy.  You had me going there!  I was all set to lynch James Rye until I read this:

Also, My night1 action: Investigate Abs investigate Laurell (False)
I did this because he said he was going to.

OUTRAGEOUS FALSEHOOD.  (Clarification: I never said that to him.  See later posts for explanation of this fiasco.)

And I can not think of any reason for you to lie if you really are James Black, so really I'm confused again.  Perhaps someone has the black suitcase, and actually couldn't investigate on Night 1?  Hmm?

[Detective Tommy]

I say we lynch James Rye.
The fact that I knew Conia didn't investigate JR somehow prooves me being James Black.


And if James Rye is BO. Then you guys might get a lead.


Btw I'm on my iTouch and going to bed now.

[Akonyl]

Well, the fact that you (conia) readily admitted that you didn't investigate JR on Night 1 after faced with Tommy's results actually points to your innocence more than your guilt--If you and JR were in league, I would have expected you to accuse Tommy of lying to protect him.

Maybe conia's town, but wrong about JR?  :P

either way, we'll find out who the real JB is after today

And now Abs has committed himself to the cause against DT. So, if Detective Tommy *is* james black, then Abs is a BO (as he's claiming it was a blatant lie), and James Rye is a BO as well (as he's claiming James Black), and conia is suspcious as well then, with his protecting of Black.

so basically, if we kill tommy and he's a BO, we're in good shape. If we kill tommy and he isn't, then we have a lot of high suspects on our hands. So to me it looks like we should still lynch tommy unless someone else has a stronger opinion.

[Conia]

Well, the fact that you (conia) readily admitted that you didn't investigate JR on Night 1 after faced with Tommy's results actually points to your innocence more than your guilt--If you and JR were in league, I would have expected you to accuse Tommy of lying to protect him.

Maybe conia's town, but wrong about JR?  :P

I'd like everyone to believe that, but I should prove myself being a townie
As I've said, I trust James Rye due to deduction, not evidence. I could have made an investigation exchange on Night 2, but I couldn't, unvoluntary, do a thing. Strange thing is, James Rye knows A LOT of me, so me not being dead by now is really weird.

[Abs.]

@Akonyl CLARIFICATION: I was referring to Detective Tommy's claim "he said he was going to."  

I never said such a thing to Detective Tommy.

I knew I should have bolded that part when I quoted it.  

[Commi-Ninja]

Well, the fact that you (conia) readily admitted that you didn't investigate JR on Night 1 after faced with Tommy's results actually points to your innocence more than your guilt--If you and JR were in league, I would have expected you to accuse Tommy of lying to protect him.

Maybe conia's town, but wrong about JR?  :P

either way, we'll find out who the real JB is after today

And now Abs has committed himself to the cause against DT. So, if Detective Tommy *is* james black, then Abs is a BO (as he's claiming it was a blatant lie), and James Rye is a BO as well (as he's claiming James Black), and conia is suspcious as well then, with his protecting of Black.

so basically, if we kill tommy and he's a BO, we're in good shape. If we kill tommy and he isn't, then we have a lot of high suspects on our hands. So to me it looks like we should still lynch tommy unless someone else has a stronger opinion.

Not that it much matters right now, but wouldn't lynching James Rye have a similar effect?  If he really was James Black, then Detective Tommy would be lying, and we'd have a good BO suspect.  If he was a BO, we'd have one less of those to deal with.  The only difference between lynching the two of them really would be having Abs. and conia as suspects as well, I think.  Unless I've missed something.

[Detective Tommy]

I've got to hand it to you, Detective Tommy.  You had me going there!  I was all set to lynch James Rye (at least that way we'll know if conia is B.O. or not - it doesn't necessarily prove your innocence if he turns out to be B.O., mind you) until I read this:

Also, My night1 action: Investigate Abs investigate Laurell (False)
I did this because he said he was going to.

OUTRAGEOUS FALSEHOOD.

And I can not think of any reason for you to lie if you really are James Black, so really I'm confused again.  Perhaps someone has the black suitcase, and actually couldn't investigate on Night 1?  Hmm?

1) What did I say that was absolute falsehood?
Very early in the game you said "PM Kleene 'Abs investigate Laurell'"
why does you go back to the prep phase or night 1...
You might have been joking. But I checked it, and you didn't do that action...

Also... I did investigate that Night 1 and what I sAid night 2.
Idiots.

[Detective Tommy]

@Akonyl CLARIFICATION: I was referring to Detective Tommy's claim "he said he was going to." 

I never said such a thing to Detective Tommy.

I knew I should have bolded that part when I quoted it. 

you didn't say it to me. You said it on the thread.
I would look for it but I'm on my itouch.

Lynching JAmes Rye would help you all get a BO.
That is the difference.....


I proved I knew conia was lying before he admitted it.
Because I checked night 1 action on night 2.

[Conia]

I've got to hand it to you, Detective Tommy.  You had me going there!  I was all set to lynch James Rye (at least that way we'll know if conia is B.O. or not - it doesn't necessarily prove your innocence if he turns out to be B.O., mind you) until I read this:

Also, My night1 action: Investigate Abs investigate Laurell (False)
I did this because he said he was going to.

OUTRAGEOUS FALSEHOOD.

And I can not think of any reason for you to lie if you really are James Black, so really I'm confused again.  Perhaps someone has the black suitcase, and actually couldn't investigate on Night 1?  Hmm?

1) What did I say that was absolute falsehood?
Very early in the game you said "PM Kleene 'Abs investigate Laurell'"
why does you go back to the prep phase or night 1...
You might have been joking. But I checked it, and you didn't do that action...

facepalm anyone?

[Abs.]

1) What did I say that was absolute falsehood?
Very early in the game you said "PM Kleene 'Abs investigate Laurell'"
why does you go back to the prep phase or night 1...
You might have been joking. But I checked it, and you didn't do that action...

You've got to be kidding me.  Here is the post you're talking about

It's okay. They can investigate me if I'm an enemy or not.

PM Kleene
Investigate if Laurell is enemy
Send

I guess it wasn't obvious it was a joke?  

I can't tell if you're just lying to cover your tracks or if you honestly took that seriously.

[Detective Tommy]

I didn't know what else to investigate.
So I checked it, because maybe you could investigator...

[Detective Tommy]

Well, the fact that you (conia) readily admitted that you didn't investigate JR on Night 1 after faced with Tommy's results actually points to your innocence more than your guilt--If you and JR were in league, I would have expected you to accuse Tommy of lying to protect him.

Maybe conia's town, but wrong about JR?  :P

either way, we'll find out who the real JB is after today

And now Abs has committed himself to the cause against DT. So, if Detective Tommy *is* james black, then Abs is a BO (as he's claiming it was a blatant lie), and James Rye is a BO as well (as he's claiming James Black), and conia is suspcious as well then, with his protecting of Black.

so basically, if we kill tommy and he's a BO, we're in good shape. If we kill tommy and he isn't, then we have a lot of high suspects on our hands. So to me it looks like we should still lynch tommy unless someone else has a stronger opinion.

Yes you can lynch James Rye and I can die from APTX.
If I am James black, abs and conia would be suspects too

[Commi-Ninja]

I didn't know what else to investigate.
So I checked it, because maybe you could investigator...

Even so, that's nothing to attack him over.  A joke's a joke...