Mafia! Mafia! Mafia! Character Role Discussions

[Detective Tommy]

I think it's really sad to think that people would be cheating in a Mafia game played for fun on a Detective Conan forum.

Dead players can get the results at the end of the game, just like the alive players.

I agree, I would rather keep it fair to see the actual results and how good a player(s) is/are.
And I agree again that all information should be revealed at the end only.

[Kleene Onigiri]

I think it's really sad to think that people would be cheating in a Mafia game played for fun on a Detective Conan forum.

Dead players can get the results at the end of the game, just like the alive players.

I agree, I would rather keep it fair to see the actual results and how good a player(s) is/are.
And I agree again that all information should be revealed at the end only.

[Abs.]

::)

Are you rolling your eyes because you're in contact with me?    That doesn't count, we are talking about important GM stuff!    And baby-making

[Kleene Onigiri]

::)

Are you rolling your eyes because you're in contact with me?   :P  That doesn't count, we are talking about important GM stuff!   ;D  And baby-making

the ::) was on tommy. Because if I remember correctly after he died he PMed me and asked if he can know the roles in round 9. Oh, the irony ->

[Akonyl]

I'm torn about the revealing of information to dead people. On the one hand, it's interesting to see if you can find stuff out while dead, and possible cheating is bad, but man I so totally wanna know the roles D:

[Kleene Onigiri]

I'm torn about the revealing of information to dead people. On the one hand, it's interesting to see if you can find stuff out while dead, and possible cheating is bad, but man I so totally wanna know the roles D:

Yeah. People that survive would say "no to ghost talking"

And if they happen to die early later on I bet they will be like: Let the ghost talk too! (at least some would do that I bet)

[nomemory]

I'm torn about the revealing of information to dead people. On the one hand, it's interesting to see if you can find stuff out while dead, and possible cheating is bad, but man I so totally wanna know the roles D:

Yeah. People that survive would say "no to ghost talking"

And if they happen to die early later on I bet they will be like: Let the ghost talk too! (at least some would do that I bet)

I think ghost should always be allowed to talk, just as alive people. Except for info of course. Otherwise it should be a strict no offtopic rule for all but thats no fun D:

@Kleene: D: is really addicting

[Abs.]

Well my plan is to always get arrested, so... 

[Beastly]

btw.. we can learn better if we know who is BO and who is townie.. after we die

Horrible idea. Because someone can cheat and PM someone alive and give them answers.

I have the tradition of giving Akonyl my roles, what i did since like Round 6.(Since he die at night 1 and i feel bad for him, i dont kill him though, if im B.O. Now you got the clue, cause a lot of people will investigate if he kill Akonyl.

[Conia]

Just to be clear: I asked for less ghost talk because information was leaked. It is in the rules people, ghosts can't give info.

[Detective Tommy]

::)

Are you rolling your eyes because you're in contact with me?  :P  That doesn't count, we are talking about important GM stuff!  ;D  And baby-making

the ::) was on tommy. Because if I remember correctly after he died he PMed me and asked if he can know the roles in round 9. Oh, the irony ->

I didn't ask for the roles when I died. I asked if I could know what all your hints/clues meant.
Then when there were only 2 BO left, you asked me about who I thought was BO.

And I said Conia and xpon. You didn't tell me anything though.
But when you asked me who I thought the last BO was, I asked who. And you told me it was Ctu.
But I didn't PM anyone, because I wouldn't cheat like that.

[CTU]

::)

Are you rolling your eyes because you're in contact with me?  :P  That doesn't count, we are talking about important GM stuff!  ;D  And baby-making

the ::) was on tommy. Because if I remember correctly after he died he PMed me and asked if he can know the roles in round 9. Oh, the irony ->

You did to in this round

[Detective Tommy]

::)

Are you rolling your eyes because you're in contact with me?  :P  That doesn't count, we are talking about important GM stuff!  ;D  And baby-making

the ::) was on tommy. Because if I remember correctly after he died he PMed me and asked if he can know the roles in round 9. Oh, the irony ->

You did to in this round

Wtf, no I didn't. I did not ask you for anyone elses role.

[Conia]

::)

Are you rolling your eyes because you're in contact with me?   :P  That doesn't count, we are talking about important GM stuff!   ;D  And baby-making

the ::) was on tommy. Because if I remember correctly after he died he PMed me and asked if he can know the roles in round 9. Oh, the irony ->

You did to in this round

Wtf, no I didn't. I did not ask you for anyone elses role.

It was directed to Kleene.

[Detective Tommy]

::)

Are you rolling your eyes because you're in contact with me?  :P  That doesn't count, we are talking about important GM stuff!  ;D  And baby-making

the ::) was on tommy. Because if I remember correctly after he died he PMed me and asked if he can know the roles in round 9. Oh, the irony ->

You did to in this round

Wtf, no I didn't. I did not ask you for anyone elses role.

It was directed to Kleene.

Oh , sorry for my uncalled for reaction.
I didn't ask for any roles. But I did use people/roles in my questions of how things work (only as examples).


And I don't ever remember asking Kleene for someone's role.
I asked for the hints+explanation and then told her who I thought was BO.