Mafia! Mafia! Mafia! Character Role Discussions

[Abs.]

I say take away Nakamori's arrest ability except auto-arrest for actually disguised Pinched Faces and stealing.

[Dus]

Sounds like I good idea, since he only cares about Kid anyway and there are quite a few cops already.

[Akonyl]

We could make "Sherry" as a BO role actually, since she was a member. And we have akemi too. The role "Haibara" isn't a BO anymore.
Could also be the first BO role that is a teenager instead of an adult (yes, I know sherry is ~18, but still, can count as a teenager D:)

That would be useful, so that observe isn't as powerful (as it is, basically anything except for adult means a townie, aside from maybe a vermouth)

Though, it would also let the BO know that Haibara isn't in the game if Sherry is a BO role, unless you split em apart, which would be a bit odd.

Sounds nice :3 Not sure how future GMs like it XD

yeah, I could imagine GMs being like "oh man everything's balanced!" and then Anokata being like "gimme vodka, please" and they put vodka in in place of Pisco or something, making the BO more powerful than intended. But at the same time, it would help point out which roles needed to be made better (because they're always being removed), and would also make it less random how powerful the BO actually is.

[Dus]

We could make "Sherry" as a BO role actually, since she was a member. And we have akemi too. The role "Haibara" isn't a BO anymore.
Could also be the first BO role that is a teenager instead of an adult (yes, I know sherry is ~18, but still, can count as a teenager D:)

That would be useful, so that observe isn't as powerful (as it is, basically anything except for adult means a townie, aside from maybe a vermouth)

Though, it would also let the BO know that Haibara isn't in the game if Sherry is a BO role, unless you split em apart, which would be a bit odd.

I'm currently considering doing exactly that, weird as it may be.

[Kleene Onigiri]

I don't mind sherry and haibara in the game (if they are on different sides)

Imagine Sherry killing Haibara. Suicide?! D:

[Dus]

I don't mind sherry and haibara in the game (if they are on different sides)

Imagine Sherry killing Haibara. Suicide?! D:

Split personality.

[Abs.]

If either Sherry or Haibara die, they both die  >:D

[Dus]

If either Sherry or Haibara die, they both die  >:D

An interesting twist. I like that.

[Akonyl]

If either Sherry or Haibara die, they both die  >:D

what about akai/okiya/bourbon though? :V

And Anokata and Kogoro?

also, that makes me wonder if the BO would perform a blood sacrifice of Sherry at the beginning of the round ever, just to be rid of haibara.

[Dus]

Nothing is official about them so they count as separate characters for now, I guess.

[Eve]

I don't mind sherry and haibara in the game (if they are on different sides)

Imagine Sherry killing Haibara. Suicide?! D:

[Abs.]

also, that makes me wonder if the BO would perform a blood sacrifice of Sherry at the beginning of the round ever, just to be rid of haibara.

...Only to discover that Haibara wasn't in the game to begin with! 

[Dus]

Also goes the other way:
People get APTXed during the day and the town goes:
"Ok, we have no idea who the BO are, but we know which one of us is Ai, so lets just kill her."

[Abs.]

Also goes the other way:
People get APTXed during the day and the town goes:
"Ok, we have no idea who the BO are, but we know which one of us is Ai, so lets just kill her."

During the night, you mean

[PhoenixTears]

No, during the day would be right. Town can't kill at night but they can lynch Haibara during the day.

Edit: nevermind. I didnt read everything properly. /fail