Voting for Mini Mafia Changes

The home to DCTP Forum Mafia as well as any other type of random forum game that you can conjure up.
PT
Community Mad Scientist
User avatar

to cammel's bav we go!

Posts: 1731

Voting for Mini Mafia Changes

Postby PT » June 13th, 2014, 4:09 am

Mini Mafia Changes Voting Thread

Discussion thread is here.

UPDATE: Before placing any votes, please read THIS POST. Most things on this list seem to be pretty clearly decided, so we need to focus mainly on the things that are not quite as clear. Voting closes at 6PM EST/EDT Saturday, June 14.

Guidelines:

⇒ If a proposed change has 2 options, please vote for one (1) option.
⇒ If a proposed change has 3+ options, please vote for two (2) options and please note which would be your first choice.
⇒ If an option you are voting for has Sub-Options, please vote for one (1) Sub-Option.
⇒ If an option you are voting for has any Items, please answer them. (In most cases this will be YES or NO.)

Example:

If, for Pisco / Tequila, I choose option #3, I would then need to choose Sub-Option A or Sub-Option B and answer the Item that goes along with them. So my vote could be OPTION 3, SUB-OPTION B, NO.

You may change your vote if you like at anytime prior to when I close the voting on this. However, please have all votes in as soon as possible. I would like to close this by the end of Friday night (US time) or Saturday afternoon at the lastest.

Please consider each option you vote for carefully, including how it would affect the balance of the game and player interest in the role, as we want to keep this game as fun as possible for everyone. Thanks!




Anokata
OPTION 1. No change.
OPTION 2. Remove him from the game.
OPTION 3. Make him the same as Vermouth (except no scent and Not BO interrogation when not disguised).
OPTION 4. Make him similar to Forum Mafia: He will take on a town role that is not in the game (cannot be the one Vermouth or Kid is disguised as, cannot be Sonoko or Detective Boys or Yumi). He will essentially become that role, however he can be investigated as disguised as that role and it will come up TRUE. He is not susceptible to being Pinched or Arrested for the disguise.
ITEM I. Should he be allowed to become Conan or Haibara? YES / NO
ITEM II. Should he have a scent and BO interrogation no matter what, in order to be more easily found? YES / NO

Pisco / Tequila
OPTION 1. No change.
OPTION 2. Give Pisco Abduct + Frighten along with his regular Erase and remove Bribe. Remove Tequila.
SUB-OPTION A. Actions should be Abduct AND Frighten AND Erase.
SUB-OPTION B. Actions should be Abduct OR Frighten AND Erase (Abduct/Erase OR Frighten/Erase).
OPTION 3. Give Pisco Abduct + Frighten along with his regular Erase and remove Bribe. Have Tequila mirror Pisco.
SUB-OPTION A. Actions should be Abduct AND Frighten AND Erase
ITEM I. Should Pisco and Tequila be allowed in the same game? YES / NO
SUB-OPTION B. Actions should be Abduct OR Frighten AND Erase (Abduct/Erase OR Frighten/Erase).
ITEM I. Should Pisco and Tequila be allowed in the same game? YES / NO
OPTION 4. Give Pisco and Tequila Abduct, Fake, Frighten, Erase. (Mirror roles.) Remove Bribe.
SUB-OPTION A. Actions should be Fake AND Frighten AND Abduct OR Erase (Fake/Frighten/Abduct OR Fake/Frighten/Erase).
ITEM I. Should Pisco and Tequila be allowed in the same game? YES / NO
SUB-OPTION B. Actions should be Fake AND Erase AND Abduct OR Frighten (Fake/Erase/Abduct OR Fake/Erase/Frighten).
ITEM I. Should Pisco and Tequila be allowed in the same game? YES / NO
OPTION 5. Give Pisco Abduct/Frighten/Erase. Give Tequila Abduct/Frighten/Fake. Move Bribe x1 to the Black Suitcase.
SUB-OPTION A. They should be able to use Fake/Erase AND Abduct AND Frighten each night.
ITEM I. Should Pisco and Tequila be allowed in the same game? YES / NO
SUB-OPTION B. They should only be allowed to use Fake/Erase AND Abduct OR Frighten each night. (Fake/Erase+Abduct OR Fake/Erase+Frighten.)
ITEM I. Should Pisco and Tequila be allowed in the same game? YES / NO

Akemi
OPTION 1. No change.
OPTION 2. Give her Fake as a second Night action. Give her Follow as Day action. She would then be able to use Fake AND Steal at night.

Kujou
OPTION 1. No change.
OPTION 2. Remove her from the game.
OPTION 3. Have her as a mirror role to Eri. (Cross Examine OR Interrogate, Voice of Reason, Lawsuit)

Detective Boys
OPTION 1. No change.
OPTION 2. Remove them from the game.
OPTION 3. Remove them from the game temporarily while we figure out what to do with them.
OPTION 4. Separate them so that they are able to have a single DB in the game.
OPTION 5. Leave them as a group but give them each an action they can use independently from the others along with Identify (which would still be usable by only one per Day phase).
ITEM I. Suggest actions for them.

Kazuha / Haibara / Agasa / Araide
OPTION 1. No change.
OPTION 2. No change to Kazuha/Haibara/Agasa. Give Araide Voice of Reason.
OPTION 3. Remove Kazuha from the game. Give Haibara the Charm (renamed "Antidote"; it would not give a notification unless used up). Give Agasa Accompany.
ITEM I. Give Araide Voice of Reason? YES / NO
OPTION 4. Remove Araide from the game. No change to Agasa. Remove Charm from Kazuha - give to Haibara under name of "Antidote". Give Kazuha Heal.

Asami
OPTION 1. No change.
OPTION 2. Rename her to Sera. Give her headgear.

BoneBreak
OPTION 1. No change.
OPTION 2. Rename BoneBreak to SnipeGuard.
Last edited by PT on June 14th, 2014, 12:27 am, edited 5 times in total.
pofa wrote: I have never done a single thing wrong in mafia, never one lie or act of violence
PT
Community Mad Scientist
User avatar

to cammel's bav we go!

Posts: 1731

Re: Voting for Mini Mafia Changes

Postby PT » June 13th, 2014, 4:19 am

Anokata
1st Choice: OPTION 3.
2nd Choice: OPTION 2.

Pisco / Tequila
1st Choice: OPTION 4. SUB-OPTION B. NO.
2nd Choice: OPTION 3. SUB-OPTION B. NO.

Akemi
OPTION 2.

Kujou
1st Choice: OPTION 2.
2nd Choice: OPTION 3.

Detective Boys
1st Choice: OPTION 2.
2nd Choice: OPTION 3.

Kazuha / Haibara / Agasa / Araide
1st Choice: OPTION 4.
2nd Choice: OPTION 2.

Asami
OPTION 2.

BoneBreak
OPTION 2.
Last edited by PT on June 13th, 2014, 9:10 pm, edited 1 time in total.
pofa wrote: I have never done a single thing wrong in mafia, never one lie or act of violence
Jd-
DCTP Staff Member
User avatar
Posts: 6187

Re: Voting for Mini Mafia Changes

Postby Jd- » June 13th, 2014, 5:55 am

Anokata
1st Choice: OPTION 2 (Remove him)
2nd Choice: OPTION 4
(NO on ITEM I, YES on ITEM II.)

Pisco / Tequila
1st Choice: OPTION 2 (SUB OPTION B, to ensure balance)
2nd Choice: OPTION 3 (I misread OPTION 5 originally, so I'll be switching to 3 here. SUB-OPTION B, and NO they should not be allowed in the same game. That'd be mental.)

Akemi
OPTION 2 (Give her Follow for a Day action, should make things very interesting for her, for once!)

Kujou
1st Choice: OPTION 2 (Remove her)
2nd Choice: OPTION 3 (Mirror Eri, but I really hope we don't have to keep her)

Detective Boys
1st Choice: OPTION 2 (Remove them from the game)
2nd Choice: OPTION 3 (Remove them temporarily; I'm sure we can figure something out, but it's probably not happening in time for this revision)

Kazuha / Haibara / Agasa / Araide
1st Choice: OPTION 4 (Remove Araide, upgrade Kazuha to healer, help Haibara, leave Agasa alone. This will make things a lot more interesting on the whole)
2nd Choice: OPTION 3 (Remove Kazuha, give Araide Voice of Reason = YES).

Asami
OPTION 2 (Bring on Sera in her place)

BoneBreak
OPTION 2 (Change the name to SnipeGuard)
Kamite
User avatar

Just keep swimming. Just keep swimming.

Posts: 551

Re: Voting for Mini Mafia Changes

Postby Kamite » June 13th, 2014, 6:18 am

Anokata
1st Choice: OPTION 3.
2nd Choice: OPTION 4 No and No

Pisco / Tequila
1st Choice: OPTION 4. SUB-OPTION B. NO.
2nd Choice: OPTION 3. SUB-OPTION B. NO.

Akemi
OPTION 2.

Kujou
1st Choice: OPTION 1.
2nd Choice: OPTION 3.

Detective Boys
1st Choice: OPTION 4.
2nd Choice: OPTION 5. +1 Investigate Night

Kazuha / Haibara / Agasa / Araide
1st Choice: OPTION 4.
2nd Choice: OPTION 2.

Asami
OPTION 2.

BoneBreak
OPTION 2.
Kleene Onigiri
Community Rice Warrior
User avatar

*punches Akonyl*

Posts: 2476

Re: Voting for Mini Mafia Changes

Postby Kleene Onigiri » June 13th, 2014, 6:39 am

Anokata
[spoiler]OPTION 1. No change.
OPTION 2. Remove him from the game.
OPTION 3. Make him the same as Vermouth (except no scent and Not BO interrogation when not disguised).
OPTION 4. Make him similar to Forum Mafia: He will take on a town role that is not in the game (cannot be the one Vermouth or Kid is disguised as, cannot be Sonoko or Detective Boys or Yumi). He will essentially become that role, however he can be investigated as disguised as that role and it will come up TRUE. He is not susceptible to being Pinched or Arrested for the disguise.
ITEM I. Should he be allowed to become Conan or Haibara? YES / NO
ITEM II. Should he have a scent and BO interrogation no matter what, in order to be more easily found? YES / NO[/spoiler]
1st: OPTION 4
ITEM I: Yes
ITEM II: Yes

2nd: OPTION 3
ITEM I: Yes
ITEM II: Yes (when disguised, disguise-rules apply like for Vermouth too)


Pisco / Tequila
[spoiler]OPTION 1. No change.
OPTION 2. Give Pisco Abduct + Frighten along with his regular Erase and remove Bribe. Remove Tequila.
→ SUB-OPTION A. Actions should be Abduct AND Frighten AND Erase.
→ SUB-OPTION B. Actions should be Abduct OR Frighten AND Erase (Abduct/Erase OR Frighten/Erase).
OPTION 3. Give Pisco Abduct + Frighten along with his regular Erase and remove Bribe. Have Tequila mirror Pisco.
→ SUB-OPTION A. Actions should be Abduct AND Frighten AND Erase
√ ITEM I. Should Pisco and Tequila be allowed in the same game? YES / NO
→ SUB-OPTION B. Actions should be Abduct OR Frighten AND Erase (Abduct/Erase OR Frighten/Erase).
√ ITEM I. Should Pisco and Tequila be allowed in the same game? YES / NO
OPTION 4. Give Pisco and Tequila Abduct, Fake, Frighten, Erase. (Mirror roles.) Remove Bribe.
→ SUB-OPTION A. Actions should be Fake AND Frighten AND Abduct OR Erase (Fake/Frighten/Abduct OR Fake/Frighten/Erase).
√ ITEM I. Should Pisco and Tequila be allowed in the same game? YES / NO
→ SUB-OPTION B. Actions should be Fake AND Erase AND Abduct OR Frighten (Fake/Erase/Abduct OR Fake/Erase/Frighten).
√ ITEM I. Should Pisco and Tequila be allowed in the same game? YES / NO
OPTION 5. Give Pisco Abduct/Frighten/Erase. Give Tequila Abduct/Frighten/Fake. Move Bribe x1 to the Black Suitcase.
→ SUB-OPTION A. They should be able to use Fake/Erase AND Abduct AND Frighten each night.
√ ITEM I. Should Pisco and Tequila be allowed in the same game? YES / NO
→ SUB-OPTION B. They should only be allowed to use Fake/Erase AND Abduct OR Frighten each night. (Fake/Erase+Abduct OR Fake/Erase+Frighten.)
√ ITEM I. Should Pisco and Tequila be allowed in the same game? YES / NO[/spoiler]
1st: OPTION 5
SUB-OPTION B
Item I: no

2nd: OPTION 3
SUB-OPTION: B
Item I: no


Akemi
[spoiler]OPTION 1. No change.
OPTION 2. Give her Fake as a second Night action. Give her Follow as Day action. She would then be able to use Fake AND Steal at night.[/spoiler]
OPTION 2


Kujou
[spoiler][spoiler]OPTION 1. No change.
OPTION 2. Remove her from the game.
OPTION 3. Have her as a mirror role to Eri. (Cross Examine OR Interrogate, Voice of Reason, Lawsuit)[/spoiler][/spoiler]
OPTION 2

Detective Boys
[spoiler]OPTION 1. No change.
OPTION 2. Remove them from the game.
OPTION 3. Remove them from the game temporarily while we figure out what to do with them.
OPTION 4. Separate them so that they are able to have a single DB in the game.
OPTION 5. Leave them as a group but give them each an action they can use independently from the others along with Identify (which would still be usable by only one per Day phase).
ITEM I. Suggest actions for them.[/spoiler]
1st: OPTION 5
2nd: OPTION 4
ITEM I: Investigate 1/2, Observe, Detect, something similar to Betrayal?, Steal/Borrow (items returns again), First-Aid (first 5 actions are good for Identify. First Aid is good if you think your DB-ally is gonna die, but will still make your other DB injured)

Kazuha / Haibara / Agasa / Araide
[spoiler]OPTION 1. No change.
OPTION 2. No change to Kazuha/Haibara/Agasa. Give Araide Voice of Reason.
OPTION 3. Remove Kazuha from the game. Give Haibara the Charm (renamed "Antidote"; it would not give a notification unless used up).
ITEM I. Give Araide Voice of Reason? YES / NO
OPTION 4. Remove Araide from the game. No change to Agasa. Remove Charm from Kazuha - give to Haibara under name of "Antidote". Give Kazuha Heal.[/spoiler]
1st: OPTION 4
2nd: OPTION 2


Asami
[spoiler]OPTION 1. No change.
OPTION 2. Rename her to Sera. Give her headgear.[/spoiler]
OPTION 2

BoneBreak
[spoiler]OPTION 1. No change.
OPTION 2. Rename BoneBreak to SnipeGuard.[/quote][/spoiler]
OPTION 1
>:D
Image
Keyhole drawn by Yuri Iwamoto <3

Spoiler: Secret Santa gift from Commi-Ninja <3
A Black Organization Christmas Carol (need to fix the link)

3DS Friend Code: 4141 3202 3514

༼ つ ◕_◕ ༽つ Giff holidays
bash7353

部下の手柄は上司のもの
上司の失敗は部下の責任

Posts: 430

Re: Voting for Mini Mafia Changes

Postby bash7353 » June 13th, 2014, 10:17 am

Anokata
First Choice: Option 4; Item II, but not Item I.
Second Choice: Option 2.

Pisco / Tequila
Option 3; Sub-Option B; yes.

Akemi
Option 2.

Kujou
First Choice: Option 2.
Second Choice: Option 3.

Detective Boys
Option 2.

Kazuha / Haibara / Agasa / Araide
Option 3; Item I.

Asami
Option 2.

BoneBreak
Option 2.
"Vad ska jag annars vara?" - "Det vet jag inte. Det måste du svara på. Men om du släpper allt du tror att du måste, och frågar dig vad du vill... Vad vill du då?"
描いた夢は叶わないことの方が多い
秀れた人を羨んでは自分が嫌になる
浅い眠りに押し潰されそう夜もある
優しい隣人が陰で牙を向いていたり

惰性で観てたテレビ消すみたいに生きることを時々辞めたくなる

人生は苦痛ですか 成功が全てですか
僕はあなたにあなたに ただ逢いたいだけ
信じたい嘘 効かない薬 帰れないサヨナラ
叫べ叫べ叫べ   逢いたいだけ
cinnamoroll
User avatar

Making the world a sweeter place :)

Posts: 2111

Re: Voting for Mini Mafia Changes

Postby cinnamoroll » June 13th, 2014, 6:03 pm

Anokata
First choice: Option 4 (Item I = No Item II = Yes)
Second choice: Option 2


Pisco / Tequila
First choice: Option 3 (Sub-option B, No)
Second choice: Option 4 (sub-option B, No)


Akemi
Option 2


Kujou
First choice: Option 2
Second choice: Option 3


Detective Boys
First choice: Option 3
Second choice: Option 2


Kazuha / Haibara / Agasa / Araide
First choice: Option 4
Second choice: Option 3 (Item I, Yes)


Asami
Option 2[


BoneBreak
Option 2
Image
Spoiler: Awesome Christmas present from Kain <3
Image

Spoiler: KL's cute Christmas present ^^
Image

Spoiler: Cute Christmas present by Stoppy ^^
Image

Spoiler: PT <3
Image

Spoiler: Jeck's Frosty :3
Image
pofa
Community Savior
User avatar

Armchair sorcerey

Posts: 1187

Re: Voting for Mini Mafia Changes

Postby pofa » June 13th, 2014, 6:23 pm

Anokata
1st choice: Option 3
2nd choice: Option 2

Pisco / Tequila
First choice: Option 4, sub-option B.
Item 1: No
Second choice: Option 3, sub-option B.
Item 1: No

Akemi
Option 2

Kujou
First choice: Option 2
Second choice: Option 3

Detective Boys
First choice: Option 3
Second choice: Option 4

Kazuha / Haibara / Agasa / Araide
First choice: Option 4
Second choice: Option 3
Item 1: Yes

Asami
Option 2

BoneBreak
Option 2
ImageImageImage

Superman = Captain America > Aquaman = Hal Jordan > Wonder Woman > Barry Allen > Thor > Martian Manhunter > The Hulk > Wasp > Hawkeye > [power gap] > Iron Man = Batman > [power gap] > Hank Pym
Jecka
User avatar

I miss not waking up at 3 am every day

Posts: 3369

Contact:

Re: Voting for Mini Mafia Changes

Postby Jecka » June 13th, 2014, 6:27 pm

Anokata:
First Choice: Option 4; NO for Item I and Item II
Second Choice: Option 2

Pisco / Tequila:
1st:OPTION 2; SUB-OPTION B.
2nd: OPTION 5; SUB-OPTION B; ITEM I: No

Akemi
OPTION 1

Kujou
OPTION 2

Detective Boys
1st: OPTION 3
2nd: OPTION 2

Kazuha / Haibara / Agasa / Araide
1st: OPTION 4
2nd: OPTION 2

Asami
OPTION 1

BoneBreak
OPTION 2
3DS FC: 1435-4098-2557
Spoiler: Yay Nini! \o/
Image

Usa-chan Man wrote: I am a rabbit, but at the same time, I am not.
Jecka: Those damn beavers
*Jecka sobs
Slider: Those DAM beavers? :V
Jecka: Slider no

Image
Paix672
Posts: 249

Re: Voting for Mini Mafia Changes

Postby Paix672 » June 13th, 2014, 6:56 pm

Anokata
First choice: Option 4
Item I: Yes
Item II: No
Second choice: Option 3

Pisco / Tequila
First choice: Option 4, sub-option B.
Item I: No
Second choice: Option 3, sub-option B.
Item I: No

Akemi
Option 2

Kujou
First choice: Option 2
Second choice: Option 3

Detective Boys
First choice: Option 4
Second choice: Option 3

Kazuha / Haibara / Agasa / Araide
First choice: Option 3
Item I: Yes
Second choice: Option 4

Asami
Option 2

BoneBreak
Option 2
Last edited by Paix672 on June 13th, 2014, 9:53 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Conia
Yurikochan's Husband
User avatar

Conan Shuuichi

Posts: 5181

Re: Voting for Mini Mafia Changes

Postby Conia » June 13th, 2014, 8:40 pm

Anokata
OPTION 4
ITEM I. Should he be allowed to become Conan or Haibara? YES / NO
ITEM II. Should he have a scent and BO interrogation no matter what, in order to be more easily found? YES / NO

Pisco / Tequila
OPTION 5.
SUB-OPTION B. They should only be allowed to use Fake/Erase AND Abduct OR Frighten each night. (Fake/Erase+Abduct OR Fake/Erase+Frighten.)
ITEM I. Should Pisco and Tequila be allowed in the same game? YES / NO

Akemi
OPTION 1. No change.

Kujou
OPTION 3. Have her as a mirror role to Eri. (Cross Examine OR Interrogate, Voice of Reason, Lawsuit)

Detective Boys
OPTION 4. Separate them so that they are able to have a single DB in the game.

Kazuha / Haibara / Agasa / Araide
OPTION 2. No change to Kazuha/Haibara/Agasa. Give Araide Voice of Reason.
ITEM I. Give Araide Voice of Reason? YES / NO

Asami
OPTION 1. No change.

BoneBreak
OPTION 2. Rename BoneBreak to SnipeGuard.
Image
PT
Community Mad Scientist
User avatar

to cammel's bav we go!

Posts: 1731

Re: Voting for Mini Mafia Changes

Postby PT » June 13th, 2014, 9:04 pm

I am posting these votes on behalf of Yurikochan.

Anokata
1st Choice: OPTION 3.
2nd Choice: OPTION 4. Item I: NO; Item II: YES

Pisco / Tequila
1st Choice: OPTION 4. SUB-OPTION A. NO.
2nd Choice: OPTION 3. SUB-OPTION B. NO.

Akemi
OPTION 1.

Kujou
1st Choice: OPTION 3.
2nd Choice: OPTION 2.

Detective Boys
1st Choice: OPTION 4.
2nd Choice: OPTION 3.

Kazuha / Haibara / Agasa / Araide
1st Choice: OPTION 4.
2nd Choice: OPTION 2.

Asami
OPTION 2.

BoneBreak
OPTION 2.
pofa wrote: I have never done a single thing wrong in mafia, never one lie or act of violence
Raiden
User avatar

~If you gimme a smile, I'm on your side. Tomorrow we'll be alright~

Posts: 645

Contact:

Re: Voting for Mini Mafia Changes

Postby Raiden » June 13th, 2014, 10:38 pm

Anokata
OPTION 4.
On answer to Item #1: NO and Item #2: YES

Pisco / Tequila
...the Fake Ability is a package deal only? It's either Tequila or no Faking stuff for Pisco? I object to that! :P

I say: Give Pisco Fake + Abduct + Frighten along with his regular Erase and remove Bribe. Remove Tequila.
1st Choice: OPTION 2. → SUB-OPTION C: Actions should be Fake AND Erase AND Abduct OR Frighten (Fake/Erase/Abduct OR Fake/Erase/Frighten).
Else; if the Fake ability is forbidden for Pisco, I'll go with...
2nd Choice: OPTION 2. → SUB-OPTION B: Actions should be Abduct OR Frighten AND Erase (Abduct/Erase OR Frighten/Erase).

Akemi
OPTION 2. I love her regardless of what happens, but I think she desperately needs an upgrade. She pulled the shortest straw in the Ability Department for Thieves (ADT) the first time around...and KID definitely came out as the winner of the two since he got his disguises. :V

Kujou
1st Choice: OPTION 2.
2nd Choice: OPTION 3.

Detective Boys
1st Choice: OPTION 3.
2nd Choice: OPTION 5. √ ITEM I: Observe, First Aid, & Borrow as per Kleene's suggestion; functions as Steal but item is delivered back to the target?

Kazuha / Haibara / Agasa / Araide
1st Choice: OPTION 4. (Note the addition written in red marker) Remove Araide from the game. No change to Agasa. Remove Charm from Kazuha - give to Haibara under name of "Antidote"; it will not give a notification unless used up. Give Kazuha Heal.
2nd Choice: OPTION 3. √ ITEM I: YES.

Asami
OPTION 2.

BoneBreak
I'll sit on the fence on this one and lean toward the majority. To me it's not that big a deal one way or the other. *shrugs*

I'm Switzerland! o/
3DS FC:2809 8617 8608
“Tea is the magic key to the vault where my brain is kept.” ― Frances Hardinge
“If you are cold, tea will warm you;
if you are too heated, it will cool you;
If you are depressed, it will cheer you;
If you are excited, it will calm you.”
― William Ewart Gladstone



Image
Image
Spoiler:
Image
Image
PT
Community Mad Scientist
User avatar

to cammel's bav we go!

Posts: 1731

Re: Voting for Mini Mafia Changes

Postby PT » June 14th, 2014, 12:13 am

IMPORTANT UPDATE

I've tallied what people have voted so far (giving 2pts for First Choice and 1pt for Second Choice; 1 point for each sub-option and item), and most changes have a pretty distinct winner, but there are a few that are tied that I would like to have people vote on once more (with narrowed options). Here are what the stats look like:

Anokata
Option 1: 0 points.
Option 2: 7 points. [First: Jd-] [Second: PT, bash, cinna, pofa, Jecka]
Option 3: 10 points. [First: PT, Kamite, pofa, Yuriko] [Second: Kleene, Paix]
Option 4: 17 points. [First: Kleene, bash, cinna, Jecka, Paix, Conia, Raiden] [Second: Jd-, Kamite, Yuriko]
(However, I set up a re-poll for this, as the Items received tie/close votes.)

Pisco / Tequila
Option 1: 0 points.
Option 2: 6 points. [First: Jd-, Jecka, Raiden] [Second: N/A]
Option 3: 11 points. [First: bash, cinna] [Second: PT, Jd-, Kamite, Kleene, pofa, Paix, Yuriko]
Option 4: 11 points. [First: PT, Kamite, pofa, Paix, Yuriko] [Second: cinna]
Option 5: 5 points. [First: Kleene, Conia] [Second: Jecka]
(Will re-poll for Options 3 & 4)

Akemi
Option 1: 6 points. [Jecka, Conia, Yuriko]
Option 2: 18 points. [PT, Jd-, Kamite, Kleene, bash, cinna, pofa, Paix, Raiden]

Kujou
Option 1: 2 points. [First: Kamite] [Second: N/A]
Option 2: 19 points. [First: PT, Jd-, Kleene, bash, cinna, pofa, Jecka, Paix, Raiden] [Second: Yuriko]
Option 3: 12 points. [First: Yuriko] [Second: PT, Jd-, Kamite, bash, cinna, pofa, Paix, Conia, Raiden]

Detective Boys
Option 1: 0 points.
Option 2: 8 points. [First: PT, Jd-, bash] [Second: cinna, Jecka]
Option 3: 12 points. [First: cinna, pofa, Jecka, Raiden] [Second: PT, Jd-, Paix, Yuriko]
Option 4: 10 points. [First: Kamite, Paix, Conia, Yuriko] [Second: Kleene, pofa]
Option 5: 4 points. [First: Kleene] [Second: Kamite, Raiden]
(Will re-poll for Options 3 & 4)

Kazuha / Haibara / Agasa / Araide
Option 1: 0 points.
Option 2: 7 points. [First: Conia] [Second: PT, Kamite, Kleene, Jecka, Yuriko]
Option 3: 8 points. [First: bash, Paix] [Second: Jd-, cinna, pofa, Raiden]
Option 4: 19 points. [First: PT, Jd-, Kamite, Kleene, cinna, pofa, Jecka, Yuriko, Raiden] [Second: Paix]

Asami
Option 1: 4 points. [Jecka, Conia]
Option 2: 20 points. [PT, Jd-, Kamite, Kleene, bash, cinna, pofa, Paix, Yuriko, Raiden]

BoneBreak
Option 1: 2 points. [Kleene]
Option 2: 20 points. [PT, Jd-, Kamite, bash, cinna, pofa, Jecka, Paix, Conia, Yuriko]




PLEASE RE-VOTE ON THE FOLLOWING THINGS

Voting closes at 6PM EST/EDT on Saturday, June 14.

Anokata (Please answer YES or NO for the Items)
OPTION 4. Make him similar to Forum Mafia: He will take on a town role that is not in the game (cannot be the one Vermouth or Kid is disguised as, cannot be Sonoko or Detective Boys or Yumi). He will essentially become that role, however he can be investigated as disguised as that role and it will come up TRUE. He is not susceptible to being Pinched or Arrested for the disguise.
ITEM I. Should he be allowed to become Conan or Haibara? YES / NO
ITEM II. Should he have a scent and BO interrogation no matter what, in order to be more easily found? YES / NO


Pisco / Tequila (Please choose 1 option and 1 corresponding sub-option and answer the corresponding Item)
OPTION 3. Give Pisco Abduct + Frighten along with his regular Erase and remove Bribe. Have Tequila mirror Pisco.
SUB-OPTION A. Actions should be Abduct AND Frighten AND Erase
ITEM I. Should Pisco and Tequila be allowed in the same game? YES / NO
SUB-OPTION B. Actions should be Abduct OR Frighten AND Erase (Abduct/Erase OR Frighten/Erase).
ITEM I. Should Pisco and Tequila be allowed in the same game? YES / NO
OPTION 4. Give Pisco and Tequila Abduct, Fake, Frighten, Erase. (Mirror roles.) Remove Bribe.
SUB-OPTION A. Actions should be Fake AND Frighten AND Abduct OR Erase (Fake/Frighten/Abduct OR Fake/Frighten/Erase).
ITEM I. Should Pisco and Tequila be allowed in the same game? YES / NO
SUB-OPTION B. Actions should be Fake AND Erase AND Abduct OR Frighten (Fake/Erase/Abduct OR Fake/Erase/Frighten).
ITEM I. Should Pisco and Tequila be allowed in the same game? YES / NO


Detective Boys (Please choose 1 option)
OPTION 3. Remove them from the game temporarily while we figure out what to do with them.
OPTION 4. Separate them so that they are able to have a single DB in the game.
pofa wrote: I have never done a single thing wrong in mafia, never one lie or act of violence
PT
Community Mad Scientist
User avatar

to cammel's bav we go!

Posts: 1731

Re: Voting for Mini Mafia Changes

Postby PT » June 14th, 2014, 12:25 am

Anokata
ITEM I. Should he be allowed to become Conan or Haibara? NO
ITEM II. Should he have a scent and BO interrogation no matter what, in order to be more easily found? YES

Pisco / Tequila
Option 4. Sub-Option B. No.

Detective Boys
Option 3.
pofa wrote: I have never done a single thing wrong in mafia, never one lie or act of violence

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 23 guests