Detective Tommy wrote:
Just to help you out: Disguise means if the role can be disguised as.
Yes: Vermouth/Kid can disguise as this role.
No: Vermouth/Kid cannot disguise as this role.
Both Contact and SOS have interesting roles.
Not sure if she shouldn't have a day/night action. Maybe Investigate 1?
Oh, no, I knew that. The question was if Vermouth could disguise as her or not. Personally, I'd say not, but that's just me.
Considering her spy role, that would be the only night action I'd choose.
PS: Double check SOS, I just added the change I forgot to add to the original.
Last edited by Edogawa4869 on August 20th, 2010, 2:02 am, edited 1 time in total.
Yugi Moto wrote:Oh, shipping is where you take two characters from a T.V. show, who aren't romantically involved in any shape or form, and then you force them to become a lesbian couple by drawing vivid and gratuitous fan art of them for about six months, before you move on to some other show. Lather, rinse, repeat.
Detective Tommy wrote:
Just to help you out: Disguise means if the role can be disguised as.
Yes: Vermouth/Kid can disguise as this role.
No: Vermouth/Kid cannot disguise as this role.
Both Contact and SOS have interesting roles.
Not sure if she shouldn't have a day/night action. Maybe Investigate 1?
Oh, no, I knew that. The question was if Vermouth could disguise as her or not. Personally, I'd say not, but that's just me.
Considering her spy role, that would be the only night action I'd choose.
PS: Double check SOS, I just added the change I forgot to add to the original.
No, she should not have a disguise at all.
Or else Vermouth would alliance with FBI.
"Well, a child's curiosity and a detective's spirit of inquiry... Do have much in common, after all..." - Tooru Amuro
Detective Tommy wrote:
Hmmm, I'm not sure if the player not receiving a result is a good thing.
What's wrong with that? BTW, I haven't decided whether the hint would reveal the player or the role...
Yugi Moto wrote:Oh, shipping is where you take two characters from a T.V. show, who aren't romantically involved in any shape or form, and then you force them to become a lesbian couple by drawing vivid and gratuitous fan art of them for about six months, before you move on to some other show. Lather, rinse, repeat.
Detective Tommy wrote:
Hmmm, I'm not sure if the player not receiving a result is a good thing.
What's wrong with that? BTW, I haven't decided whether the hint would reveal the player or the role...
It should reveal both
Haha, nice try... That would be too easy. Unless the clue was very hard, that is.
Yugi Moto wrote:Oh, shipping is where you take two characters from a T.V. show, who aren't romantically involved in any shape or form, and then you force them to become a lesbian couple by drawing vivid and gratuitous fan art of them for about six months, before you move on to some other show. Lather, rinse, repeat.
Detective Tommy wrote:
Hmmm, I'm not sure if the player not receiving a result is a good thing.
What's wrong with that? BTW, I haven't decided whether the hint would reveal the player or the role...
It should reveal both
Haha, nice try... That would be too easy. Unless the clue was very hard, that is.
Yeah, probably the player.
That might be too powerful in someone else's opinion.
But isn't the player all that one needs to make an arrest? (Ex. Detective Tommy Killed Abs. on Night 4 instead of Irish Killed 1412 on Night 4)
Yugi Moto wrote:Oh, shipping is where you take two characters from a T.V. show, who aren't romantically involved in any shape or form, and then you force them to become a lesbian couple by drawing vivid and gratuitous fan art of them for about six months, before you move on to some other show. Lather, rinse, repeat.
Detective Tommy wrote:
Hmmm, I'm not sure if the player not receiving a result is a good thing.
What's wrong with that? BTW, I haven't decided whether the hint would reveal the player or the role...
It should reveal both
Haha, nice try... That would be too easy. Unless the clue was very hard, that is.
Yeah, probably the player.
That might be too powerful in someone else's opinion.
But isn't the player all that one needs to make an arrest? (Ex. Detective Tommy Killed Abs. on Night 4 instead of Irish Killed 1412 on Night 4)
Yes, so knowing the exact player that did the killing might be... too powerful in someone's eyes.
So, we're agreed: Role it is, then?
Yugi Moto wrote:Oh, shipping is where you take two characters from a T.V. show, who aren't romantically involved in any shape or form, and then you force them to become a lesbian couple by drawing vivid and gratuitous fan art of them for about six months, before you move on to some other show. Lather, rinse, repeat.
Well if she's restricted to just those two actions (Contact and SOS) I see no problem with revealing the player's identity. It's similar to being Sonoko's friend, except that the two parts of that are broken up (knowing the identity // giving out the notice)
It should also work like Sonoko's friend in that it would not work in the event of a sniper
Edogawa4869 wrote:
So, we're agreed: Role it is, then?
No, that makes her character too weak.
I guess the player would be better.
Abs. wrote:
Well if she's restricted to just those two actions (Contact and SOS) I see no problem with revealing the player's identity. It's similar to being Sonoko's friend, except that the two parts of that are broken up (knowing the identity // giving out the notice)
It should also work like Sonoko's friend in that it would not work in the event of a sniper
I agree about the sniper part.
So what are her abilities?
- Knowing what BO roles are in the game.
- Contact
- SOS
- Investigation 1?
"Well, a child's curiosity and a detective's spirit of inquiry... Do have much in common, after all..." - Tooru Amuro
Edogawa4869 wrote:
So, we're agreed: Role it is, then?
No, that makes her character too weak.
I guess the player would be better.
Abs. wrote:
Well if she's restricted to just those two actions (Contact and SOS) I see no problem with revealing the player's identity. It's similar to being Sonoko's friend, except that the two parts of that are broken up (knowing the identity // giving out the notice)
It should also work like Sonoko's friend in that it would not work in the event of a sniper
I agree about the sniper part.
So what are her abilities?
- Knowing what BO roles are in the game.
- Contact
- SOS
- Investigation 1?
That sounds about right, provided Abs. has no objections to Investigation 1...
Yugi Moto wrote:Oh, shipping is where you take two characters from a T.V. show, who aren't romantically involved in any shape or form, and then you force them to become a lesbian couple by drawing vivid and gratuitous fan art of them for about six months, before you move on to some other show. Lather, rinse, repeat.
Edogawa4869 wrote:
So, we're agreed: Role it is, then?
No, that makes her character too weak.
I guess the player would be better.
Abs. wrote:
Well if she's restricted to just those two actions (Contact and SOS) I see no problem with revealing the player's identity. It's similar to being Sonoko's friend, except that the two parts of that are broken up (knowing the identity // giving out the notice)
It should also work like Sonoko's friend in that it would not work in the event of a sniper
I agree about the sniper part.
So what are her abilities?
- Knowing what BO roles are in the game.
- Contact
- SOS
- Investigation 1?
That sounds about right, provided Abs. has no objections to Investigation 1...
3 Abilities, and 1 Special Rule.
Sounds okay... People might consider her as overpowering.
"Well, a child's curiosity and a detective's spirit of inquiry... Do have much in common, after all..." - Tooru Amuro
